37 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Palestine

1
Tia's

Tia's Tacos •
5933 US-52 Suite N, New Palestine

Customers` Favorites

Chorizo and Cheese Quesadilla
Sausage Egg Cheese
Choose Your Bread
Biscuitst Gravy
White American
Ham Cheese

“5 stars all around! I went in Tia's for the 1st time since they've been open and it just blew me away the place was clean the people were nice and helpful and the food is amazing I would recommend Tia's to anyone that ask breakfast and lunch they have a decent “

4.9 Superb32 Reviews
Mozzi's Pizza Pizza • $
18 W Main St #8755, New Palestine

Customers` Favorites

Hawaiian Pizza

“This is a great place to pick up your pizza and head home after a long day. The staff is friendly and courteous. The food is so good and they have a variety of toppings to choose from. It is a pick up only location. It is nice and clean inside.“

4 Good26 Reviews
Y-Not Pizza & Lounge Pizza • $
45 E Main St, New Palestine

Customers` Favorites

Two Toppings Pizza
Breadsticks with
Sandwich

“Love this locally owned pizza place. The staff is always friendly and helpful. The pizza and breadsticks are a hit with our family. We particularly love the crumbled sausage and bacon pizza. This is in one of our permanent rotation for pizza night.“

3.8 Good26 Reviews
Tony D's Pizza • $$
5918 Dragon Dr, New Palestine

Customers` Favorites

Cheeseburger and Fries
Pulled Pork Nachos
Biscuits and Gravy
Mashed Potatoes
Chicken Strips
Boneless Wings
Pretzel Bites
Beef Manhattan
Chicken Wings
Chicken Wrap

“Verily it came to pass that on the 4th day of the 4th week of the second month of the year of our lord, 2024 that God filled my loins with the pressure of two and a half she-bears after partaking of the dairy, despite being intolerant of the milk of cow, sheep, and other mammals that lactate.For it came to pass that the porcelain throne of the second largest stalls would also meet its maker.As my bosom met with the cold porcelain, God's fury did unleash upon the bowl. The demons expelled in haste and the sound of trumpets did fill the space. The air did smell of horrid stench and the room of bathing did become exceedingly humid.And it came to pass that condensation from my body did drip down upon my cloth and the tile floor, for God's fury knew no boundaries. The circles of hell did surround me as I prayed unto the lord for mercy, and yet the lord did not answer, for my punishment was just, although cruel, but I received many of warning to abstain from the product of dairy by my father, mother and healer, but I did not listen, for the cheese was worth the multitudes of sufferings that begot me.The Mac and cheese was good.Also they have code red mtn dew :)“

3.8 Good136 Reviews
Mama Nita's Pizza Pizza • $
5040 US-52, New Palestine

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Buffet
Lunch

“Very fun and friendly atmosphere. The prices are much more reasonable than other pizza shops in town and the food is superior.The buffet is always fresh at peak meal times, but is available all day. The employees are always happy to freshen it up :) Cheese sauce is available upon request. The bacon barbecue chicken is awesome!“

3.7 Good35 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
5971 W U.S. 52 Suite H, New Palestine

Customers` Favorites

Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie
Traditional Wings
Cheese Pizza
Breadsticks

“This Pizza hut has always treated us well. The staff has always been friendly. On the weekend it's usually ran by teenagers but they are very polite. My order is almost always correct. On the very few occasions that it wasn't, they have fixed it for us immediately. The main complaint is that they often put very little sauce on the boneless wings but have always added some without complaints whenever I point it out.“

3.6 Good32 Reviews
Pizza and Chicken Express Pizza • $
4175 N Post Rd, Indianapolis - 9.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Medium Cheese Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Meatlover Calzone
Pepperoni Pizza
Supreme Pizza
Pizza Cake
Fried Okra
10 Wings
Cookies

“Best pizza place I have found in Indianapolis. I got the Calzone which buttery and cheesy. The highlight was the chocolate cake pizza. If you are from the south and heard of Pizza Inn it is essentially the chocolate chip dessert pizza with a fluffier base. I was thanking God that I found it bc that is my all time favorite pizza. Now I don't have to travel to Mississippi just to enjoy it.“

