Papa Johns Pizza

114 Hometown Plz, Sellersburg
(812) 246-8000

Recent Reviews

Melinda Barnes

I always have the best experience at Papa John's. It's our families go-to pizza place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Traditional Wings

Sean Hehr

Everytime we order from here the pizza looks like thin crust and it isn't supposed to be.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

LaMicra Martin

Always delivered hot food.

Food: 4

Service: 4

Joshua Mason

It was Papa John's. Same as you would expect from any Papa John's.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: 10 Piece Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks

Dawn Walker

Papa John's good no matter what state you're in.

Food: 4

Service: 5

Carol Flynn

It doesn't take half an hour to get from Hamburg to next to the cemetery in Sellersburg. Driver admitted, "I typed in the wrong address." Pizza was lukewarm.....

Food: 1

Service: 1

Game Trip

Ordered at 4pm notified it would be about 25 minutes. Got there 15 minutes after it said it would be ready and they told me 15 more minutes! It's actually my fault for trusting these

Service: 1

B T.

I don't know why people still order pizza from Papa Johns. I guess b/c they deliver. Their pizzas suck. There are too many bare areas with no cheese. Is cheese THAT expensive? Even getting extra cheese is barely enough cheese. Save your money, get frozen pizzas and sprinkle a little extra mozzerella on them. You'll save alot of money.

Kendal Roberts

The pizza I ordered was incorrect. The manager "credited" my account and when I went to order with the credit on my account the other manager said it was already claimed. Awful customer service and the manager didn't even look into the situation. Not wasting anymore money here for disgusting pizza and staff. Will order from the local pizza restaurant now and get better service AND pizza.

Stephen Pinkston

Pizza was hot and fresh and ready when I arrived. They always seem to have great deals on their website too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jess Lo

Papa John's has good pizza and almost always hot and fresh! Employees at this location are almost always friendly. They are slow moving from time to time

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Brownie

David L Hughes

Family loves Papa John's and the value for our money is an added bonus!!

Kenny Clemons

Online ordering is not simple. After ordering, then it asks you to join rewards. I don't want to. No option. Finally, I call my order in and get a person in a call center. I'm hard of hearing, so the accent makes it harder to understand. Get my order through, then, wife gets the order, but no 2 liter is with it. Says 2 liter of orange crush on my box, why not on delivery guys? Call back, it's now been 27 minutes with no drink. Big fail on Papa John. But, they already got my tip. Tipped for bad service. Never again..

David L. Hughes

Family loves Papa John's and the value for our money is an added bonus!!

Blaise Kist

The service was horrible. Told me the wrong time about my food and others as well. They confused a lot of people and lost many angry customers.

Load More