So good!! Highly recommend. The cobbler is fantastic!
Jacgueline Brackett
Great donuts
Jim R.
OK, first of all I'm reticent to review this business due to past experiences. A long time ago I did a review on King Donuts in Charlestown IN. I said King's Apple Fritters were the best I'd eaten. Now everytime I stop at King, they're out of Apple Fritters! Now for Toni T's. Wow, no seriously WOW. This was my first ever stop at Toni T's. It was later in the day so there wasn't a lot to choose from. I bought a serving of Bread Pudding. Now, I hate cake like bread pudding. I love moist, pudding like, Bread Pudding. Toni's Bread Pudding is the best I've eaten in my long life. It was moist, full of spices, and melted in my mouth. I swear, if it was calorie free I'd eat it everyday! I also bought some Banana Pudding but haven't tried it yet. Looks delicious.
Lindsey Goetz
I have been here several times to pick up treats and ordered cupcakes and cookie cakes for a few events. The desserts are absolutely delicious and everyone here is very friendly and kind and goes above and beyond. Toni took my order for my daughter’s birthday party despite the fact that it was the same day as a major local festival. She still made sure the cupcakes and cookie cake were fresh and decorated beautifully. My husband is a huge fan of cookies and has had many cookie cakes, but swears hers is the best he has ever had. We had multiple guests ask for the bakery details after serving it at my daughter’s party. We will return here for any dessert orders we have in the future and love to pop in and check what is in the display case whenever we can!
Brian Matherly
Being someone that used to make doughnuts this place is incredible. The filled doughnuts aren’t like most places, here they completely fill them not just a little dab of filling. Most of the doughnuts are oversized and all that I have had taste great. This is a place that actually takes pride in the quality of the food and all the staff have been very nice. I would definitely recommend them.
Kaitlin Bugh
Prices a bit spendy, but not ridiculously high.Doughnuts were a hit or miss.Boston cream round was good.Apple fritter left much to be desired.The staff was nice.Place was clean and looked nice.Went later in the day so stock was low,but bet it is a lot better first thing in the morning.Overall a good place for doughnuts ?.
Bren De Chari
Great donuts and all desserts!!
Kristy Knable
We’ve been enjoying tasty treats from Toni T ever since we discovered them at the farmers market in New Albany. Now they have a store and more goodies available! Their cobbler is the best I’ve ever tasted (besides my own grandmother’s cobbler). Their banana pudding is mouth-wateringly good. Their donuts are some of the best I’ve ever had. Everything I’ve had there is like an amusement park to my taste buds. Seriously. I’m a devoted customer for life.
Mark D.
Bought 3 cinnamon rolls today @$2.75 each. They were dry and tasted artificial. We gave them a second chance as the first time we weren’t satisfied. I was told to give everyone a second chance. Oh well, we tried. Donuts not as good as the former Jeff’s Bakery that was in this location.
J Walls
We used Toni T’s for our wedding desserts and everything was AMAZING. The desserts were delicious and our guests raved about them. I cannot stop dreaming about our wedding cake. She was such a pleasure to work with, offering us numerous options, affordable pricing, and samples to taste. Lucky for us, we have some desserts left over we will be enjoying for the next few days.
I stopped by on a whim after visiting a shop next door & got donuts for the guys at work. It just so happened that my boss had the same idea - he brought donuts for the guys, but from a competitor. My donuts were ravaged and his weren't touched! Great job, Toni T! I'll be back!
Amanda Beirne
The service was warm and friendly. The bread pudding is absolutely amazing!!!!
Miranda Seawell
I love this place, my favorite is the pumpkin spice cheesecake, originally, I thought my slice was burnt on the bottom, but after I tried it some more later on today, it tastes just fine and just like how I remember. Most likely my medications are at fault. Sometimes don’t taste things or smell things correctly. This place deserves 5 stars. They work hard passionately at what they do.
Katrina Soils
Have thoroughly enjoyed everything I've purchased at Toni T’s ?! Most recent purchase of banana pudding and the chess cake were excellent ??!
