Sucre Baking Company

5261 N Pennsylvania St, Indianapolis
(317) 473-3541

Recent Reviews

Donald Stearns

They were absolutely amazing!!! Definitely recommend!

Alex b Broecker

I ordered 3 pies for my family thanksgiving this year- sugar cream, Pecan, & pumpkin. They were all absolutely outstanding!!! My entire family asked for the information of where I got them. Thank you, Amy!!! 10/10 would recommend.

Cary O

These cupcakes were delicious and beautiful. Huge hit!!!

Teresa Pomeroy

Everything looks lovely but I have tried to call and no one ever answers or responds to messages.

Deborah Brewer

Delicious!!!!

Ashleigh Joyce

I had cookies made for my wedding day and they were absolutely beautiful! They also have gluten free options which was perfect for my mother in law. I would highly recommend this business!

D Slack

We ordered some very delicious press pies for an event and it was very well made and tasty. We look forward to trying more Amy’s creations

Brandi Levy

Beautiful rainbow cake! And it tasted delicious also! I will be doing more business with Amy in the near future.

Derrick S.

We ordered a very very delicious batch of vegan treats and they were simply amazing. The vegan pies were at hit and we can't wait to order more. This city is so hard to find great tasting vegan treats and I think we found a place!!

Brian Cason

I was able get two pies from Sucre this past weekend -- the Dutch Apple and the Key Lime pie. They were absolutely amazing!!! We brought them to a cookout, and everyone was asking where I got them from. Definitely recommend!

rbrar31

I had the pleasure of having cupcakes from Sucre for my birthday this year. They did not disappoint. They were so moist and flavorful! I can't wait to enjoy more!

Anthony Ross

Fantastic sugar cream pie! Creamy texture, not overly sweet, and a light crust. 10/10!

Amsalu Bizubeh

I had a carrot cake from Sucre for my birthday. It was simply the best carrot cake I’ve had in my life!

Jeff Berebitsky

Detail is impeccable (see unicorn sugar cookie photo). And the cinnamon rolls - my son's review after having just tasted one, "Oooh yeah." And I could not agree with him more. Excellent bakery.

Jeff Berebitsky

Detail is impeccable (see unicorn sugar cookie photo). And the cinnamon rolls - my son's review after having just tasted one, "Oooh yeah." And I could not agree with him more. Excellent bakery.

Load More