Capriotti's Sandwich Shop

1508 US-41, Schererville
(219) 515-2187

Recent Reviews

Cynthia Archie

Excellent place to order for your next party or any

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

David K.

Ignore the old reviews, this shop is UNDER NEW MANAGEMENT. This is my favorite go to restaurant when I want a treat. Same order every time. Turkey sub hold the mayo hold the onion, add oil add easy red pepper relish. Warm the bread and meat. I'm picky, I know, but this young lady took my order without any confusion and delivered a perfect sandwich in less than 4 minutes to my table. It's difficult finding that much pride in the staff of most restaurants, especially a young person. I could tell they took pride in doing it right and not because anyone told them to. I watched the two bustling behind the counter. Cleaning the grill and busting out orders...FAST! I made sure to speak to the shift lead lady and extend my gratitude for the great experience. I hope management has noticed these ladys to keep them around a long time.

Dan G

Modern sandwich joint that puts a spin on some traditional sandwiches. The wagyu beef cheese steak sandwiches are good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Arthur B

Took a large party order online and charged my card, for thanksgiving. Thrn failed to inform me that they were closed and that the order would not be available. No call, no email. Got a verification email, no food.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

John Stemmelin (Axis 360 Media)

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop is a haven for sandwich lovers. Their subs are generously filled with fresh ingredients and creative combinations, making for a satisfying meal. The "Bobbie" with Thanksgiving-style turkey and cranberry sauce is a standout. The bread is soft, and the portions are hearty. While it's a fast-casual spot, the quality of their sandwiches is consistently high. If you're seeking a delicious, made-to-order sandwich, Capriotti's is a great choice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom 4writer

Great sandwiches. Staff was excellent. I ordered a try for a late pickup. I needed it for the next day. Everything was well wrapped. Drop on in and tell em TJ sent ya.

Food: 4

Service: 5

Steve Elliott

Arrived 5 minutes before closing and were never rushed or told to hurry. The food and service were both outstanding.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mike Lakie

My daughter and I went there around 11:30 today. They told us that because of a large online order, they weren't taking any other orders at the moment. They said to come back in an hour or two and maybe they would be ready for orders! Terrible service! It's lunchtime! You're seriously going to turn away paying customers?!

Service: 1

Woodworker24

Service was good both times we been there. The food was good and made to order.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Classic Cheese Steak

Alex R

Good food, but they seemed short staffed, which leads to waiting times.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: American Wagyu, Roast Beef

Matt Jones

Very Dissapointed in their food. Got the Bobby and Chicken Parm Sub with 2 Soups. Pricey and food was sub par. Chicken Noodle Soup was all broth no chicken and No Noodles. Tomato Bisque tasted like it came from a can. Chicken Parm sub was more like a minced meat sub. Bobby Sub was just pack with stuffing and hardly any Turkey. Oh yeah. Ordered the Meatball Sub as well. Took a bit and threw it away. Avoid...Avoid...AvoidOverpriced Subway

Food: 1

Service: 1

Michael Gulley

Food was good. Prices were fair. Only 2 workers. One was very slow. Dining room could have used a good cleaning.This was during a busy noon hour on a Saturday.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Katie Trezak

I ordered quite regularly for my family via Uber Eats. Now every single time I've tried ordering it says they're closed to any type of order. It's been 6 weeks!!! When are you coming back to Uber? You've got loyal fans that you're telling we don't matter.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Joseph

This was the worst cheesesteak sandwich I've ever had. It was dry, touch and it had little cheese.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Scott Pyle

I was at the Midwest Express Clinic next door. Regardless, I've heard good things about the wide variety of sandwiches. Also, there was constant foot traffic into this sandwich place at 230pm on a Sunday. That's the mark of a professional to me. HOORAY FOR SANDWICHES!!!

Load More