South of Chicago has the best combo I have had outside of Chicago. The food is so good I dont even miss my home state of Illinois. The service is great and the atmosphere really feels like a Chicago diner. Go get a cheesey beef and sausage combo with hot peppers. Itll change your life.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Beef & Sausage Combo
Kelly C.
We've tried a lot of pizza joints around our house, and this has definitely become one of our go-to choices. I'm a sandwich girl, and I think the bread is important, and that is the primary reason I like this place. They have very good French-style bread they use for sandwiches, which then is toasted and crispy. The hot ham and cheese is delicious. Sandwiches come with chips and a pickle. The pizza is neither thin crust nor thick crust, it is somewhere in between, but it is tasty and filling. My husband gets a large and it can feed him for a few meals. We also really like the breadsticks, which are well-seasoned, soft, and have a variety of sauce choices. If you're looking for solid pizza take out, this is a good Greenwood option.
Roy Kidd
Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
beth chesser
It was our first time stopping here. It was Saturday afternoon and the dining room was steady. The gal who took our order and was outstanding. She moved to each table and spoke to everyone like they were friends. Now to the pizza.... the deep dish supreme was delicious! The sauce had to made In house. The craft beer selection was good and inexpensive. This place is now on our radar when we want great pizza and service. Our new fav place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 1-Topping Deep Dish Pizza
Jason Arthur
Great place, hands down, the best pizza on the Southside.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Josh Mathews
My first job was at a small pizza shop owned by a family that cared deeply about the quality and taste of their food. I thought that their food ruined pizza for me because no other pizza places could stand up to the love and care they put in to what they did. That was until I came across South of Chicago. I've been absolutely blown away with my experience, I never eat pizza anymore but I can see myself hooked! Thank you for the passion put in to what you do. With love, from Josh M.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatballs, 1-Topping Deep Dish Pizza
John Siegel
Great pizza, friendly owners, and reasonable prices. We especially love the deep dish pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 1-Topping Thin Crust Pizza, 1-Topping Deep Dish Pizza, 12 Pan Pizza, Italian Beef Sandwich
Rob Wills
Outstanding pizza and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rusty Gerritson
Had the Italian beef and took the pizza home...Italian beef was one of the best I've ever had...pizza was great too we had a ton crust and a deep dish...we drove 40 minutes to eat here and my wife said when we have friends come to town we are bringing them
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Beef Sandwich
Glenn Stutsman
Good food even better service. Will be back I am sure.
This restaurant was not busy - in fact, we were the only customers there until nearly the end of our meal, when a couple of other customers came in. It's a good thing, because it seems as though there was only the one gentleman working there. We were told to seat ourselves, and we went past a couple of tables that were cleaned off but hadn't been wiped down before we selected a table that looked clean. My husband ordered the meat lasagna, only to be told that it was not available, only the vegetable lasagna was available. So he ordered that. I ordered an individual-size pizza that came with a single breadstick and a drink. I'm sure these items were made fresh, because we were there a while before they were served. The pizza was as I ordered it and was hot and fresh. I didn't taste my husband's lasagna, but he says it was good. My pizza was good, except I didn't like the tomato sauce on it. I like my pizza sauce to be a little bit on the sweet side, and this was not. The service was fine, I got low on my drink and was brought a refill. The bread stick was acceptable, as was the melted cheese that accompanied it. Overall this place was nothing to write home about. It was an okay but rather forgettable meal.
Bill A.
We had the supreme thin crust and it was delicious! Lots of toppings and so much cheese. We will definitely be back
Mark K.
Great pizza lots of flavor crust was good pepperoni was a tad greasy but pepperoni is almost always greasy. Cheese bread was very good as well. Would definitely got back
Danny Chrenko
Service leaves something to be desired, but one of my favorite pizzas in CG now.After 6 years, I’m changing my review to 5 stars. We get South of Chicago at least once a month. This IS the best pizza on the south side, I’d argue in all of Indy. Thin crust is where it’s at.
