Paper Street Baking Co

9 W Union St, Liberty
(765) 458-7500

Recent Reviews

Chris Goedde

The cupcakes were phenomenal! The owner is very courteous and a fantastic baker!

Google user

Stopped in for the first time today. This is a gourmet bakery. You can taste the real ingredients. Pineapple upside down cakes you could taste the butter in the cake. Sugar pie bars were excellent. Looking forward to trying the other things I bought. I will be back.

Melissa S.

We stopped by this little bakery while spending the week at Whitewater state park. Summer hours were 10-5 Weds-Sat I believe. It is located to the right of the coffee shop across from the courthouse in towns square. Everything was yummy and reasonably priced, I paid a little over $7 for my goodies. They also had cookies, cupcakes, assorted turnovers and mini peanut butter pies on day of visit. A great stop if in the area.

Misti Wells

Tasty bakery items!! Clean store!

Dinah Colvin

Stopped in for the first time today. This is a gourmet bakery. You can taste the real ingredients. Pineapple upside down cakes you could taste the butter in the cake. Sugar pie bars were excellent. Looking forward to trying the other things I bought. I will be back.

Wendy Blanton

Everything I have had from here has been amazing!!

Becky Turner Holsinger

wonderful sweet treats of all types. Have recently started to make smoothies and cold coffee creations, Frappuccinos!

Darlene Mahaney

My photo doesn't do this delicious cake justice! The Kahlua buttercream filling was rich and flavorful yet light and fluffy; the chocolate gananche icing was to die for!

Cullen Phillips

The pastries were delicious! Very friendly, professional, neat and clean. Worth the drive from Eaton, Ohio!

Jenna S.

Cute bakery. Variety of different baked goods. My boys loved their iced cookie & gingerbread cookies. Things were well priced. The store was clean. We enjoyed visiting and would stop back in when we are in Liberty.

Janet Prows

Her products are very delicious

Eddie Groen

Awesome cupcakes for my birthday!!! German chocolate was moist and delicious.

Shelly Walker

Wonderful sweets and talented baker!! Never disappointed!!

Jeanette Marmouze Hoffbauer

Joy does a wonderful job! Delicious and beautifully decorated!

Kayla Clevenger

We ordered our wedding cake and cupcakes from Paper Street Baking and they were beautiful and delicious!

Load More