We ordered a pizza 1 hour early due to the wait of a deep dish. We arrived with a pizza that had toppings we did not order. Greeted with unprofessional staff.When we ordered early, we were told that we could sit and dine, but then we were told that it was to go. Please know that this place is huge (sat night) and only three families dining there and that was all. The staff was rude and unprofessional. Disgusting atmosphere. Somebody is running this place into the ground.
Jason Creighton
Best classic Sauce. Take a jar home, also Best Meatballs, 4oz order extra. Meatball trays avail. Wherever we take them, everyone loves them. Worth every $$. Pizza is loved by locals, deep dish best fully loaded. Breadsticks with red sauce, and garlic butter dipping also a fav of our family. ENJOY.
John Gorecki
For me being an outsider, or at least a recurring visitor, Tony's is a longstanding icon of Valpo. Travelling here since the early 1980s, I have many fond memories of pizza and great times with family and friends. So long as the doors remain open, I will return to Tony's any trip I make to the region. Thanks for everything!
Kevin Troyer
Yummy food ?, stuffed shells very tasty
Tony Avalos
Food and service is OK, took awhile for our food it was hot,. One servicer, Remember Cash ONLY.No Miller products,? Very dark inside. Only thing good was the half meals. Just enough food for seniors and a fair price.
Azilain
The interior decorations are gaudy and the place generally feels filthy: a 2x4 wooden board holds up a piece of the ceiling, broken LED lights are strung up on the rafters (It does not help the extremely dim lights). By the way, this is an Italian place, and it's decorate like a hunting lodge--does it feel appropriate to be looking at mounted deer and elk heads when eating *Italian* food? The bathrooms, while nice and clean, do not match the feel for this place. It is obvious that the owners do not spend a single cent on the physical location, as evident by its ugly exterior. The waitstaff was off-putting and awkward; the service was extremely slow. Our food was mediocre: the pizza was greasy, my girlfriend's pasta tasted bland, and the Italian beef was about the same. Based off my experience, I would personally not recommend anybody go to Tony's Place to dine.
Shaun C
Tony's has been around forever and there's so many reasons why. Yes they are old school yes the place looks the same since I was a kid going there and yes the food is still AMAZING!!!!! No fu-fu Italian food here just the best Homemade recipe Italian in NWI.Tony's has been around forever and will stay around.
Mike Goggans
It was probably a fluke because there was apparently “ two parties “ thereBut we waited for. 1 hour and 45 minutes for our food which never came. Because we ended up leaving.Honestly super dissatisfied considering people after us and they got their food.We didn’t order anything complex just a pizza and some pasta.Parking: Street / parking lot parking
Megan Catherine
Great place if you're looking for good pizza or pasta at a reasonable price! Service is always good, food is always good.
Iris F.
The thin pizza was really great, delicious. I also enjoyed exploring the decor, especially with the festive decorations.
waitresses we're too busy. still good pizza. been going there a long time.
Mattjo212
My Wife and I were very disappointed with Tony's Pizza. I ordered a crispy pizza to go and it was more on the burnt side and bland. We think Tony's needs a new cook. We won't be going there again. You need some positive changes Tony! Good luck!
Rachelle Cassatt
The place needs an update. There are so many things I would love to change about this place.Plating, the menu, the fact that it says NO CREDIT CARDS everywhere, the serving sizes(the stuffed shells is two stuffed shells and like a full cup of sauce), the bathrooms.It doesn't look open from the outside, I doubled checked online that they were.It just feels very cheesy and old.It has great bones and I would love to visit again after a little TLC
Jerry W.
One of the worst pizzas's ever eaten !!!! Stuffed pizza! Sauce is very bitter. Not enough cheese on it. Skimpy on the Italian Sausage plus no taste to it. Too much dough on the edges. Even the worst pizzas in Chicago are way better ! NEVER AGAIN !!!!
Delia T.
This place is garbage! As soon as you walk in it smells!!! The smell of old dirty second hand store!!! The hostess did not greet you at all!! They were worried about seating me in a dark corner table, which I told her to seat us somewhere else. She did but with an attitude!!! We sat down and there was food around our table and the seats were sticky. Not only that they said no credit cards, no debit only only local checks. We are in 2022!!! Oh then the hostess said there's an ATM. We left because who knows how old the food is in this horrible smelly place!!!
