Extremely friendly staff. Absolutely amazing food. I have dietary restrictions, and they were more than happy to accommodate my needs. Very impressed. I highly recommend it.Dietary restrictions: I am very low carb. (Carnivore). My family is not. I had a steak and chicken breast with nothing else. It was awesome. My wife had the Conch fritters and loved them.
Great atmosphere and food bringing back memories of our trip to the Keys!
Benjamin Schlegel
Amagansett sucks. This place rocks.
Brett Lochbihler
Place is great for food and a cool ambiance.If you actually use Google reviews to try and get a feel for restaurants, please disregard the one star reviews here from people upset about something unrelated to the food and atmosphere.Have been here multiple times and have had no issues at all. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
abby lynn
Sydney the bartender was amazing! So fun & made the best dirty martini we’ve ever had! That girl deserves a raise for how above and beyond she goes! Also the key lime pie was fantastic!
Adam Bernard
Big sized appetizers. Good food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Conch & Shrimp Fritters
Charles Edwards Jr
Someone asked for good seafood restaurant suggestions, in a foodie group I'm in, & out of the different places people mentioned..the Tipsy Mermaid caught my attention. It was the only place that I wasn't really familiar with & with a name like that.. I had to check it out. I was surprised that they didn't take reservations & even though it was around 8:30 on a Friday evening.. there was no wait. Very casual, cool, atmosphere. March Madness games were playing at the bar & several staff members came to check on us throughout the course of the evening. Being pescatarian often limits our dinner choices, but this place had more options than I knew what to do with. Everything that we ordered was great, but I'm already looking forward to going back again because there were so many other things I still wanna try.. it's actually probably gonna take a few more trips because there were just that many delicious looking choices. I'm glad I stumbled across this place & I will be going back.. SOON. ?Vegetarian options: I didn't get a vegetarian dish this time, but on my next trip I want to try their mushroom gnocchi.. it looked delicious.Parking: There was parking on the street, but we were able to find a spot, on their lot, directly behind the restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley Jones
Great service, drinks and atmosphere!
Brantley Forbes
Just absolutely horrible....Tip to ownership, be nice, happy & and don't judge people.Sincerely best of luck.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Robert Klein
Food was great but it took over 30 minutes from ordering until getting any food.
My husband and I split four appetizers as our meals and loved all of them. The restaurant definitely reminded us of being in Key West.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
S Sutton
First of all we had a good dinner at this restaurant a month ago and were excited to return! We told my parents who were in from out of town all about it and planned to visit on a Friday. They got there first and we walked in with our daughter and were told that the restaurant is 16 and older. When we asked to see the information on the website the manager had a hard time locating the info. And apologized twice while scrolling the website saying maybe it was removed. He did finally find some info but only on the menu. not the website or google.I had seen a review referring to not letting kids eat there and looked at the website and didn’t see the information. As a customer I should not have to look everywhere for such unusual and important information. I would suggest that information be made a priority on the website!! As a customer to walk in on a Friday night with guest and not be able to eat was very disappointing as well as difficult for us to find another restaurant. Thank you Seasons 52 for accommodating us for the second time this week. Thankfully not allowing kids of 15 and under to eat isn’t the norm I would not have expected to have this. Unfortunately will not be returning to this restaurant or any of the others by the owner. I have no issues with them not wanting to accommodate under 16, however it should be well documented on the website as well as google.
Atmosphere: 1
Candace Robison
We live in the Keys (Key Largo). There is an overwhelming keys vibe here! This is our go to when we are visiting our family in Zionsville. We love that they added a kid friendly brunch on Saturday & Sundays. The atmosphere, staff & food are amazing!! Definitely 5 stars!David & Candace
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rick T
The manager is rude and doesn’t know the law.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Reva Long
The atmosphere is cozy, clean and fun. The decor and attention to detail makes the experience enjoyable. The service and food are excellent. Prices are reasonable for the quality and portions you get. Can’t wait to return!
Extremely friendly staff. Absolutely amazing food. I have dietary restrictions, and they were more than happy to accommodate my needs. Very impressed. I highly recommend it.Dietary restrictions: I am very low carb. (Carnivore). My family is not. I had a steak and chicken breast with nothing else. It was awesome. My wife had the Conch fritters and loved them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Truman PO' Boy, Papa's Steak Sandwich, Conch & Shrimp Fritters
Great atmosphere and food bringing back memories of our trip to the Keys!
Amagansett sucks. This place rocks.
Place is great for food and a cool ambiance.If you actually use Google reviews to try and get a feel for restaurants, please disregard the one star reviews here from people upset about something unrelated to the food and atmosphere.Have been here multiple times and have had no issues at all. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sydney the bartender was amazing! So fun & made the best dirty martini we’ve ever had! That girl deserves a raise for how above and beyond she goes! Also the key lime pie was fantastic!
Big sized appetizers. Good food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Conch & Shrimp Fritters
Someone asked for good seafood restaurant suggestions, in a foodie group I'm in, & out of the different places people mentioned..the Tipsy Mermaid caught my attention. It was the only place that I wasn't really familiar with & with a name like that.. I had to check it out. I was surprised that they didn't take reservations & even though it was around 8:30 on a Friday evening.. there was no wait. Very casual, cool, atmosphere. March Madness games were playing at the bar & several staff members came to check on us throughout the course of the evening. Being pescatarian often limits our dinner choices, but this place had more options than I knew what to do with. Everything that we ordered was great, but I'm already looking forward to going back again because there were so many other things I still wanna try.. it's actually probably gonna take a few more trips because there were just that many delicious looking choices. I'm glad I stumbled across this place & I will be going back.. SOON. ?Vegetarian options: I didn't get a vegetarian dish this time, but on my next trip I want to try their mushroom gnocchi.. it looked delicious.Parking: There was parking on the street, but we were able to find a spot, on their lot, directly behind the restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service, drinks and atmosphere!
Just absolutely horrible....Tip to ownership, be nice, happy & and don't judge people.Sincerely best of luck.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Food was great but it took over 30 minutes from ordering until getting any food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
My husband and I split four appetizers as our meals and loved all of them. The restaurant definitely reminded us of being in Key West.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First of all we had a good dinner at this restaurant a month ago and were excited to return! We told my parents who were in from out of town all about it and planned to visit on a Friday. They got there first and we walked in with our daughter and were told that the restaurant is 16 and older. When we asked to see the information on the website the manager had a hard time locating the info. And apologized twice while scrolling the website saying maybe it was removed. He did finally find some info but only on the menu. not the website or google.I had seen a review referring to not letting kids eat there and looked at the website and didn’t see the information. As a customer I should not have to look everywhere for such unusual and important information. I would suggest that information be made a priority on the website!! As a customer to walk in on a Friday night with guest and not be able to eat was very disappointing as well as difficult for us to find another restaurant. Thank you Seasons 52 for accommodating us for the second time this week. Thankfully not allowing kids of 15 and under to eat isn’t the norm I would not have expected to have this. Unfortunately will not be returning to this restaurant or any of the others by the owner. I have no issues with them not wanting to accommodate under 16, however it should be well documented on the website as well as google.
Atmosphere: 1
We live in the Keys (Key Largo). There is an overwhelming keys vibe here! This is our go to when we are visiting our family in Zionsville. We love that they added a kid friendly brunch on Saturday & Sundays. The atmosphere, staff & food are amazing!! Definitely 5 stars!David & Candace
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The manager is rude and doesn’t know the law.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The atmosphere is cozy, clean and fun. The decor and attention to detail makes the experience enjoyable. The service and food are excellent. Prices are reasonable for the quality and portions you get. Can’t wait to return!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5