This place was not ok....I didn't know what too expect seemed small town friendly come to find the staff is rude and the pizza was dry it seemed almost stale if that's a better description.
Shanna S
This is the only pizza place in town we order from! It's our favorite!We usually eat woody's atleast 2 times a week. ? Love it!Woody's has been around for 20+ years! They are very consistent and always our go to!Very friendly workers!Sometimes we want things done a special way and they never hesitate to do it! You've got to give it a try!Wheelchair accessibility: Flat surfaces, easy to get into.Dietary restrictions: When I did Keto, the crustless pizza was amazing! They do it however you'd like!
My favorite pizza place, hands down. Never had anything bad come from Woody's. I have been known to travel pretty far in my life to get Woody's. BEST PIZZA in Indiana, and possibly the entire U.S.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Big John Pizza, Four Toppings Pizza, Stuffed Breadsticks, One Topping Pizza, Breadsticks
peter pinkham
This is the kind of nice, family run business that deserves your patronage! A modest but well rounded menu, and all the food is freshly prepared... We got a pizza and it was delicious! We also tested a smoothie that I urged them to go ahead and sell as part of their regular menu. The place is right on the main drag, and has a very comfortable vibe. Stop in, you'll not be disappointed! ? For sure, and worth the trip! Prices are very reasonable as well...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deluxe Pizza
Kacy Varvel
Love Woody's!!!!! Used to get it all the time when we lived in Sheridan. Now living in Indy, we go whenever we're close. Always good! No extra cheese needed and plenty of toppings! Our fav!
matt mosier
Excellent pizza. We get the meat lovers, and it is filled with a lot of stuff. Very reasonably priced. They deliver quick and are friendly.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deluxe Pizza
Jodi Houghton
Excellent pizza; highly recommended. Small mishap made right; went above and beyond. Happy to support this hometown business.
Best breadsticks I’ve ever had and the service was amazing couldn’t have asked for anything better.
Lance Williams
Ordered a pizza at 8 o'clock they told me they stopped delivery service at 8pm so I said that's fine I'll pick it up,they said it would be ready at 825-830 went in at 8:35 paid for the pizza, about 5 till 9 I asked them what the status was and it was just going in the oven ,finally got my pizza about 10 after 9 undercooked and pale, took it home and finished putting it in the air fryer so we could eat it,no apologies on their part,not sure what's going on certainly not like them normally
James Lewis
Best Pizza in town by far!!!!!
Lance Williams
Best pizza in Sheridan hands down and good prices too !!!! Favorite is the Western
Shantay Dautrich
Came to sheridan to visit family just to eat this pizza. It is so good! Highly recommend!
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place was not ok....I didn't know what too expect seemed small town friendly come to find the staff is rude and the pizza was dry it seemed almost stale if that's a better description.
This is the only pizza place in town we order from! It's our favorite!We usually eat woody's atleast 2 times a week. ? Love it!Woody's has been around for 20+ years! They are very consistent and always our go to!Very friendly workers!Sometimes we want things done a special way and they never hesitate to do it! You've got to give it a try!Wheelchair accessibility: Flat surfaces, easy to get into.Dietary restrictions: When I did Keto, the crustless pizza was amazing! They do it however you'd like!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, Deluxe Pizza, BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza, Boneless Wings, One Topping Pizza, Breadsticks, Cheese Pizza, Taco Pizza, Ultimate Meat Lovers Pizza
Best pizza in sheridan!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My favorite pizza place, hands down. Never had anything bad come from Woody's. I have been known to travel pretty far in my life to get Woody's. BEST PIZZA in Indiana, and possibly the entire U.S.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Big John Pizza, Four Toppings Pizza, Stuffed Breadsticks, One Topping Pizza, Breadsticks
This is the kind of nice, family run business that deserves your patronage! A modest but well rounded menu, and all the food is freshly prepared... We got a pizza and it was delicious! We also tested a smoothie that I urged them to go ahead and sell as part of their regular menu. The place is right on the main drag, and has a very comfortable vibe. Stop in, you'll not be disappointed! ? For sure, and worth the trip! Prices are very reasonable as well...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deluxe Pizza
Love Woody's!!!!! Used to get it all the time when we lived in Sheridan. Now living in Indy, we go whenever we're close. Always good! No extra cheese needed and plenty of toppings! Our fav!
Excellent pizza. We get the meat lovers, and it is filled with a lot of stuff. Very reasonably priced. They deliver quick and are friendly.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deluxe Pizza
Excellent pizza; highly recommended. Small mishap made right; went above and beyond. Happy to support this hometown business.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best breadsticks I’ve ever had and the service was amazing couldn’t have asked for anything better.
Ordered a pizza at 8 o'clock they told me they stopped delivery service at 8pm so I said that's fine I'll pick it up,they said it would be ready at 825-830 went in at 8:35 paid for the pizza, about 5 till 9 I asked them what the status was and it was just going in the oven ,finally got my pizza about 10 after 9 undercooked and pale, took it home and finished putting it in the air fryer so we could eat it,no apologies on their part,not sure what's going on certainly not like them normally
Best Pizza in town by far!!!!!
Best pizza in Sheridan hands down and good prices too !!!! Favorite is the Western
Came to sheridan to visit family just to eat this pizza. It is so good! Highly recommend!