4.9 Superb97 Reviews
Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta Pizza • $
7755 E Washington St, Indianapolis - 8.22 miles

Customers` Favorites

Small 1 Topping Pizza
Stuffed Breadsticks
Garlic Cheese Bread
Pepperoni Pizza
Marinara Sauce
Baked Spaghetti
Chicken Wings
Garlic Bread
Stromboli
Ham

“Phoned in order. Arrived at told time for pickup. Pizza just coming out of oven. By the time I payed, it was on the counter. Could not make it all the way home with my car smelling like pizza. At the first stop sign I grabbed a bread stick to snack on. Got pizza home, looked wonderful, & tasted wonderful. Best pizza on the east side. Give them a try. PS. They are about the only business on that corner, so plenty of parking!“

4.8 Superb52 Reviews
Cutting Edge Pizzeria Pizza Takeaway • $
506 W Carey St, Fairland - 9.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Deluxe Calzone Pepperoni Sausage Onions Green Peppers Mushrooms
Henry's Favorite Pizza - 8
Spicy Pizza Dipping Sauce
Brownie Pizza 10 Ounce
Pepperoni Pinwheels
Toasted Ravioli
Taco Pizza - 12
Breadsticks
BBQ Pizza
Meatballs

“I ordered a 16 inch speciality pizza, bread sticks, and a calzone. The food was fantastic, but the real star of the show for me, was the garlic butter dipping sauce. So flavorful and the perfect sauce to dip bread sticks or pizza. I will be a returning customer!“

4.8 Superb49 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $
10820 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis - 10.68 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings Chicken Dippers
Pepperoni Magnifico Pizza
The Big Cheese Pizza
All Meat Pizza
Chicken Caesar
Cheezybread
Deluxe

“Ordered from here for the first time recently. Really good and crispy thin crust with quality ingredients. Staff was friendly and helpful. Been looking for another option for pizza near me and this Marcos store is definitely high on my list.“

4.5 Superb72 Reviews
New Bethel Ordinary Pizza • $
8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker - 6.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Nbo Large Sausage Pizza with Extra Cheese
Half and Half Supreme and Meat Lovers Pizza
Breaded Tenderloin and Fries
Traditional Bone in Wings
New Bethel Nachos
Brisket Sandwich
Tenderloin Strips
Chicken Wings
Supreme Pizza
Bread Pudding

“We went on a Thursday Night, and it was a packed house. Very quickly some put us on the short waitlist. Our server was very friendly and attentive. All of the food was very good. The meat lovers pizza had pepperoni, sausage and bacon. One piece and I was full. The boneless wings had a great tasting breading. The house made sauce was amazing.“

4.3 Superb113 Reviews
Brewskies Pub & Eatery Bar & Grill • $
7925 Southeastern Ave, Indianapolis - 7.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

5 Boneless Wings And
Biscuits and Gravy
Breakfast Sandwich
Chewbacca Burger
Wicked Shrimp
Fried Chicken
Patty Melt
Wrap
Pizza

“I have always loved Brewskies love the family side and the adult bar side ! I love there food since I was very young but there pizza sauce has changed significantly over the years and it's just not what it used to be years ago ! But it's still really really good . Just miss the old sauceKid-friendliness: There is a family side and then the adults bar ????????on other side ????????????? ??? ?????? ? Wheelchair accessibility: Yes it is wheelchair assible on both sides bar and family side“

4.5 Superb59 Reviews
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza Pizza • $$
9165 Otis Ave, Indianapolis - 11.16 miles

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Pizza Veggie
Slaughterhouse Five Pizza
Goat Cheese Marinara
Meatlovers Pizza
Creamy Parmesan
Lasagna Pizza
Spinach Salad
Cheese Pizza
Hummus Plate
Italian Beef

