6 Best Pizza Restaurants near Winona Lake

“We worked with Lauren to create a large carry out order for an off-site work meeting and loved it! The food was great, service was wonderful, and we were happy to be able to support a local business.Dietary restrictions: We were able to customize dishes to accommodate vegan, vegetarian, and other special diets.“

“We love to eat at places that aren't close by our home as we're traveling. So on the way back from Shipshewana, we stopped by Gambies for pizza.OH MY GOODNESS!! Such awesome pizza!!So we're planning another trip up north but unfortunately they won't be open. However i wanted to put in a good review for this place because they deserve it!!We love our pizza with thin crust, but not a cracker and Gambies was perfect!!The ingredients tasted fresh, pizza was hot and the service was polite. All this with fair prices! And for those who are concerned with parking, there is plenty close to the door. I'd also say this place is kid friendly as the employee was very kind & friendly.Y'ALL MUST TRY THIS PIZZA if you haven't!! You'll be glad you did!!My point regret is not ordering extra pizzas to freeze!!!“

“Located in an historic building tucked in between Big and Little Barbee Lakes Barbee Hotels offers an elevated supper club experience with fine dining flourishes with a speakeasy ambiance. There are many menu items you would expect and a few you might not. I chose their Scallops Rockefeller - a dish I hadn't seen offered anywhere before. It was seriously delicious! The service was impeccable (thanks Holly!). We had a great evening.“

“It is in a gas station, and it's a good place to order your pizza and take it back to the house or camper and eat it. Way to many people coming and going for me. It has really good food, that's for sure. Give it a try, and it is not disappointing.Wheelchair accessibility: It is in a gas station.“

“I can tell you the Elmo's in N. Webster Indiana was fantastic. I've tried their thick and thin crust - both were excellent!! We went with the Perfect Pepperoni thin crust and added xtra pepperoni on top!!! It was amazing. Try it and you will most likely want to get Elmo's again.“