Pat-A-Cakes and Cookies Too

3204 IN-32, Westfield
(317) 867-9866

Recent Reviews

Spencer Faulkner

Margo is the best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mary Holladay

Love this local bakery! The cakes and cookies are delicious.

Carly Thompson

Amazing sweets for an awesome price! I love this bakery

Olivia O.

Hands down best classic cinnamon roll in town! Perfect ratio of icing and not too overpowering and perfect amount of "doneness". We always heat them up a little in the microwave but wow these are amazing! Still drooling just looking at the picture. I could easily eat three in one sitting because of how good they are and not too rich! Also their sugar cookies are top notch. Such a good bakery that I feel not many people know about. Go check them out!

Tina R.

Disappointed in my custom order cake. I just picked up my daughters birthday cake I'm pretty frustrated with its appearance. The cake that I said that I wanted had an ice cream scoop on top with frosting that looked like it was ice cream dripping down. This is just a (smashed) scoop of icing on top. I noticed there was a crack on the top of the cake (I know the cashier saw it too because it's right in front). I didn't say anything because I didn't want to complain and honestly I'm on a time crunch. -I know nothing could be done about it in time anyway. Now taking the cake out of the box, I see that the icing is cracked on all of the drips around the entire cake. It's almost as if the cake collapsed? Yes, I could've asked for a discount or for them to fix it, but I'm leery of businesses that are comfortable with presenting a custom order that is clearly unacceptable. I won't be going back. I was so excited to be ordering from them but this is not the experience that I was expecting to have or the product I was expecting to receive. If you have a special event and need a custom order cake, unfortunately, I'd advise going elsewhere. I've spent so much time, money, and energy to make this event special for my daughter, and having this cake as the centerpiece is a complete letdown.

Nicole F.

TASTED TERRIBLE AND OVERPRICED!!! My kiddos wanted to go for a little treat after school and we decided on Pat-Cakes. We got 2 deluxe decorated football shaped cookies ($2.95 each) and 2 bonbons. Our total was over $9. I knew the price when we made our selections, but not the lack of quality. They were all terrible. My kids took 2 bites and said it was the worst cookie they have ever had and I tried them and they were awful. The bonbons were edible, but wouldn't go back.

Rich D.

Both the people and the cookies are awesome. Always enjoy stopping by to pick up these wonderful desserts to share with friends and family on special occasions.

Robert Aroca

Great cookies at a reasonable price and very helpful staff! Will be my “go too” baker from now on.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookie Tray

Teia Givens

I had an all around great experience. The atmosphere was warm and inviting and the cake was pretty and delicious ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Scott P.

Chocolate cake is scrumptious! Moist cake with rich chocolate icing. The cookies are really good as well!

Annette Cousert

I ordered a lemon cake for my husband's retirement celebration. Lemon is his favorite and he is PICKY. He loved the cake. Everyone commented on the flavor and lightness of the cake and the whipped buttercream icing. This will be my go-to bakery for every occasion.

Elizabeth B.

I had a 1/2 sheet cake for my daughter's baby shower, not only was the design I requested perfect, the icing, well I could have just eaten that and been satisfied. It was delicious and definitely a hit at the party. I will definitely have them do desserts for all my future celebrations!

Gene Cosler

I bought a birthday cake for my wife last week and asked if it was fresh. I was told it was. When we ate it, I could tell it was not fresh. I bought it on Tuesday AM and they were closed on Sunday and Monday.

Amarie J

Very nice place it has a welcoming feel to it! Staff was very nice and attentive. The lemon cookie is one of my favorites. It was soft and very tasty. The carrot cake cookie was also good. My 2 year old loved the sprinkle cookie of course!

Jacqueline V.

I ordered a carrot cake for my sisters birthday asking for a dog decoration. She LOVED it!! Thank you so much. Report is that the cake was moist and not overly sweet, the frosting perfect. Only small critique was it was more like spice than carrot cake, but some carrot cakes are like that and she quite enjoyed it as it was!

Load More

Pat-A-Cakes and Cookies Too

3204 IN-32, Westfield, IN 46074
(317) 867-9866