“Shout out to Kari at the drive thru window and the whole staff at McAllisters. I was instructed by my wife to pick up a sandwich that was a add on to her catering order for today. I went to pick it up but it wasn't in their system. Kari and staff fulfilled the order anyway. Turns out the order my wife put in never went through. The order was for a Ruben sandwich. I typically don't order that but I will say it was DELICIOUS. The added brownie was icing. I'm glad McAllisters is part of the Newburgh community. Props to the staff as well!!!“
“Both the young man that made my two sandwiches today and the manager that gave me the buy one get one free sub sandwich today did a great job they were wonderful and kind professional and did a great job they deserve recognition and should get a raise! Great job guys!“
“This is a Subway and Noble Romans in one site. Talked us into personal pizzas from Noble's and said it would take same amount of time. My husband loved it. They used processed cheese which I don't care for. Next time I would honestly order the Subway pizza and get real cheese on it with more veggies but that's personal taste. Service was fast and efficient.“
“Stopped in to grab a sandwich on my way from Evansville to Owensboro. The staff was working very efficiently despite a busy lunch hour, and my sandwich was made exactly as ordered. I'm allergic to tomatoes and every Jimmy John's I've been in has taken extra precautions to avoid cross contamination. This location was no different. I really do appreciate the concern and dedication to keeping the customers safe.Dietary restrictions: Let them know if you have food allergies and they will take extra precautions. That small gesture is very much appreciated!“
“Insane customer service. I’ve been to high end restaurants that don’t even have this type of service. Truly.I don’t know the two guys who helped me out. But they were absolutely exceptional. The food was great, too!I HIGHLY recommend.“
“I used to live in Jersey. And I had never, ever seen any of these sub shops inland that were able to reproduce the subs that i'd experienced there. Jersey. Mike's has got it down. I will not go to any other sub shop in town. there are the only sub shop. That has pepper mash. I highly recommend trying the classic italian mike's way with pepper mash“
“The whole staff was amazing both times I went. The first time I went I was told to try a sandwich called "the Sergio". This last time I went the worker who created the sub was there and I had him make it for me.That sub should be on the menu it is that amazing!! Next time I go I'm definitely going in when he's working and I'm definitely having it again.“
“This was our first visit. My son, who doesn't usually like chicken salad, actually enjoyed his meal too. He had the bbq chicken salad on a croissant and a scoop of the classic. Both were delicious but the bbq was pleasantly unique. I ordered the Fancy Franny in a melt, also delicious. We both tried the grape salad, yum! We'll be back.“
“Great shout out to Penn station Newburgh!!!!! We go there often to get lunch for staff, I have to ask that fries be bagged separately because of a peanut allergy. This time I actually forgot, but the young lady inside remembered and came out with the bagged separately…Great customer service♥️“