Papa Johns Pizza

17023 Mercantile Blvd, Noblesville
(317) 773-9595

Recent Reviews

Sarah Carpenter-Simpson

It took another 50 minutes after my order was suppose to be ready. No garlic sent, ne cheese sent for breadsticks. The workers could not care less about how long everyone was waiting. 1 of them even had time to go take a break. As I am standing in the lobby with 9 other people waiting for our orders. Terrible service. Won't be back, terrible place to go if your wanting food within the next 1 1/2 hours.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Carolyn Cole

Ordered ahead of time for pickup and had to wait over 25 mins still. Usually better service but this time customers were somewhat ignored, and no order to taking care of us all.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 2

N C

Ordered a small pizza. Showed up with the right stickers on the box but the wrong pizza inside. Had me a new large pizza with an extra garlic butter in less than 40 minutes.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 4

Maria Broaddus

Don't order boneless wings here they will come out like this also my pizza was missing one topping that I paid for the sad thing is the order was double

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Anson Simque

Placed an order through door dash. Dasher showed up about 30 minutes after the order was placed. After letting the dasher wait another 30 minutes (an hour from order being placed) they just cancelled my order. Called them no one will answer the phone. Just close your doors!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Cameron Sinnett

Monday afternoon crew fishing out picture perfect products, nice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

brandi boillat

Website and app were not working for specials. Called customer service and they said could take up to 48 hours. Called the store and they can’t give the special prices in store, only online. Asked them if I could be reimbursed or compensated for having to pay full price and was told no by both the manager of the store and the customer service person. I did everything I could on my side and no one was willing to help. Wanting to save a few dollars should not be this hard!

Mark Fite

I understand gross margins, I’m a manager of home service company. But this is bad , no sauce , cheese and so much dough….. quality really lacking hereVegetarian options: No

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 5

L M

So the last few times I have been there food is ok. This very last time it gave me stomach issues and also left a rotten oil taste in my mouth and it was bad enough to make me want to gag. Not sure if they checked the items for being expired but I would. I don't think I am eating here anymore. The breadsticks taste ok other than they are super small and not really a breadstick length. I would not eat here if you have sensitive stomach. My family and their stomachs was also affected by the pizza order. Just be aware.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

William Chastain

Let me give some of you one star reviewers some advice. There is a thing called right place right time. How many Americans order pizza on a Friday night or weekend night? So you really expect everything to be up to a 5 star standard? You must be a clown. It’s a tough business. And before you try to argue that your order/experience was messed up for other reasons than it being busy, go try to work there on the usual nights you order pizza. Give them a break and order pizza when you know it won’t be busy from them. All these reviews claiming they aren’t what they used to be just never eat pizza for lunch. Go Karen someone else.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shannon Reitz

If you haven’t tried this Papa Johns in the last 6 months, you should really give it a try! Hands down, best service in town!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marilyn Gregory

Papa John’s is not a big ‘eat in’ restaurant so the atmosphere rating does not really apply but did not want to give a 0 rating

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jasmine Simmonds

He rang the ring doorbell and I told him my son is on the way downstairs to grab the food. Instead of waiting another second he puts the food on THE GROUND directly in front of our screen door..so guess what happened to the food. The chicken wings got knocked on the ground, inedible! Not to mention the chicken was supposed to be sauced...as you can see they are dry af, barely any sauce to be found. The Oreo dessert balls or whatever are pitiful as well. NEVER AGAIN. I should have ran when I saw the negative reviews before I ordered.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jazzy Jazz

He rang the ring doorbell and I told him my son is on the way downstairs to grab the food. Instead of waiting another second he puts the food on THE GROUND directly in front of our screen door..so guess what happened to the food. The chicken wings got knocked on the ground, inedible! Not to mention the chicken was supposed to be sauced...as you can see they are dry af, barely any sauce to be found. The Oreo dessert balls or whatever are pitiful as well. NEVER AGAIN. I should have ran when I saw the negative reviews before I ordered.

Jay Symone

He rang the ring doorbell and I told him my son is on the way downstairs to grab the food. Instead of waiting another second he puts the food on THE GROUND directly in front of our screen door..so guess what happened to the food. The chicken wings got knocked on the ground, inedible! Not to mention the chicken was supposed to be sauced...as you can see they are dry af, barely any sauce to be found. The Oreo dessert balls or whatever are pitiful as well. NEVER AGAIN. I should have ran when I saw the negative reviews before I ordered.

Load More