Ashley Pollard
Our favorite donut place ❤️Always fresh and the owners and so nice!
So good!! Highly recommend. The cobbler is fantastic!
Great donuts
OK, first of all I'm reticent to review this business due to past experiences. A long time ago I did a review on King Donuts in Charlestown IN. I said King's Apple Fritters were the best I'd eaten. Now everytime I stop at King, they're out of Apple Fritters! Now for Toni T's. Wow, no seriously WOW. This was my first ever stop at Toni T's. It was later in the day so there wasn't a lot to choose from. I bought a serving of Bread Pudding. Now, I hate cake like bread pudding. I love moist, pudding like, Bread Pudding. Toni's Bread Pudding is the best I've eaten in my long life. It was moist, full of spices, and melted in my mouth. I swear, if it was calorie free I'd eat it everyday! I also bought some Banana Pudding but haven't tried it yet. Looks delicious.
I have been here several times to pick up treats and ordered cupcakes and cookie cakes for a few events. The desserts are absolutely delicious and everyone here is very friendly and kind and goes above and beyond. Toni took my order for my daughter’s birthday party despite the fact that it was the same day as a major local festival. She still made sure the cupcakes and cookie cake were fresh and decorated beautifully. My husband is a huge fan of cookies and has had many cookie cakes, but swears hers is the best he has ever had. We had multiple guests ask for the bakery details after serving it at my daughter’s party. We will return here for any dessert orders we have in the future and love to pop in and check what is in the display case whenever we can!
Being someone that used to make doughnuts this place is incredible. The filled doughnuts aren’t like most places, here they completely fill them not just a little dab of filling. Most of the doughnuts are oversized and all that I have had taste great. This is a place that actually takes pride in the quality of the food and all the staff have been very nice. I would definitely recommend them.
Prices a bit spendy, but not ridiculously high.Doughnuts were a hit or miss.Boston cream round was good.Apple fritter left much to be desired.The staff was nice.Place was clean and looked nice.Went later in the day so stock was low,but bet it is a lot better first thing in the morning.Overall a good place for doughnuts ?.
Great donuts and all desserts!!
We’ve been enjoying tasty treats from Toni T ever since we discovered them at the farmers market in New Albany. Now they have a store and more goodies available! Their cobbler is the best I’ve ever tasted (besides my own grandmother’s cobbler). Their banana pudding is mouth-wateringly good. Their donuts are some of the best I’ve ever had. Everything I’ve had there is like an amusement park to my taste buds. Seriously. I’m a devoted customer for life.
Bought 3 cinnamon rolls today @$2.75 each. They were dry and tasted artificial. We gave them a second chance as the first time we weren’t satisfied. I was told to give everyone a second chance. Oh well, we tried. Donuts not as good as the former Jeff’s Bakery that was in this location.
We used Toni T’s for our wedding desserts and everything was AMAZING. The desserts were delicious and our guests raved about them. I cannot stop dreaming about our wedding cake. She was such a pleasure to work with, offering us numerous options, affordable pricing, and samples to taste. Lucky for us, we have some desserts left over we will be enjoying for the next few days.
Restaurantji Recommends
I stopped by on a whim after visiting a shop next door & got donuts for the guys at work. It just so happened that my boss had the same idea - he brought donuts for the guys, but from a competitor. My donuts were ravaged and his weren't touched! Great job, Toni T! I'll be back!
The service was warm and friendly. The bread pudding is absolutely amazing!!!!
I love this place, my favorite is the pumpkin spice cheesecake, originally, I thought my slice was burnt on the bottom, but after I tried it some more later on today, it tastes just fine and just like how I remember. Most likely my medications are at fault. Sometimes don’t taste things or smell things correctly. This place deserves 5 stars. They work hard passionately at what they do.
Have thoroughly enjoyed everything I've purchased at Toni T’s ?! Most recent purchase of banana pudding and the chess cake were excellent ??!
Our favorite donut place ❤️Always fresh and the owners and so nice!