Sylas and Maddy's Homemade Ice Cream

1101 Massachusetts St, Lawrence
(785) 832-8323

Recent Reviews

Alex Cross

Ice cream was creamy and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pistachios and Da Bomb Single Cone, Chocolat Dip Ice Cream Cone, Cookies and Cream

Jackie Fritsch

Absolutely fantastic homemade ice cream!!! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Don Stoltz

Best ice cream in Lawrence. Must try "Da Bomb".

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolat Dip Ice Cream Cone

Tom Price

Excellent as

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anna Cherry

Excellent customer service! My date has celiac's and the employees went above and beyond with their consideration! I was deeply impressed! Also excellent quality of ice cream!

Austin Swegle

Very good place. Ice cream was great, service was fast and excellent.

Ryan Lucke

Indulging in a delightful experience at this charming ice cream parlor was a true delight.Their specialty flavors are a testament to creativity and quality.From unique combinations to classics with a twist, each scoop was a burst of flavor.The cozy ambiance and friendly staff only added to the overall experience.A must-visit for any ice cream enthusiast looking for a sweet adventure!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Adriane Ammerman

Hands down, the best ice cream in Lawrence and the Kansas City Metro! I can't even imagine eating fresh, flavorful, homemade ice cream anywhere else. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Diane T.

For my family of ice cream lovers it's a must when shopping on Mass Street. Great variety. Obviously made fresh on site. Friendly staff. Great place to sit and watch passersby from the large windows.

FamleeLegacyRec

Great service. Awesome ice cream. Even in negative degrees I come for a milkshake. It's that good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Darlene M.

We were here in October and my posting got submitted with the wrong number of stars so here it is again if you're in the area hope you enjoy ! Excellent ice cream and the waffle cones are delicious! Staff is friendly and helpful and the line moves very quickly because there is always a line there. Plenty of ice cream in the medium waffle cone for each of us! The ice cream is smooth and creamy, and the waffle cones are freshly made, Iloved the pumpkin pie and the turtle! The pumpkin cheesecake had big chunks of cheesecake in it. The boys had butter brickle, Reese's and butter pecan, It must've been good because it disappeared quickly. We all really enjoyed it and it was a great way to end the evening celebrating together in downtown Lawrence. So good I forgot to take pictures.

Kelley Cooper- Cameron

The most delicious ice cream. Fresh flavors made in house. If you like ice cream this is a must!

Osaid M

The ice cream tasted great and they had plenty of options, my only complaint is the waffle cones are a tad to crumbley

Krysten Brown

I live close to the Olathe location, and it's my favorite ice cream joint. So when I took a day trip to Lawrence, I HAD to make a pit stop to get my favorite ice cream.

Fiona Z.

Ice cream is great--creamy and thick, sweet but not overly so, and they have lots of flavors. However, the layout and info could be better. The display cases don't have any labels on the glass; you have to bend down to see the labels for ice cream flavors, sometimes cramming several words of ingredients on a label size meant for a couple of words. I wouldn't be surprised if figuring out what's what is half the wait time, unless you order the same thing every time or have a solid go-to flavor.Also, some of the names are downright opaque or contrary to what you'd expect. For instance, Da Bomb is drawn in red, white, and blue on their flavor chalkboard like those fun Bomb Pops, so I was expecting something with cherry and blue raspberry. No--the flavor is cookie dough, chocolate flakes, and Oreos. Graduation Day didn't hint at what the flavor is, but the label indicated brownies, cashews, and caramel swirls.Another note: I got wrongly charged once and then when they corrected it, they double charged me, so just check your transactions.I personally like their 5-flavor sampler cup ($4.85). I don't mind mixing flavors in one cup and it's about a large cup's worth of ice cream. Their 6-flavor flight is more expensive, but the flavors are kept separate.My personal notes:Orange sherbet: good, exactly what you expectBirthday bash: vanilla ice cream with chocolate cake and sprinkles; I prefer this to sweet "birthday batter" type ice cream flavorsStrawberry lemonade sherbet: mostly just tasted strawberryStrawberry ice cream: small, evenly sized frozen strawberry chunks; surprisingly good for a "standard" flavorMuddy Maddy's: Oreo and coffee and fudge; pretty goodCookie monster: no soft cookies like in other cookies n' cream types; almost peanut butteryMint chocolate chip: disappointingly kind of meh; more bitter mint than sweet mintToasted coconut: good, exactly what you'd expectPeaches & cream: tastes like peach gummy rings; I'm not a fan of that fake peach tasteRock choc jayhawk: basic chocolate-y goodnessQueen of hearts: raspberry-covered chocolate; too many inclusions to ice cream ratio, not enough ice cream for every chocolate-covered raspberry chunk

Load More

Sylas and Maddy's Homemade Ice Cream

1101 Massachusetts St, Lawrence, KS 66044
(785) 832-8323