“I visited three times this week. I called initially to see about placing a placing a delivery order to the library, I was informed they only had carry at at this time. Drivers were limited.I read the reviews. So after reading about the Lasagna Pizza and the grave reviews I decided I would go once I left the library.I walked in and the server told me that I could sit anywhere I like.I had an excellent first time experience. I had Lasagna Pizza and a spinach salad.My waiter checked on me frequently. I could rave on him all day long. He and the gentleman cleaning the tables need a raise for their services.Since I know they did not have delivery. I went ahead and did a carryout order the next day. I could not get enough of the Lasagna Pizza. The lady who took my carryout order told me it would take 15 to 20 minutes. I walked to the gas station, returned to the Jockamo, and then walked too wherever I wanted to go to next.The third day. I walked in. It was a little busier than my first experience. It was not overly crowded. I asked to sit at a table on one of the walls rather than in the middle of the room where I was being asked to sit.I was told no due to setting arrangements. I could have chosen to leave, but I decided to stay. I could read the greeters face and tell she thought that decision was out of her hands.I wanted to try something different. Therefore, I ordered the Lazy Boy Pizza. The waitresses and waiters worked as a team. I was checked on often. They have a great team going.A lot of times when I visit an establishment. It is to continue working on business projects. That third day I arrived at about 6:30 p.m. and left at around closing time. I asked for items as I packaged up to leave. The lady behind the counted pleasantly handed them to me.The seat that I had desired in the back of the room in which to work. No one sat at that table the duration of my visit. It was empty in a half full room. Where people request to be seated if a table is available and does not take up too much space matters.“

4.2 Good129 Reviews
Just Pizza Pizza • $
2140 N Mitthoefer Rd, Indianapolis - 7.58 miles

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheese Steak Sub
Bone in Wings
Baked Potato
Medium Pizza
Garlic Bread
Loaded Fries
Pizza Sub
Pan Crust

“Last night you all showed me how much you care about your customers! My pizza was late so I was calling to cancel order and the manager called me back and said your pizza is free and apologize for it being so later. That spoke volume to your customers appreciation. Thank you!“

4.4 Superb61 Reviews
Shakers Good Eats & Ale American • $
8142 E Southport Rd Suite 101, Indianapolis - 7.9 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pulled Pork Loaded Fries
Shakers Steak Sandwich
Chicken Bacon Wrap
Chicken Sandwich
Fish and Chips
Cheeseburger
Steak Fries
Onion Rings
Salad Bar

“This was our first time here. We will definitely put this on our favorite places. We had loaded pulled pork and fries, a bacon cheeseburger with a fried egg and French Fries. Everything was hot, fresh and tasty. We also had adult beverages. They have great mixed drinks and a great beer selection. The atmosphere is very nice and the service was outstanding what a great staff. 5 stars all the way.“

4.1 Good117 Reviews
Mozzi's Pizza Pizza • $
2221 W Main St, Greenfield - 6.22 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sicilian with Sausage and Pepperoni
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Specialty Calzones
Pizza Buffet
Breadsticks
Nacho Pizza

“My husband has been going here since he was a teenager and he's 63. We love this place. Have nothing negative to say about them. I've been going there for many years. We didn't go for several years because we moved out of state. Nothing has changed still great service and great “

4.2 Good65 Reviews
Hometown Classic Pizza Pizza • $
1002 E Main St, Greenfield - 8.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Topping and Extra
Cheddar Bacon Fries
Pepperoni Pizza
Bread Sticks
Wings

“Hometown Classic Pizza has the best wings in Greenfield! They are meaty and a very nice portion. Their staff are so helpful when you call to order and the delivery service is one of the best! Usually the order arrives a little earlier than they promise and it is hot still when we sit down to enjoy! Great for Sunday night football!! You should try them before the Super Bowl in case you want some for the Big Game!“

4.3 Superb46 Reviews
Xtrordinary Pizza Pizza • $$
7639 Southeastern Ave Suite B, Indianapolis - 7.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Pepperoni Green Peppers Onion Black Olives Banana Peppers and Jalapeño
Pizza with Sausage Onion Mushrooms and Black Olives
All Around the World Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Sticks
Deluxe Pizza
Parmesan Stix
Pizza Bread
Breadstix

