Papa Johns Pizza

120 N Walnut St, Hartford City
(765) 330-3030

Recent Reviews

Casey Carpenter

Constantly shutting off online ordering, won't honor any of the deals over the phone.

Jimmy Warner

My Ole lady is more into Papa John's pizza than I am. It's OK.. Crust is descent but sauce is way to sweet to my liking.Customer service is nice. Cashier were nice and helpful while purchasing and helping if needed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Doug Zumbrun

Great store and fantastic staff!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Blake Mavrix

I could only eat one slice because there was a stupid amount of cheese on that pizza.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 2

Sabrina Walters

Pizza nasty orange color. Burnt and so hard I couldn't bite it! The crust so hard and nasty pretty much inedible. Gross!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Robin Willis

Great bunch and lots of hand washing seen. Makes me happy!Wheelchair accessibility: Fully accessible

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michelle FaRannte

Seems like there's always something wrong with my food way too much cheese or way too much sause. Today my pizza wasn't even cooked through. The cheese was melted but the bottom wasn't crust, it was dough (soft stretchy dough.) I had to put my pizza on a pan and put it in the oven. There was no point in me taking it back as I live 15 minutes out of town.Update: after baking the pizza in my oven until the outer crust was black, the middle was still just as soft. I have come to the conclusion that it just had so much sauce it made the crust way too moist. I have videos but I don't see anywhere to post them. This was a Philly cheesesteak pizza by the way

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Jennifer Pitman

Papa bowls aren't too bad, but I love the papadias

Tymyddeus Owen Sr.

I'm not usually a Poppa John's fan, but this one has really good pizza and service. Especially being as it's inside a had station.

Lori Maher

My garlic knots were burnt. Won't order from here again.

Sheila Davis

I set up my order for 5:30. I called to check on it because the order summary wasn't showing everything I ordered they said order would be ready at 5:30-5:40. Ok fine. I left my home at 5:10 and got a text message that my order was already ready. So it sits for 10 minutes while I get there. I'm really trying to be easier going about things these days because places are having trouble getting enough staff but that is no excuse for just not caring. The staff is nice enough when they are aware they have customers and aren't playing on their phones. So I get my order and when I get home, the order is wrong. Received the wrong crusts and my garlic knots are burned. Needless to say, Papa Johns will no longer get my business. Not that that really matters to them.

EndermanOuch

Slow ordered a pepperoni pizza got sardines??? i have no idea how a place could manage to mess that up

Nash Pearson

My personal favorite pizza around. It's inside of a gas station which is convenient

Timothy Ort

pizza was great and service was also. I will recommend to all.

Richard Budaj

Every time you order they are out of something last mushrooms this time large pizza crust and receipt paper.With the way this store is managed pappa johns should close it down.

Load More