Behind the Times Bakery

411 Main St, Tell City
(812) 772-2095

Recent Reviews

Chad Miller

I started coming here faithfully about a week ago. I am more of a gas station kind of coffee guy. Never really thought coffee should cost an arm and a leg. Plus, I always made jokes at high end coffee spot to give me the coffee Jesus drank. But Behind in time made a believer out of me. I love there snickerdoodle hot coffee. It brings me back to when I would have coffee and cookies with my Nana. One of the reasons I believe it's name. Plus the way the coffee is made fresh each time. You can tell the owner cares because with everything going up in price. She stays the same price. She stated a fact, they would rather the coffee stay the same price and you come back 5 times instead of raising the price and only seeing you 1 or 2 times a week. You have to come try this place out. Java coffee, time to step up your game.Parking: Park in front of coffee shop or across the street.Kid-friendliness: No Rated R here.Wheelchair accessibility: Plenty of room to get around.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Snicker Doodle

Dakota Brumfield

Good lattes, and the pastries are awesome!

Nancy Weedman

The cutest shop with an amazing menu and even better service!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Scones

Kassidy Weedman

great coffee, and even better service! the energy and the ladies are top tier! ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

brad harding

Sweet tooth..decent coffee

Melayna Garrett

We ordered a cake for our wedding & they put the wrong letters, so instead of Congratulations T & M, it read Congratulations P & M. It was ALL in brown because they said they didn't have time to do any decorations. They couldn't switch colors for the writing??!! And the cake was SO rich no one could finish a small slice. Horrible!!

Kayla Fehribach

Had the Pig & Pimento sandwich, I've never had one before. It was great. This is small shop has a cozy vintage atmosphere I simply adored. The stuff was small, but overabundance with small town charms. Can't wait to go back.

Caroline Thomas

If you’re down for a breezy drive to a sleepy quiet cute town for some dang good food this is a stop for you. The biscuits were fluffy. The scones were crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The pancakes were cake like. Everything was fantastic. Just like momma and grandma made and like no one makes it anymore really! The decor was old fashioned like visiting meemaw or nana and I loved it. I left absolutely stuffed and I have ZERO regrets.

Leah Marie Walker

Love this bakery so much. The brown sugar rhubarb pastry is so delicious. Orange cardamom coffee cake was fantastic. The mini chocolate cake with buttercream & caramel sauce was so rich that it lasted me 4 days.

Monster Ford

Stayed across the street made my way over ,phenomenal service huge cinnamon rolls and biscuits and gravy. All great food. But please get some canned soda or something I need mountain dew in the morning lmao.

Tiffany Rasche

Delicious cookies and the staff is always so polite and helpful!

S. Michelle Noffsinger

You have to stop in.. so adorable with bakery items at its best.

Shelley Blackwell

Great menu - different and creative. Beautiful location and open early. I very much enjoyed stopping for a quick hot breakfast.

Clara M

The only place I have ever been where the food didn't just take a long time, but the order was never even given to the kitchen. After a very long wait we went to the counter for a refund and the cook said, "I didn't even know you ordered."

Amanda Dearborn

Amazing place to buy local foods, gifts and coffee.

Load More