Stopped in with my boyfriend to grab some sweets and ended up walking out with enough to last us two weeks. We tried the espresso cheesecake, strawberry pie, and a various other treats. Everything was fresh and delightful. The atmosphere was incredibly charming and the staff were very friendly! Kelsey helped us with some recommendations and told us about some of her favorites. We only got sweets this time but their savory pies looked delicious too, we’ll definitely be returning to try some of their dinner options. The sloppy Joe and chicken pot pies looked hearty and delicious. Definitely recommend to anyone looking for a sweet treat and to support a local business!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Debra Ann Massey-Szachnitowski
The Shepherds Pie is the best I've ever eaten north of the MASON/DIXON line!And the Chicken Pot Pie makes you "wanna smack 'yer granny"according to my husband! We only wish they were open 7 days a week.♡
Sheri did an outstanding job on my son's birthday cake. The 6" Chocolate cream pie and Cookies and Cream Brownie is outstanding.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chelle Hainlen
First time ordering the chicken pot pie, taco dip, pecan bars and cranberry bliss bars. Everything tasted fantastic! The pecan bars were the favorite. We will be back!
Dee Reese
I was on a school outing and found this gem. After looking at the reviews, I walked in being greeted by all the workers. Very friendly, nice, attentive, but I was asked if I liked to try a candy... Hook line and sinker... Yum A beautiful Creamy Buckeye. The gentleman who started with me helped another set of customers when they came in since I was still deciding. I bought a French onion beef pot pie that he suggested, a chicken pot pie that another customer said was AWESOME, and lastly, Raspberry Cheesecake slice that was SUPERFANTABULOUS I told the workers, you are going to get my into trouble. So we laughed and I left. I got home and heated the French onion beef pot pie for my husband....IT WAS DEMOLISHED! SUPER HIT! My husband loved it! I am eating my chicken pot pie today. You all hit it out of the park! Thank you so much, and I will be back for sure. Dee Reese
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily White
It's tradition that every year I order my husband a pineapple upsidedown cake for his birthday and I decided to try them. I was worried it wouldn't be enough time if I ordered on a Tuesday and needed it by Friday/Sat as some places need to know well in advanced. They got back with me right away and I picked it up on Friday evening. (Just a small cake for 6-8 people)We didn't eat it till Sunday evening (refridgerated it) and it was delicious! Would definitely order from them again! They had a lot of delicious options in their store too
Kelly Willis-rice
I needed a strawberry rhubarb for my daughters birthday and in the past have been disappointed in various ones I’ve tried. I make an incredible blueberry lemon pie and apple pie but never tried strawberry rhubarb before and didn’t want my first to be her birthday. I ended up going with tastefully Indiana and it was incredible!!! Thank you!!!!!
Pam
The pies here are amazing! Their pot pies are awesome and so delicious. My husband and I share one. Great place, definitely recommended it.
Jessica McAmis
Very tiny sit in restaurant. I think maybe 4 tables. The lady who helped us was SO nice and made it very enjoyable! The food was delicious!!! Pot pies are huge! Cookies were great! They had cute handmade craft items for sale! The reason I didn't give 5 stars was because...they only had canned drinks, which is ok. I just prefer fountain! And the pot pies were absolutely amazing, but they were SO hot....you couldn't do anything with them for like 10 mins! But once they cooled down they were delicious! Highly recommend stopping in and checking them out!!!
Janet Allbaugh
This was my first visit here. My husband said their apple dumplings were about the best he's ever had! The chicken pot pie is amazing. German Chocolate cake, my husband loved. Kahala muffin Yummy! The young lady that helped us was so friendly and helpful. Great experience, highly recommended; I will be return customer soon!
We ordered 9 pies for a family event and it was perfect! Everyone got to order what they wanted and it was wonderful. My guests even said I should give 6 stars because the pot pies were fresh and all I had to do was put them into to oven on 250 to keep them warm for 45 minutes. Then our party was a prefect success!
Trisha Fronczak
Tastefully Indiana has some amazing pot pies, cookies and homemade pies. Their prices are reasonable and the food is so good. There are also vendor booths set up where you can get a gift and a sweet treat.
Matthew Dunstan
Delicious!!! I had the shepards pie chunky apple sauce and a chocolate chip cookie! YUM everything is made from scratch. Very nice, friendly people. They also support local artisans, showcasing some beautiful works.
Pamela Riley
LOVE the French onion pot pie! Best one I’ve ever eaten!
