Papa Johns Pizza

2467 Nicholasville Rd, Lexington
(859) 278-7272

Recent Reviews

Scott Ford (Scott Exploring)

If I want Papa Johns pizza, I come here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mike Haley

Update 2/15/24. Amazing rip off again. Ordered extra sauce. 3 inches from edge,, absolutely no sauce,, no toppings.. please owners do better.. Amazing. Spoke to a guy in India. Damn accent so strong, could not understand a damn word he was trying to say. Got so frustrated, just hung up.

Lust The Wolf

Food is always fresh and the service is on point, I normally only order pizzas late at night.Vegetarian options: If you want a vegetarian pizza you can customize one online. They have olive, onions, green bell peppers, jalapeno, banana pepper.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Add-On, 8 Piece Garlic Knots, Spicy Garlic Sauce

Gracie Wilson

whatever girl is working on february 23 at 12 pm is very rude and should not be working there!!!! hung up on us twice because THEY got the order time wrong!!

Food: 5

Service: 1

Melissa Smith

I ordered on the app. I paid extra for their zesty sauce and pepperonchinis. Usually their pizza comes with one pepperonchini and garlic sauce. I got no sauce (not even the one I paid extra for)and only one pepperonchini. The app doesn't really have a way to easily report any issues. They are already a pretty pricey pizza place. Disappointed I spent extra and ended up with less.

Food: 4

Service: 3

Dennis Cuzick

The manager named Amanda she tries, but when she don't know what she's talking about she should shut up and listen, I'm going to prove her wrong and hope she's made enough to apologize....

Andy Olsen

So appreciate manager Amanda’s great service. A bizarre glitch in the app caused our pizza to be delivered from this location (we never order from this location) to another Papa John’s (who would do that?). Delivery driver actually took a photo of our pizza boxes sitting on the curb in front of the other store. Amanda very helpfully made it right and sent a new delivery, even though the app error was not her fault.

Service: 5

Nicole Cosner

Always fast and good customer service skills and delivery service. Great deals offered every day and can change up monthly for specials offered. Great Value and taste for the food and drink items offered and served when you get your orders.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Brownie, Buffalo Chicken Papadia, Chicken Alfredo Papadia

Elie Sagamba

I oreded something and I received another

Food: 1

Joe Renner

My second favorite pizza

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Andi Coe

Every time I ask for light sauce on the pizza what I always get is a pizza drenched in sauce, how hard is it to make a cheese pizza with light sauce! So ridiculous, will never order from this location again, they do not care about your order or pay attention to detail. Spending a good amount of money just to have to throw away food.

Bilbo Bloggins

.63$ for a single season packet is ridiculous. But the workers here are always cool and food is on point ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

M Jennette

There customers service has always been amazing!!!

S RC

30min wait for breadsticks is so silly. Just have some ready for the public at primetimes. Wings at pizzahut was a 7 minute wait by comparison.

Crystal Masters

Very friendly staff! The night manager is awesome and he deserves a raise and a big thank you for his work and dedication to this store. This is the only papa John's that we will go to because of the great service.

Load More