“If this isn't the BEST pizza, and pizza deal, in Indy; then I'll eat my hat!! Xtrordinary Pizza just blew me away. The crust, the sauce, the edge-to-edge toppings (piled high!), the perfect amount of cheese, and THE BROWNED finish!!! We're talking pizza perfection here. I know I should have stopped at a couple of pieces, but I just couldn't. It was VERY hard to control myself. I had tried this place years ago, and wasn't impressed. Now I am!! Something has changed for the better, that's for sure. Very friendly people, as well. The only negative is finding it after pulling off the road. It's all the way in the back, hidden by other buildings. I will be putting this place in my regular rotation. Who needs Jack's anymore!!?? (They're too expensive anyway, IMHO).“

4.1 Good86 Reviews

19
Sunoco

Sunoco Pizza •
12740 Southeastern Avenue, Fairland - 4.93 miles

“11/10 id give more stars if I could, I drive out of my way to come here. Great selection, lot of vape/cbd if that's your thing, great prices, well-stocked, gas is great obviously. Above all though its the people that run it that set them apart, kind, warm, welcoming, type to make you feel like family just walking in. Highly recommend“

4.3 Superb38 Reviews
Wooden Bear Brewing Co. Brewery • $
21 W North St, Greenfield - 7.71 miles

“We love this place. It’s very welcoming, with good service, yummy drinks and fantastic pizza. We love the extra crispy pepperonis! We’ve gone almost every Friday for the past month or so and the staff recognizes us now. Great music too!“

4.1 Good51 Reviews
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza Pizza • $
188 E New Rd, Greenfield - 9.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Dipping Sauce
Papa's All Meat
Big Murphy

“Ordered 2 large pizzas and both were delicious 4 the most part. Walking in 4 the very 1st time and it smelled great.. just like an old fashioned pizzeria only modern, fresh and clean.The only critique I have is I didn't like how the worker who prepared the pies basically dumped most of the toppings in clumps and mostly all towards the middle of the pie. I prefer my toppings spread out and all the way to the edge of the crust evenly.“

4.4 Superb24 Reviews
O B's Pizza Pub & Eatery Pizza • $$
2102 N Mitthoefer Rd, Indianapolis - 7.56 miles

Customers` Favorites

Three Toppings Classic Cheese Pizza
Jalapeno Poppers
Sausage Pizza
Chef Salad
O B

“Love this place ...good to see new faces music always good always have a great seat & table and the crowd is awesome... I enjoy every chance I can get to hear great music and drinks are on point...Parking: Plenty of lights to see for safety“

4.2 Good33 Reviews
Cugino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $$
4751 N Franklin Rd, Indianapolis - 11.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hawaiian Personal Pizza
Home of the 30 Pizza
Classic Stromboli
Garlic Butter
Cheese Pizza
Cheeseburger
Chef Salad

“This place sure is great. The food was good, the service was good, and the price was right. On top of that when one of the other local businesses created a problem for me the owner came out to comfort me and help on a Saturday in the middle of dinner rush.“

4.1 Good43 Reviews
Mozzi's Pizza Pizza • $
1282 N State St, Greenfield - 8.33 miles

Customers` Favorites

Various Types of Pizza

“Ordered for the 1st time tonight, & WOW, was totally blown away! We just relocated & where I was before it was so hard to find a gem of a pizza place & I think I just found it with yall!!! Order arrived hot n fresh, was made perfectly(which I don't think has ever happened anywhere else), nothing missing, was square cut as I love! I tried a slice of my sons cheese pizza & even that was sooo good with the ricotta on top. Very nice. The delivery driver "David" was so personable & kind. If you are hesitant on ordering...dont be! This establishment rocks! I even called them as well to let them know & I didn't catch the guys name who answered the phone but he was super kind & appreciative. This will def be my go to pizza joint! Thank youuuuu“

