6 Best Bakeries near Shipshewana

“the cupcakes were life changing, very moist and great flavor“

“Delicious buffet style dinner, we had fried chicken, shrimp, sweet corn, green beans, salads of many kinds, and desserts, all included in the dinner buffet.The staff is the greatest, they're always checking your drinks, and to make sure your visit is the best it can possibly be. We eat there at least once everytime were in Shipshewana.“

“I didn’t know it was cash only and when I was $6.00 short, I tried to put something back but another customer insisted I had to have it, and offered to pay for it. As I waited for my items to be bagged, the customer tried to pay but the owner motioned “no” and didn’t take her money so she gave it to me for free. They were the best cinnamon rolls and peanut butter cookies I’ve had in a long time and the customer service was over and beyond.“

“My son wanted these for his wedding instead of cake. We order 100 hand pies and picked them up the day before the wedding, approximately a 3 hour (6 hours)drive there and back. He was married June 3, 2023 and they were amazing. I would do it again all over.“

“Staff is pleasant and patient (with so many Yummy options, it's tough to choose). The treats are out of this world goodness, very fresh. I'm so happy they decided to open up this store for convenience instead of having to drive to Shipshewana for a donut or two or a boxful.“

“We were undecided about buffet or sit down dining. The staff allowed us to look at buffet and the menu for sit down as well. Buffet looked good but we chose sit down. I had the creamed chicken over biscuits and mashed potatoes. I ordered the small portion, which was pretty big. The biscuits were delicious and fluffy. The mashed potatoes were great as well. BF had the same but with egg noodles and mashed potatoes. Noodles were great as well. We were served rolls, we only ate the whole wheat and took white with us. BF also had the beets, which were amazing, not acidic, but sweet. Would definitely recommend“