A Piece of Cake

484 N Madison Ave, Greenwood
(317) 887-2253

Recent Reviews

Jill D.

Amazing service. I walked in last minute to get a cake for our twins birthday. They designed the cake in 20 minutes.

Matthew Ambs

Great service! Great cakes!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jake Lashbrooks

We ordered a gender reveal cake from here and it turned out so good! Everyone loved it and we even had leftovers. Will be coming here more

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shelley Lambert

A big thank you to A Piece of Cake for the beautiful “watermelon” themed cake. The cake was for a 1-year old birthday party and the theme was “One in a Melon.” The cake created look better than the picture we provided. Not only did it look beautiful but it tasted delicious. The bakery provided prompt and efficient communications to order the cake and confirm. The cake was also reasonably priced. I would definitely recommend A Piece if Cake.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Miranda Voehringer

Definitely recommend this bakery! The cake looked great and tasted even better!! I was shocked by how reasonable the price was for a custom cake. Very friendly workers, easy to order and pickup. Will be using again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

JD COLE

This bakery deserves a round of applause. My little girl wanted a Barbie cake, and they delivered exactly what she wanted down to the detail of the doll. The lady at the front is super sweet and makes you feel like an old friend. Thank you so much. You have a lifetime customer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Trash Cake White Cake with Vanilla Icing

Sophie P.

Try the cake trash! I discovered this bakery because I read that they sell leftover cake and frosting from whatever they baked that day. The flavors and textures were great, so I ordered my birthday cake there. I showed the lady some photos of fairly elaborate cakes. I said "it doesn't have to be THIS fancy, but I like lots of decorative borders." She said "which photo do you like the best?" I showed her the fanciest one. She said "yeah, we can do that!" And they did not disappoint!! It was absolutely stunning. As the kids say, "they left NO crumbs!" (They gave 110%)

Linda Hanks

I absolutely loved getting birthday cakes here for my family's celebrations. The chocolate cake has a perfect balance of sweetness and the buttercream icing is very tasty. As you can see in the photo, they are very talented with designs. I highly recommend using this bakery for your next celebration with cake.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Danielle Dennis

Do you only take so many orders for Thanksgiving? Is there a cutoff date to order? I ask because I left a message on Monday to order a cake for Thanksgiving and did not receive a call back. If this is the case, you could post your instructions on Facebook or your website. If I had been able to look at Facebook to see that it wasn't a possibility, I wouldn't have even called. Update 11/20/23: Sorry don't know who you called but I do not have you on my call log or in my visual voicemail.

Charli Downton

We used a piece of cake for our wedding cupcakes - they were gone by the end of the night and everyone loved them! The staff was also wonderful to work with!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeff Whitlock

This place is amazing! My daughter is allergic to eggs and they always take extra precautions from taking the order to preparing the cake. Everyone always says how good the cakes are at birthday parties!Absolutely recommend this place for anyone looking for cakes!

Little Red

10/10! 5 stars! I have bought several cakes from this business and it's fantastic every time! I recently got a banana flavored frankenstein cake for my birthday! The taste was beyond amazing! It looked so fun! And they are very affordable.

Denise Ford

They made our vow renewal cake exactly the way I wanted and it was more beautiful when we picked it up. Definitely will do my future event cakes with them!

Heather Spaw

Went in to place a cake order based on a recommendation I had gotten and while I was there at least 8 people came in to pick up orders. So it must amazing.

Megan Coffey

My first time trying out A Piece Of Cake. I had a vague idea of what I wanted and a pintrest picture. It turned out beautifully for our baby boys 1st heavenly birthday AND it tasted amazing! Will definitely be back. Thank you so much!!❤️

Load More