Eddy's Neighborhood Bar & Grill

11693 Fall Creek Rd, Indianapolis
(317) 849-0925

Recent Reviews

Roger K.

It doesn't matter if they are busy or not busy they screw up my carry out order at least every other time!

Kevin Lee

The food and service are great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Smokehouse Burger

Mason Hollis

Grabbed a Reuben sandwich for lunch. Food was hot and served quick. A little messy, but delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Gwen H.

This was our first time to eat at Eddy's and we'll definitely be back. I had fish and chips which was delicious. My husband is a tenderloin snob, and he said it was one of the best tenderloins he'd ever had. The staff was very friendly and attentive. Looking forward to our next meal there!

Ryan S.

I absolutely love this place on Geist - intimate setting and really good apps (love the grilled chicken tendies, all the wraps are stellar, and then sweet potato fries are my fav. James and the staff are TOP TIER

Rich Palmer

overpriced and food was not very good. ordered the salmon looked like a chicken

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Varinia Nevilles

My cousin and I stopped in to try for the first time The staff did not acknowledge us. We decided to leave and the started clapping . Wow! Did not want to service black people! Shame on you!

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Stephanie R.

Eddy's is one of our favorite places! It's a great local watering hole and has great food. Their soups are always stellar. Today's soup was Chicken and Dumplings and it was excellent. Sat at the bar with bartender, Brian. He is the best. He works Sundays, Mondays and Tuesdays. Great TVs for watching sports.

Karl P.

My family went there for dinner after a day on the lake. 2 Of my party ordered the Reuben sandwich. When the order was received, there was only 1 thin slice of meat on the bread. I was going to complain to the Manager but the group did not want me to embarrass them. I called the next day to question why there was so little meat on the sandwich and the manager stated that the portion should not have been like that. He asked what I wanted??? I wanted to understand why we paid $15 for 2 slices of bread and 1 thin slice of meat. I told him that they should provide us 2 free sandwiches for the ones we received the day before and he was not willing to do that. The manager was almost hinging on rude. Customer service at this dinner is poor at best. I would not recommend visiting this establishment.

Mike D.

Went with an unexpected party of 23. Waitress and owner bent over backwards to make sure everyone got their orders correctly. Food was excellent .

Jeff Clemow

Great outside patio with wonderful staff. Loved my burger and beer was cold.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Smokehouse Burger

Debra Pierce

We enjoy this neighborhood place. Better for lunch than dinner.

Christina B.

It definitely had a waterfront vibe. We had lunch outside on a Sunday and had a good view of the water until the parking lot filled up, then we couldn't see the water over the cars. The server and hostess were super friendly. They had a menu with the daily specials on top of their menu items so there's lots to choose from. I was on a health kick so I ordered the turkey burger with a gluten free bun. It was just ok. I always regret ordering the healthier option. I should've learned by now to just order what I really want. My mom loved her sloppy joe. This was my first time visiting the marina/Geist area and it was pretty cool.

Doreen Reineck

We had planned to eat at another restaurant nearby, but they didn't have the room to seat us. Went to Eddy's instead and loved it! Fun place to eat! Server was fantastic as was the food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings

Mel B.

Best Hamburg in Geist, super support staff really great bunch of help there Nice views

Load More