Joe's Ice Cream Supreme Shop

1201 S Huntington St, Syracuse
(574) 457-8763

Recent Reviews

Mark Owen

This is a great place to stop for Ice cream. If you order the banana split, make sure you bring a friend. It's enough for two.

Hannah G.

It's nice to see Joe's open because it means it's summertime! But it's slow service and expensive for Hudsonville ice cream. But they do make there waffle cones fresh, so that's a plus. It's a hit or miss, if they will be actually open.

Rich Pardy

It's too good that the lines are usually long but worth the wait!!

Samantha Sinn

Wait times are always long but the service and ice cream is so worth it.

Kari Smith

They have chai on the menu and told my boyfriend they don't serve it anymore

Wanda Parris

People are really friendly and great ice cream

Sagan Stier

Friendly staff and delicious ice cream! I tried the pineapple shake, Soo good! They use fresh ingredients and mix the shakes the old fashioned way. A necessary staple when visiting Syracuse, IN!

Rob Harrison

Nothing but good things to say about this place. It’s always fantastic. Banana splits are huge and cheap, the chocolate covered cherry sundae is amazing. Malts are fantastic too!

Allison Kuipers

They have so many handed ice creams to choose from they also have a drive-thru I like going and getting their Turtles Sunday is huge and only $6 whipped cream and cherry on top included

Stephanie Thomas

Great hand dipped banana split!!

Scott Babcock

First time there and we loved it! Nice little place!

Josh B

It’s got good ice cream but slowest service I’ve ever experienced. 25 minutes to move through 4 cars. No excuse for that.

AJ M.

Joe's is a staple for summertime in Syracuse / Lake Wawasee. They source their hand dipped ice cream from a great spot - it's always tasty.They have razzles, which are equivalent to Blizzards or McFlurries, and you can pretty much customize them to your liking. We appreciated them taking our unique combo requests this weekend.The high school aged kids that typically serve you are always well trained and quick at their work.Usually a long line between 8-9pm on a holiday weekend.

Richard Page

Good ice cream, great value

Mike W

If you are ever in Syracuse Indiana you need to stop by at this ice cream place. They have the best soft serve and hard ice cream. Try the two people banana split and so many flavors I can’t list them all!!!

Load More