Michele Leming
Just CHOKED down the driest suger cookie I have ever had. Couldn't finish it!!! SAVE YOUR TIME AND $$$$$ GO ELSEWHERE
Stopped in with my boyfriend to grab some sweets and ended up walking out with enough to last us two weeks. We tried the espresso cheesecake, strawberry pie, and a various other treats. Everything was fresh and delightful. The atmosphere was incredibly charming and the staff were very friendly! Kelsey helped us with some recommendations and told us about some of her favorites. We only got sweets this time but their savory pies looked delicious too, we’ll definitely be returning to try some of their dinner options. The sloppy Joe and chicken pot pies looked hearty and delicious. Definitely recommend to anyone looking for a sweet treat and to support a local business!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Shepherds Pie is the best I've ever eaten north of the MASON/DIXON line!And the Chicken Pot Pie makes you "wanna smack 'yer granny"according to my husband! We only wish they were open 7 days a week.♡
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork Baked Potato Casserole, Lasagna Pot Pie, Loaded Potato Soup
Sheri did an outstanding job on my son's birthday cake. The 6" Chocolate cream pie and Cookies and Cream Brownie is outstanding.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time ordering the chicken pot pie, taco dip, pecan bars and cranberry bliss bars. Everything tasted fantastic! The pecan bars were the favorite. We will be back!
I was on a school outing and found this gem. After looking at the reviews, I walked in being greeted by all the workers. Very friendly, nice, attentive, but I was asked if I liked to try a candy... Hook line and sinker... Yum A beautiful Creamy Buckeye. The gentleman who started with me helped another set of customers when they came in since I was still deciding. I bought a French onion beef pot pie that he suggested, a chicken pot pie that another customer said was AWESOME, and lastly, Raspberry Cheesecake slice that was SUPERFANTABULOUS I told the workers, you are going to get my into trouble. So we laughed and I left. I got home and heated the French onion beef pot pie for my husband....IT WAS DEMOLISHED! SUPER HIT! My husband loved it! I am eating my chicken pot pie today. You all hit it out of the park! Thank you so much, and I will be back for sure. Dee Reese
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's tradition that every year I order my husband a pineapple upsidedown cake for his birthday and I decided to try them. I was worried it wouldn't be enough time if I ordered on a Tuesday and needed it by Friday/Sat as some places need to know well in advanced. They got back with me right away and I picked it up on Friday evening. (Just a small cake for 6-8 people)We didn't eat it till Sunday evening (refridgerated it) and it was delicious! Would definitely order from them again! They had a lot of delicious options in their store too
I needed a strawberry rhubarb for my daughters birthday and in the past have been disappointed in various ones I’ve tried. I make an incredible blueberry lemon pie and apple pie but never tried strawberry rhubarb before and didn’t want my first to be her birthday. I ended up going with tastefully Indiana and it was incredible!!! Thank you!!!!!
The pies here are amazing! Their pot pies are awesome and so delicious. My husband and I share one. Great place, definitely recommended it.
Very tiny sit in restaurant. I think maybe 4 tables. The lady who helped us was SO nice and made it very enjoyable! The food was delicious!!! Pot pies are huge! Cookies were great! They had cute handmade craft items for sale! The reason I didn't give 5 stars was because...they only had canned drinks, which is ok. I just prefer fountain! And the pot pies were absolutely amazing, but they were SO hot....you couldn't do anything with them for like 10 mins! But once they cooled down they were delicious! Highly recommend stopping in and checking them out!!!
This was my first visit here. My husband said their apple dumplings were about the best he's ever had! The chicken pot pie is amazing. German Chocolate cake, my husband loved. Kahala muffin Yummy! The young lady that helped us was so friendly and helpful. Great experience, highly recommended; I will be return customer soon!
Restaurantji Recommends
We ordered 9 pies for a family event and it was perfect! Everyone got to order what they wanted and it was wonderful. My guests even said I should give 6 stars because the pot pies were fresh and all I had to do was put them into to oven on 250 to keep them warm for 45 minutes. Then our party was a prefect success!
Tastefully Indiana has some amazing pot pies, cookies and homemade pies. Their prices are reasonable and the food is so good. There are also vendor booths set up where you can get a gift and a sweet treat.
Delicious!!! I had the shepards pie chunky apple sauce and a chocolate chip cookie! YUM everything is made from scratch. Very nice, friendly people. They also support local artisans, showcasing some beautiful works.
LOVE the French onion pot pie! Best one I’ve ever eaten!
Just CHOKED down the driest suger cookie I have ever had. Couldn't finish it!!! SAVE YOUR TIME AND $$$$$ GO ELSEWHERE