Buttery Shelf Eatery

927 Main St, Lafayette
(765) 429-8250

Recent Reviews

Abhishek Guin

Absolute hidden gem!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ryan Anderson

The food was absolutely delicious.The service was kind, pleasant, and prompt.I am shocked and delighted to say that, At the time of posting, Jan 6, 2024, everything in the photos totaled $8.56 before tip.May future patrons tip incredibly well for this wonderful deal.Wheelchair accessibility: The Main Street entrance was not wheelchair accessible. I'm unsure if the back entrance would work.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kris Erickson

Excellent food and service.

Carol B.

Intimate setting and service. Felt very cared for. Food was excellent, with a targeted menu for lunch. Wish it was open more days, but they have quality a priority over quantity.

Stephanie D.

What an absolute hidden gem. It's a little hard to catch them during their limited business hours but when you make it, it's so worth it. Everything is donation based and the food is just phenomenal. With such a wholesome staff, i left feeling like I should hug everyone there. The food was better than my grandmas.. just don't tell my grandma.

Cindy Gray

Food delicious, service friendly and efficient and lovely surroundings

Anastacia Vasyukhina

This place is a hidden gem. The interior is so beautiful, and the lunch deal is fantastic

Ben Denos

Very good! I enjoyed the sandwich, soup, and salad sampler.

Michelle Coble

Food was delicious and everyone was very friendly!

Tiffany Emmons

This is a true hidden gem! Food was fresh & spectacular. Service was on point! I will definitely return.

Andrea

The food is delicious, the service is warm and inviting, and the ambience transports you to another era that offers a brief respite from a busy day.

Amy F.

What a magical little place! I got beef roast and mashed potatoes and French onion soup and everything was perfect and tender and flavorful and they brought a lovely cinnamon cookie and strawberries for a dessert. And offered me extra gravy for the half I took home because it was so much food. And the restaurant is spotless and adorable and everybody was so nice, and they made a grilled cheese for my husband because he is vegetarian and all the dishes had meat. This was a special and memorable lunch.

Kat B.

Lafayette's best-kept lunch secret. This place offers an incredible deal for lunch. The soup, salad and sandwich sample is hearty, filling and delicious for only $9. Service is always friendly. Atmosphere is quaint and historic. Only open Fridays and Saturdays at lunch.

Bradley Lemna

Everything I've had was delicious! The only bad thing is that it's only opened 3 days a week when it should be 24/7. So make sure you clear your culinary calendar Thursdays thru Saturdays

Matt Hurja

What a great place and purpose!! Highly recommend!Petra

Load More