My wedding cake turned out amazing! Callie was up to the challenge of doing a half wedding cake half Spider-Man cake. She did amazing, and the cake tasted so good! Thank you for being a part of my big day!
Maureen Hoard
Can’t say enough about how great our cake order was. Great customer service and the cake was perfect both looking and taste ☺️?
Holly Plew
We ordered butter cookies for our coffee hour after the Sunday school Christmas program and they were a huge hit! We had lots of church members ask where they came from and I was happy to recommend Toy Ann’s Sweeterie! Hope to try more things in the future.
debbie mrotek
I ordered 60 cupcakes for a 30th birthday party in the shape of 30.and they looked like roses .they were light pink with a little gold.. they were beautiful and delicious! 3 different flavors! Everyone said how pretty they were and really delicious! We have been ordering for years and never disappointed! ?
Amanda Runion
Best cakes ever!!!! They are very nice and great with littles and involve them.
Natalie Mazur
Cute little bakery! Tried the chocolate chip cookies and a malt cupcake with strawberry frosting. Highly recommend. Cookies are soft and packed with chocolate chips. is a must try. Great prices too. Added bonus: little containers of leftover icing.
Vanessa Powers
They did my wedding cake 2 weeks ago. I had to call 3-5 times over probably 2-4 weeks to call back each time I needed to talk to them. They either wouldnt pick up or they said they would call me back and never did. I wanted to sample a few before we chose the flavor and I called in for a tasting. The day I went they were running an hour late and they said they already had another tasting scheduled and so I could only just pick up the cupcakes. They were somehow shocked that I wanted a tasting. I took time out of work for that day for the "tasting"Very stressful working with them.The cake was good and done well, but I wouldnt use them again.
Eugene K
Yucky ucky. Me no likey.
H Brown
This bakery wasn't professional at all. I was so disappointed by what I got.
Raney Clark
I ordered a birthday cake for my son last year and it was delicious! I wanted to get something small for my dad’s birthday so decided on personalized cut-out sugar cookies. They turned out amazing as well! Everything was beautifully decorated! Thank you Toy Ann’s!!
Had my family over for dinner for the first time since quarantine. It was all Toy. Her chicken pot pies and her banana bread. Absolutely delicious. How have I lived back in Valpo for three years and not enjoyed her baking? Highly, highly recommend. Very reasonably priced and her pie crust...the best.
Melissa Barajas
They make beautiful delicious cakes and are so easy to work with. Highly recommend!
Crystal Requena
A huge shout out to Toy Anne's for the amazing Gabby's Dollshouse themed strawberry cake they made this year and for the previous cakes I've bought from them.I've been going to them for a year now for about 5 different cakes and they always taste so fresh and delicious and have the best communication and friendly service! I already can't wait for the next one ?
Freddy Requena
Awesome cakes!
Abigail Sigler
Toy Ann's did both our wedding cake and cupcakes and everything was amazing! Our cake was beautiful and delicious and our guests are still talking about how good the cupcakes were. They were very generous and made the entire process so easy. I highly recommend Toy Ann's, and we will definitely be ordering from them in the future!
My wedding cake turned out amazing! Callie was up to the challenge of doing a half wedding cake half Spider-Man cake. She did amazing, and the cake tasted so good! Thank you for being a part of my big day!
Can’t say enough about how great our cake order was. Great customer service and the cake was perfect both looking and taste ☺️?
We ordered butter cookies for our coffee hour after the Sunday school Christmas program and they were a huge hit! We had lots of church members ask where they came from and I was happy to recommend Toy Ann’s Sweeterie! Hope to try more things in the future.
I ordered 60 cupcakes for a 30th birthday party in the shape of 30.and they looked like roses .they were light pink with a little gold.. they were beautiful and delicious! 3 different flavors! Everyone said how pretty they were and really delicious! We have been ordering for years and never disappointed! ?
Best cakes ever!!!! They are very nice and great with littles and involve them.
Cute little bakery! Tried the chocolate chip cookies and a malt cupcake with strawberry frosting. Highly recommend. Cookies are soft and packed with chocolate chips. is a must try. Great prices too. Added bonus: little containers of leftover icing.
They did my wedding cake 2 weeks ago. I had to call 3-5 times over probably 2-4 weeks to call back each time I needed to talk to them. They either wouldnt pick up or they said they would call me back and never did. I wanted to sample a few before we chose the flavor and I called in for a tasting. The day I went they were running an hour late and they said they already had another tasting scheduled and so I could only just pick up the cupcakes. They were somehow shocked that I wanted a tasting. I took time out of work for that day for the "tasting"Very stressful working with them.The cake was good and done well, but I wouldnt use them again.
Yucky ucky. Me no likey.
This bakery wasn't professional at all. I was so disappointed by what I got.
I ordered a birthday cake for my son last year and it was delicious! I wanted to get something small for my dad’s birthday so decided on personalized cut-out sugar cookies. They turned out amazing as well! Everything was beautifully decorated! Thank you Toy Ann’s!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Had my family over for dinner for the first time since quarantine. It was all Toy. Her chicken pot pies and her banana bread. Absolutely delicious. How have I lived back in Valpo for three years and not enjoyed her baking? Highly, highly recommend. Very reasonably priced and her pie crust...the best.
They make beautiful delicious cakes and are so easy to work with. Highly recommend!
A huge shout out to Toy Anne's for the amazing Gabby's Dollshouse themed strawberry cake they made this year and for the previous cakes I've bought from them.I've been going to them for a year now for about 5 different cakes and they always taste so fresh and delicious and have the best communication and friendly service! I already can't wait for the next one ?
Awesome cakes!
Toy Ann's did both our wedding cake and cupcakes and everything was amazing! Our cake was beautiful and delicious and our guests are still talking about how good the cupcakes were. They were very generous and made the entire process so easy. I highly recommend Toy Ann's, and we will definitely be ordering from them in the future!