The Original Highland Fish Market (Middletown)

12121 Shelbyville Road - Middletown, Louisville
(502) 254-3474

Recent Reviews

M L

Genuinely fresh seafood. Great people to deal with. Very clean store. Quality selection and capability to get more if desired is a plus. Will be making the trip to go here many more times.

Robert Garbus

I always felt the owners cared about every piece of seafood in the store, delivering the best quality possible being 10 hours from the nearest ocean. A 3 pound plank of Scottish Salmon is always a hit at parties especially smoked on a Big Green Egg. The Ahi Tuna is easy to prepare for when you want to make a creative dinner. Everett will give you cooking recommendations for anything there. Remember, doctors are starting to say that fish is a healthy meal option.

David Carlson

Wonderful and best quality selection of fish. The best.

John Martel

Top quality and great recommendations, the prices are on par with a top rate seafood grocery. So much to choose from!

Jack

I just moved to Louisville after living in Tokyo for 4 years and happened to drive by and stop at this place.The employee (I believe Everett) was very kind, helpful, and passionate about fish.My wife and I ate sushi about once a week in Japan, so we were really excited to find this fish market. We bought some salmon and scallops and they were both delicious. Can't wait to come again!

Jason Williams

Great seafood. Strange issues with ordering online. Not sure why

Luke DeGroot

Amazing seafood mart; I bought the rest of their Smoked Salmon.Smoked Salmon tasted very closely to the Smoked Salmon I'm use to from Alaska.They have many different options of seafood. Puts any other mart to shame.Have Mahi Mahi, Swordfish, (Almost fist size) Scallops, Snow crab, lobster, & much more.Interior is cleaned & organized.

Stan Triplett

Great place for fresh fish. Clean store. Staff is friendly and eager to accommodate.

Travis Trahan

Well-lit, clean, and fresh seafood market.Large, high-quality raw and live oysters.Non- frozen Red-snapper and Grouper.Worth the visit to this family-owned business.

Ashley T

Spoke with Michael to get a quote for a fish fry for 50 people and he was awesome. He answered all of my questions and I was happy to hear that I could get what I needed on such short notice. Will definitely continue to get seafood here!

Theresa Watkins

Love this place! Staff is always helpful and food is fresh and delicious.

Crystal Sweet

Helped make my crab boil a success! The muscles in the crab boil where frozen because of the time of year but still did not disappoint. The muscles in the sauce pan where from earlier in the year and where fresh "live" omgoodness so yummy! This place is a one stop shop for everything you need.

Joe B

We got there at about 1:30 pm on a Saturday and were seated immediately. Service was quick and pleasant. We both got the half chicken salad sandwich and tomato artichoke soup. The chicken salad sandwich is s specialty and very good. They also gave us some bread to munch on while waiting for our food. I also had coffee that was quite good. Sometimes I am hesitant to get coffee at restaurants as it generally pales in comparison to coffee house brews. This was one of the exceptions.

Sherri M.

Awesome service and quality seafood! I bought the Oysters -From Highlands - and used a recipe from ACME Oyster House in NOLA. They were absolutely delicious!

Lana Glover

I buy all of my seafood here. Owners are always friendly and helpful. Wouldn't go anywhere else.

Load More

The Original Highland Fish Market (Middletown)

12121 Shelbyville Road - Middletown, Louisville, KY 40243
(502) 254-3474