4.6 Superb16 Reviews
Godfather's Pizza Express Pizza • $
2935 N Mitthoefer Rd, Indianapolis - 8.18 miles

“I used to love Godfather's Pizza and didn't realize there was one still around in the Indy area. Thanks to Yelp I ran across this little gem! Placed my delivery order online through the Yelp app and once I received confirmation it was on! The delivery was fast and my food arrived hot and delicious. Ordered delivery via Yelp app and Grubhub. Update: I was ready to have the same experience the second time around. However it never happened. Grubhub dropped the ball. We again ordered through the Yelp app via Grubhub. We waited and waited and then I got a notification that my pizza had been delivered so I called Grubhub and it seemed they delivered it to the wrong address. Oh well, no pizza for us. Maybe another time.“

4 Good42 Reviews
Greek's Pizzeria Greenfield Pizza • $
21 W North St, Greenfield - 7.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni & Sausage Pizza
Supreme Pizza
Five Cheese

“Everyone's pizza was great, and the herb breadsticks are always so good. I do still wish they had the option to get it well done, but it definitely wasn't underdone, so not a big deal just personal preference. Also personal preference that I'd rather have extra sauce and a bit less cheese but everyone else loved it and I wasn't mad. The person making pizzas could use a lesson in what toppings to put on top v under cheese but other than that it was great and we will be back, especially when the wooden bear is so accommodating. The bar will get you a flight of however many drinks you'd like to try, and it's a great deal. Helps that the staff is always so friendly even with kids that can be a bit crazy and needy.“

4.1 Good29 Reviews
Chuck E. Cheese Pizza • $
10021 E Washington St, Indianapolis - 6.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

A Topping to Your Large Pizza for 2
Medium Build Your Own
Mac and Cheesy Pizza
Large Cheese Pizza
Cotton Candy
App Sampler
Small Wings

“We had a great time celebrating our son's 7th birthday in December at this location. We worked with two managers (one was Abbrial) and they were professional, friendly, and accommodating. Our party helper (Keshaun, I think) was so fun and a great host for our party. They have added a lot to the party experience, which made it so worth the price and helped create a ton of great memories. Very clean, every game was working, pizza was excellent. Thanks for a wonderful time!“

4 Good39 Reviews
Sugar Creek Brickhouse Pizza • $
5821 W US Hwy 40, Greenfield - 4.06 miles

Customers` Favorites

Boneless Chicken Wings
Crinkle Cut Fries
Hoosier Tenderloin
BBQ Pork Nachos
Cheeseburger
Deluxe Pizza
French Fries
Burgers

“Parking: Parking is great they always have an open spot along with plenty of front parking for those who have difficulties physically getting to and from.Kid-friendliness: They're kid friendly and provide high chairs and good food/drink options.“

3.9 Good54 Reviews
Chicago's Pizza On Tap Pizza • $
1031 N State St, Greenfield - 8.25 miles

Customers` Favorites

Deep Dish Pizza
Regular Salad
Cheese Pizza
Big Salad
Budlight

“For takeout pizza, this place is worth the 25 minutes I drive to get it. Dining in is usually reasonable service, but sometimes, even when the place had only a couple of other people dining in, you'll be forgotten at your booth. That said, the food is AWESOME! Can't go wrong with a pizza, calzone, dessert pizza, cinnamon balls (I don't remember what they're called), or the garlic cheese bread.“

3.8 Good60 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
1202 N State St, Greenfield - 8.3 miles

Customers` Favorites

Thin Crust Alfredo Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Garden Salad
Tater Tots
Lava Cake

“I started going to the Greenfield location because the New Castle IN location would get my order wrong 4 out of 5 times which is an accurate measurement. The Greenfield Domino's has been awesome. Thanks!Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pizza“

3.8 Good54 Reviews
Godfather's Pizza Express Pizza Takeaway • $$
6925 S Franklin Rd, Indianapolis - 7.83 miles

“I have been to this location a few times and LOVE the pizza here. I am originally from Nebraska where Godfather's originated. When I start to feel like I need a taste of home, I go here. Very comparable to the pizza from back home. We always call ahead to place our order and the pizza is always good and fresh. We always get a Taco Pizza and a pepperoni pizza.“