We ordered a pizza 1 hour early due to the wait of a deep dish. We arrived with a pizza that had toppings we did not order. Greeted with unprofessional staff.When we ordered early, we were told that we could sit and dine, but then we were told that it was to go. Please know that this place is huge (sat night) and only three families dining there and that was all. The staff was rude and unprofessional. Disgusting atmosphere. Somebody is running this place into the ground.
Best classic Sauce. Take a jar home, also Best Meatballs, 4oz order extra. Meatball trays avail. Wherever we take them, everyone loves them. Worth every $$. Pizza is loved by locals, deep dish best fully loaded. Breadsticks with red sauce, and garlic butter dipping also a fav of our family. ENJOY.
For me being an outsider, or at least a recurring visitor, Tony's is a longstanding icon of Valpo. Travelling here since the early 1980s, I have many fond memories of pizza and great times with family and friends. So long as the doors remain open, I will return to Tony's any trip I make to the region. Thanks for everything!
Yummy food ?, stuffed shells very tasty
Food and service is OK, took awhile for our food it was hot,. One servicer, Remember Cash ONLY.No Miller products,? Very dark inside. Only thing good was the half meals. Just enough food for seniors and a fair price.
The interior decorations are gaudy and the place generally feels filthy: a 2x4 wooden board holds up a piece of the ceiling, broken LED lights are strung up on the rafters (It does not help the extremely dim lights). By the way, this is an Italian place, and it's decorate like a hunting lodge--does it feel appropriate to be looking at mounted deer and elk heads when eating *Italian* food? The bathrooms, while nice and clean, do not match the feel for this place. It is obvious that the owners do not spend a single cent on the physical location, as evident by its ugly exterior. The waitstaff was off-putting and awkward; the service was extremely slow. Our food was mediocre: the pizza was greasy, my girlfriend's pasta tasted bland, and the Italian beef was about the same. Based off my experience, I would personally not recommend anybody go to Tony's Place to dine.
Tony's has been around forever and there's so many reasons why. Yes they are old school yes the place looks the same since I was a kid going there and yes the food is still AMAZING!!!!! No fu-fu Italian food here just the best Homemade recipe Italian in NWI.Tony's has been around forever and will stay around.
It was probably a fluke because there was apparently “ two parties “ thereBut we waited for. 1 hour and 45 minutes for our food which never came. Because we ended up leaving.Honestly super dissatisfied considering people after us and they got their food.We didn’t order anything complex just a pizza and some pasta.Parking: Street / parking lot parking
Great place if you're looking for good pizza or pasta at a reasonable price! Service is always good, food is always good.
The thin pizza was really great, delicious. I also enjoyed exploring the decor, especially with the festive decorations.
Restaurantji Recommends
waitresses we're too busy. still good pizza. been going there a long time.
My Wife and I were very disappointed with Tony's Pizza. I ordered a crispy pizza to go and it was more on the burnt side and bland. We think Tony's needs a new cook. We won't be going there again. You need some positive changes Tony! Good luck!
The place needs an update. There are so many things I would love to change about this place.Plating, the menu, the fact that it says NO CREDIT CARDS everywhere, the serving sizes(the stuffed shells is two stuffed shells and like a full cup of sauce), the bathrooms.It doesn't look open from the outside, I doubled checked online that they were.It just feels very cheesy and old.It has great bones and I would love to visit again after a little TLC
One of the worst pizzas's ever eaten !!!! Stuffed pizza! Sauce is very bitter. Not enough cheese on it. Skimpy on the Italian Sausage plus no taste to it. Too much dough on the edges. Even the worst pizzas in Chicago are way better ! NEVER AGAIN !!!!
This place is garbage! As soon as you walk in it smells!!! The smell of old dirty second hand store!!! The hostess did not greet you at all!! They were worried about seating me in a dark corner table, which I told her to seat us somewhere else. She did but with an attitude!!! We sat down and there was food around our table and the seats were sticky. Not only that they said no credit cards, no debit only only local checks. We are in 2022!!! Oh then the hostess said there's an ATM. We left because who knows how old the food is in this horrible smelly place!!!