Miranda Moore
Sabrina is a friendly, fun server! She was engaging, and suggested tge best pizza! 1st time here, and Def will be back!°
South of Chicago has the best combo I have had outside of Chicago. The food is so good I dont even miss my home state of Illinois. The service is great and the atmosphere really feels like a Chicago diner. Go get a cheesey beef and sausage combo with hot peppers. Itll change your life.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Beef & Sausage Combo
We've tried a lot of pizza joints around our house, and this has definitely become one of our go-to choices. I'm a sandwich girl, and I think the bread is important, and that is the primary reason I like this place. They have very good French-style bread they use for sandwiches, which then is toasted and crispy. The hot ham and cheese is delicious. Sandwiches come with chips and a pickle. The pizza is neither thin crust nor thick crust, it is somewhere in between, but it is tasty and filling. My husband gets a large and it can feed him for a few meals. We also really like the breadsticks, which are well-seasoned, soft, and have a variety of sauce choices. If you're looking for solid pizza take out, this is a good Greenwood option.
Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It was our first time stopping here. It was Saturday afternoon and the dining room was steady. The gal who took our order and was outstanding. She moved to each table and spoke to everyone like they were friends. Now to the pizza.... the deep dish supreme was delicious! The sauce had to made In house. The craft beer selection was good and inexpensive. This place is now on our radar when we want great pizza and service. Our new fav place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 1-Topping Deep Dish Pizza
Great place, hands down, the best pizza on the Southside.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
My first job was at a small pizza shop owned by a family that cared deeply about the quality and taste of their food. I thought that their food ruined pizza for me because no other pizza places could stand up to the love and care they put in to what they did. That was until I came across South of Chicago. I've been absolutely blown away with my experience, I never eat pizza anymore but I can see myself hooked! Thank you for the passion put in to what you do. With love, from Josh M.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatballs, 1-Topping Deep Dish Pizza
Great pizza, friendly owners, and reasonable prices. We especially love the deep dish pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 1-Topping Thin Crust Pizza, 1-Topping Deep Dish Pizza, 12 Pan Pizza, Italian Beef Sandwich
Outstanding pizza and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had the Italian beef and took the pizza home...Italian beef was one of the best I've ever had...pizza was great too we had a ton crust and a deep dish...we drove 40 minutes to eat here and my wife said when we have friends come to town we are bringing them
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Beef Sandwich
Good food even better service. Will be back I am sure.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Beef Sandwich
Restaurantji Recommends
This restaurant was not busy - in fact, we were the only customers there until nearly the end of our meal, when a couple of other customers came in. It's a good thing, because it seems as though there was only the one gentleman working there. We were told to seat ourselves, and we went past a couple of tables that were cleaned off but hadn't been wiped down before we selected a table that looked clean. My husband ordered the meat lasagna, only to be told that it was not available, only the vegetable lasagna was available. So he ordered that. I ordered an individual-size pizza that came with a single breadstick and a drink. I'm sure these items were made fresh, because we were there a while before they were served. The pizza was as I ordered it and was hot and fresh. I didn't taste my husband's lasagna, but he says it was good. My pizza was good, except I didn't like the tomato sauce on it. I like my pizza sauce to be a little bit on the sweet side, and this was not. The service was fine, I got low on my drink and was brought a refill. The bread stick was acceptable, as was the melted cheese that accompanied it. Overall this place was nothing to write home about. It was an okay but rather forgettable meal.
We had the supreme thin crust and it was delicious! Lots of toppings and so much cheese. We will definitely be back
Great pizza lots of flavor crust was good pepperoni was a tad greasy but pepperoni is almost always greasy. Cheese bread was very good as well. Would definitely got back
Service leaves something to be desired, but one of my favorite pizzas in CG now.After 6 years, I’m changing my review to 5 stars. We get South of Chicago at least once a month. This IS the best pizza on the south side, I’d argue in all of Indy. Thin crust is where it’s at.
Sabrina is a friendly, fun server! She was engaging, and suggested tge best pizza! 1st time here, and Def will be back!°
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5