Good pizza but the hours are so Goofy I never go because it doesn't work with my schedule
William Decoudres
Pizza was good, but being charged a 4% fee for using a card is definitely not cool. I understand if I was a small amount but when your over $80 that's bs
Melodie Nickerson
A couple of weeks ago, our order was given away to the wrong person. They gave us a paper entitling us to a free pizza and chippers. We called tonight an hour before the time listed on the website and was told "sorry were closed" ARE YOU KIDDING ME?? WHAT A JOKE OF A BUSINESS!!!!!
Jmacole
Not good! I ordered a 2-topping 14-inch pizza. Slightly burnt. I will not be returning!
Mike
I have never had a bad pizza from Starlight, but this was bad. It was so greasy I had to use 4 napkins just to get some of the grease off of it. I will not be going back to this one on Crumbstown.
Ben Reese
Best pizza & pierogi in town along with friendly service!
Patrick Melton
Best Pizza in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda Macias
The older lady that was working tonight was so kind and went above and beyond on my customized order. All while also training another lady who’s first day was today. Love this place.
Donna Popovic
Pizza nit as good as it used to be. Sauce is very sweet.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Percy Reed
Tomato paste real sweet this was gross never again
I’ve heard good things about Starlite and wanted to give it a try. We ordered a medium pizza and two salads for $30, which seems astronomical. The pizza was lackluster but okay tasting. We ordered salads with no onion or pepper, yet got salads with no tomatoes, peppers, onions, or black olives. We’ve just moved back into the area and are sad to say we will not be returning to Starlite.
Joy Hurd
Newer to SB and found starlite pizza about 6 months ago, fell in love with the food! It became our new go to. Tonight, we placed an order online and waited at least 30 minutes before we headed to pick it up per our online confirmation. When we went in to pick up we were warned by another customer with a "good luck". Quickly found out that our food wasn't ready (1 cheese pizza) an older woman snarkily said it's not ready yet we just got your order. We replied that we placed the order over 30 minutes ago and came in when we were instructed. While saying this we were interrupted by a man in the back who yelled "I'm the only one making Starlite pizzas tonight so it's gonna be a while!" The older woman then changed her story and said she actually just now handed him the online order. We asked if there was a better way to order and she told us to call the phone number. We had to wait almost an extra 20 minutes for our 1 pizza.It was all very rude, if we get Starlite again it will be from another location. I shouldn't feel like a burden as a customer and if online ordering doesn't work correctly, disable it.Gets two stars because the pizza was still good.
Stacia Weaver
Not sure who the newer employees are, especially the older lady, but they are VERY RUDE! Food was NASTY and inedible! Prices are a rip off for the quality/quantity of food! That's the LAST time I give them my money!
Dawn Keiser
The pizza is always amazing!
Joey Reed
Not good! Pizza one topping was 20$ the sauce is just tomato paste. Slightly burnt. I was very dissatisfied. No flavor and cheap cheese.
Good pizza but the hours are so Goofy I never go because it doesn't work with my schedule
Pizza was good, but being charged a 4% fee for using a card is definitely not cool. I understand if I was a small amount but when your over $80 that's bs
A couple of weeks ago, our order was given away to the wrong person. They gave us a paper entitling us to a free pizza and chippers. We called tonight an hour before the time listed on the website and was told "sorry were closed" ARE YOU KIDDING ME?? WHAT A JOKE OF A BUSINESS!!!!!
Not good! I ordered a 2-topping 14-inch pizza. Slightly burnt. I will not be returning!
I have never had a bad pizza from Starlight, but this was bad. It was so greasy I had to use 4 napkins just to get some of the grease off of it. I will not be going back to this one on Crumbstown.
Best pizza & pierogi in town along with friendly service!
Best Pizza in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The older lady that was working tonight was so kind and went above and beyond on my customized order. All while also training another lady who’s first day was today. Love this place.
Pizza nit as good as it used to be. Sauce is very sweet.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Tomato paste real sweet this was gross never again
Restaurantji Recommends
I’ve heard good things about Starlite and wanted to give it a try. We ordered a medium pizza and two salads for $30, which seems astronomical. The pizza was lackluster but okay tasting. We ordered salads with no onion or pepper, yet got salads with no tomatoes, peppers, onions, or black olives. We’ve just moved back into the area and are sad to say we will not be returning to Starlite.
Newer to SB and found starlite pizza about 6 months ago, fell in love with the food! It became our new go to. Tonight, we placed an order online and waited at least 30 minutes before we headed to pick it up per our online confirmation. When we went in to pick up we were warned by another customer with a "good luck". Quickly found out that our food wasn't ready (1 cheese pizza) an older woman snarkily said it's not ready yet we just got your order. We replied that we placed the order over 30 minutes ago and came in when we were instructed. While saying this we were interrupted by a man in the back who yelled "I'm the only one making Starlite pizzas tonight so it's gonna be a while!" The older woman then changed her story and said she actually just now handed him the online order. We asked if there was a better way to order and she told us to call the phone number. We had to wait almost an extra 20 minutes for our 1 pizza.It was all very rude, if we get Starlite again it will be from another location. I shouldn't feel like a burden as a customer and if online ordering doesn't work correctly, disable it.Gets two stars because the pizza was still good.
Not sure who the newer employees are, especially the older lady, but they are VERY RUDE! Food was NASTY and inedible! Prices are a rip off for the quality/quantity of food! That's the LAST time I give them my money!
The pizza is always amazing!
Not good! Pizza one topping was 20$ the sauce is just tomato paste. Slightly burnt. I was very dissatisfied. No flavor and cheap cheese.