4 Good21 Reviews
GOD FATHERS PIZZA EXPRESS Pizza • $
8020 Brookville Rd, Indianapolis - 7.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Large Deluxe Cheese Pizza with 2 Toppings
Large Deluxe Cheese Pizza with 1 Topping
Ham Egg and Cheese Pizza Breakfast
All Meat Combo Pie
Classic Combo Pie
Buffalo Chicken
BBQ Chicken

“I love stopping at this particular godfathers pizza as well as this gas station. The employees are always so nice and I dare you to find a nicer and classier bunch of employees in the city as far as Shell stations go. And the pizza and chesters is fire. I even have Chinese food and it’s all clean the place is spotless.“

4.4 Superb9 Reviews
Pizza King Pizza • $
237 W Main St, Greenfield - 7.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Pepperoni Feast
Royal Fiesta Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Ham and Cheese
Sausage Pizza
Chef's Salad
Breadsticks
Salad Sub

“Greenfield Pizza King has an amazing staff. They were 3 people short tonight and still provided great service and kept a positive attitude. The manager was doing everything so the rest of the team could keep the food and drink coming to customers.“

3.7 Good71 Reviews
Randy's To Your Door Pizza • $
8602 Southeastern Ave, Indianapolis - 6.7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Randy's Special Pizza
Two Topping Pizza

“This is by far the BEST PIZZA I've had in Indiana and being from Florida, I would have to say this is the best quality, best value, most consistent, freshest ingredients, passionately made pizza I've ever had.My family has lived in the Wanamaker Estates area since the late '50s and they have been ordering Randy's for ever.I've heard about it all of my life but only got to try it for the first time about 5 months ago. I've gone and grabbed a pizza at least twice a month since! Great pizza, great service, great value, and great quality.The 16" is huge and feeds my sister and I for at least three separate meals if not four with us each eating 2-4 pieces at a time!I know there may be some not so great reviews about service, but we have NEVER had a bad experience. Just be kind, be patient, and have your order ready when you call and you will have a great experience.“

3.8 Good16 Reviews
Pizza King Pizza • $
12110 E Washington St, Indianapolis - 5.08 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Feast with BBQ Sauce
The Royal Feast Pizza
Pizza Barbecuesauce
Banana Peppers
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Bread
Chef's Salad
Breadsticks
Bread Stix
Side Salad

“I just want to say how extremely impressed I am with the crew who was working on Friday night, October 21. We ordered door dash, and decided to pick up instead of have it delivered because of the wait time for delivery after a kids’ school event. Upon arrival, we found our order had been missed at the Door Dash printer. I was pretty frustrated as I had a crew of young kids in the car who now had to wait and were hungry (and of course had to potty). The order then took even longer than we thought, so we had to wait for almost thirty minutes. Throughout the whole process, the front desk person, cooks, and manager were gracious, apologetic, helpful, and had amazing attitudes. They offered us cookies while we waited, and were incredibly friendly. I was so pleasantly surprised because it was extremely busy and they were also having to help a steady stream of customer coming in the door. I can’t remember the last time I had such great service at ANY restaurant, especially the local pizza place that has a lot of young staff. I hope they get the opportunity to read this, and know that because of their amazing service, hard work, and great attitudes, that they turned what could have been a one star experience into a five star review!“

3.6 Good97 Reviews

36
Sbarro

Sbarro Pizza •
990 S State St, Greenfield - 7.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

XL New York Style Pizza
Meat Primo
3.9 Good9 Reviews
Mozzi's Pizza Pizza • $
5875 US-40, Greenfield - 4.06 miles

“This is the best pizza in the Indianapolis area. This is not the place to be if you’re looking for fine authentic Italian but if you want something delicious and different than the norm this is the place to be. My food was brought to me promptly and all of the waitresses were extremely attendant. Courtney and Samara stood out to me the most. Samara sat me and got my drink and Courtney took my order and made me feel welcome. They are the epitome of what waitresses should be. Thank you Mozzi’s for being the best.“

3.7 Good17 Reviews
Loading...
map Map