Graeter's Ice Cream

4310 Charlestown Rd, New Albany
(812) 949-6263

Recent Reviews

I Am The Love U Give

Super cute little ice cream shop, tasty ice cream, and not a bad price. Was a great dessert for an after dinner treat.Parking: That parking lot on a Saturday night is usually packed but it was still easy to find parking.Kid-friendliness: Plenty of kids enjoying their tasty treats.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Turtle Sundae, Sugar Cones

Cruz Herrera

Great at greatest greaters!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sugar Cones, Single Scoop Specialty Choc Dip

Josh Adams

Service was amazing! Seasonal flavors are always good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A. H.

$7 for a single scoop of ice cream and it was freezer-burnt. Wtf. At least they had a water fountain.

Fred Alan

Really good ice cream, but super rich. Thankful for mini cups at the water cooler in back. Super Nice staff at night. Atmosphere is rather bleak and sterile however. Needs wooden booths along interior wall.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Edwin Avila

We wanted dessert after dinner. We looked this place up. It did not disappoint! Very good ice cream. Many flavors. Very attentive service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah W.

Love their extremely high quality ice cream and the seasonal flavors. Love their occasional offers for free delivery via the app with minimal purchase. Love that I can also order treats for my pup!!! We downloaded the app and receive bonus offers, points for purchase, and can peruse the up to date menu selection. Very convenient location in a strip mall off of Charlestown Road, clean and well lit establishment if you venture inside to snag pre packaged ice cream out of the freezer display case, and has a drive through with what I consider to be fairly late hours the last time that we checked -- open until 10 PM. Staff are always friendly and greet us as soon as we open the door and offer fast checkout.

Muddy Juddy

There ice cream is the best in town they also have a ton of flavors and quick service.

DoN

I had a great service today. Everybody was friendly and helpful. The ice cream was awesome.

Kristie Leaphart

Really nice ice cream place. Lots of choices of flavors. The 1 scoop is definitely a hefty scoop. Must try if you're looking for some good dessert.

Jim R.

We've been coming here for many, many years. But, we haven't been here for quite some time.We've always enjoyed their ice cream.Today, I found one thing to be odd. I'm not even sure I understood exactly what one of our server's was saying. What I got out of it was: They can't sell you two large scoops in one order??. They can sell you two smaller scoops, but not two of the larger scoops. IF I understood correctly, that's the craziest thing I've ever heard. Seems to me they'd want to sell all the ice cream they could!Anyway, ice cream was good as ever. Not considering the big scoop/little scoop situation, both young ladies behind the counter were very friendly and accommodating when we asked for little tastings.

Charles Conrad

Nice selection of hand dipped ice cream

Ron A.

You can't beat Graeter's for ice cream. I'm pretty sure this is what the eat in Valhalla. My favorite is black raspberry chip. Their s'mores flavor is excellent, too. Chocolate can't be beat. They have vegan options! It tastes like actual ice cream, not frozen coconut milk. The staff is always friendly. The store and the bathrooms are very clean. It gets busy on nice days, but it's never really bad.

Andria Wenz

Ice cream was AMAZING! Not a fan of thier chocolate dipped waffle cone but the ice cream more then made up for it! The staff were courteous and helpful. Totally going again the next time we are in town!

Hailey Janes

Josh (Atlas) was super friendly and had great customer service. Will be returning.

Load More