Uncommon Cups and Cones

518 Vincennes St, New Albany
(812) 924-7047

Recent Reviews

Kaleb Lawton

Great little ice cream shop! A lot of cool unique flavors and plenty of variety to choose from. Great service and friendly atmosphere!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ashley Schaeffer

Stopped in for some ice cream. Loved the ice cream, the friendly folks and the comfy place to sit and enjoy the Icecream. Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Banana Split, Double Scoops

Don Schofield

Wonderful ice cream and great owners.

Kevin King

What an amazing little shop! Wonderful people, fantastic treats, very, very comfortable place to just rest and relax. LOVE IT!

Ariel Findley

We absolutely LOVE this place! The ice cream is delicious. We can't go to New Albany without making a stop!

Michelle Babbitt

Such a cute little place to enjoy I will definitely be back ??❤??

Jason Byrd

Great people. Great ice cream. Good price. Fun place to be.

Queen Scorpio (Sarah W)

Such great ice cream and atmosphere! Will definitely go back!

Angel Hood

Our kiddos really liked the flavors of their ice cream but the triple scoops didn't even come to the top of the container, very uncommon indeed. The atmosphere is always friendly and super cute but $30 for 3 people to have a fairly small portion of ice cream Id prefer to go somewhere with less of a vibe and know we'd leave satisfied. The flavors are creamy and great too, just didn't feel like we got what we paid for.

Kevin Duchon

The ice cream isn't made in house, but they do a good job of choosing flavors that seem to fit their namesake (not sure who they buy it from). The decor is fun, and the glass dishes are awesome. But I just wish the product was better. Also, if a kid drops their cone... These guys don't offer to get them a new one.

Albert Flieg

Excellent highly recommend stopping in for a ice cream shake banana split and anything else they offer very nice ladies

6 i x a m

The family that runs this place is extremely friendly and are accommodating to requests. The building is cute and feels like a classic ice cream place with a homey vibe. The selection of ice cream is awesome, some flavor combos I’ve never seen anywhere else. Personal favorite item is the brownie with the exhausted parent ice cream scoop. Definitely stop by and get a cone or two.

Cristina Garcia

Such a cute place !! I’ve been to many ice cream shops and so far this is my favorite. So many unique options and very tasty and fun place to go with the kiddos. I would have taken a pic of what I got but before I remembered it was pretty much gone lol

Sommer Chasteen

This is a cute little shop with very tasty ice cream!! Always friendly service and you can’t beat the prices. A Fat Elvis milkshake hits the spot every time!!

Samantha D.

WOW! Yelp is never wrong when a place shows up as having 5 stars!I was in the area and wanting to get some ice cream to go. I looked up ice cream shops on Yelp and this one came up so I decided to give it a try.As soon as I walked in I said "omg this is so cute!". I felt like I had gone back in time. Needless to say I decided to actually sit down and enjoy my ice cream inside the parlor.I was greeted by a really nice girl who asked if I had been there before and when I said I hadn't, she walked me through the menu. You can try up to 3 options which is good because it is so hard to choose! I decided to do the Kitty Kitty Bang Bang ice cream and it was delicious!When I paid I got a frequent shopper card which I was glad because I will definitely be back! Such nice service!

Load More