We absolutely love it, we are originally from New Orleans so it was a great to know we could still enjoy our favorites in Baton Rouge.Only 1 problem, for the past month I have tried calling with no answer and now a recording saying the number has changed. I am not happy, did you close?☹️
Candace Shaidaee
Ordered to go… food was fine- not the best, certainly not the worst.. the best part was the lovely lady who waited on me…she was very polite and helpful.
Daniel Henderson
Food is always good and cooked to order highly recommend it. You won't be disappointed.
Matt Wiseman
UPDATED 12-22-2021: (STILL) MY FAVORITE PIZZE PLACE IN THE ENTIRE CITY! . Takeout, dine in, all good. They have the best spinach/artichoke pizza in existence, and the service is usually one of the best i know of; friendly, quick, and attentive. My family are regulars to this place and the owners learn your face after only a few times going, so if you are a loyal customer they will treat you even better than usual if you get to know them well enough, they even remember your order when you call for takeout. They know my grandmother's voice so when she calls, they say somethi ng like "the usual?" And make it perfectly.
Michael Harper
Ordered 2 lasagna plates, picked up 2 plates that are 2” X 2” plates of noodles with nothing in between no sauce no ricotta no cheese just overloaded with marinara sauce. $20 for meals less than canned ravioli. Not sure if they having a bad day. I worked at Italian Pie 6 years ago, this definitely isn’t the same.
Lori F.
Soooo good! The cheese sticks and chicken Alfredo pizza are our go to things. The people are super nice too.
Donna Goudeau
Original Italian Pie has the best food! My go to menu items are one of the pasta plates. So much food and oh so good! Only four stars this time because my Vene tian chicken could have been hotter. My noodles and garlic bread were nice and hot though. The Mediterranean salad is my favorite too! The staff there is always so nice. It's a pleasure to dine there.
Amber M.
Love Italian Pie. I hadn't been to one in over 10 years since I moved to Baton Rouge and just realized there was one out here. Their food is always delicious. The cheese bread (called garlic bread on the menu) is some of the best I've had in a good while. Pepperoni pizza was also really good. My husband had a calzone which he enjoyed - it was a pretty good size.
Amber Roxanne
Was really excited to try this place after finding out it was still open. I didn't make it passed the door.
Vanessa Knowlton
The staff is always friendly. I love their lasagna and garlic bread.
Went Mother’s Day weekend -great food-great experience—shared a meal with my daughterToday first time since then -my husband & I went for lunch ordered pasta with salad & itialian salad with Italian sandwich BOTH lunch specials -our Italian salads came out with chunks of white lettuce (little green) , a few tomato cubes & moz cheese? Where was the green pepper, red onion, mushroom slices, Olive slices, or pepperoni? I asked owner -she explained they had to cut back on quantity due to prices-they wanted prices to stay same-I understand but I would rather pay more for QUALITY than less for lacking salads etcSandwich was no better missing key ingredients? Chicken parm was 1/2 the size -I don’t see how they will survive if they choose to cut back by making these choices
Sandi Edwards
The owner is always friendly & goes out of his way to see if you are happy.
laurin fairley
Great neighborhood restaurant! The food is consistently delicious! Yummy pizzas! Owners are very gracious. Have been coming for years and never disappointed!
Debbie Kirschke
Great Food...Best Stuffed Mushrooms Ever! Pizza and Salads Excellent! Wait Staff and Owner/Chef always nice! Stop by table and ask if all was good!
Aaron Roy
Food was fresh, nice size portions and it was delicious! i had the chicken parm, chicken was flakey and moist!
We absolutely love it, we are originally from New Orleans so it was a great to know we could still enjoy our favorites in Baton Rouge.Only 1 problem, for the past month I have tried calling with no answer and now a recording saying the number has changed. I am not happy, did you close?☹️
Ordered to go… food was fine- not the best, certainly not the worst.. the best part was the lovely lady who waited on me…she was very polite and helpful.
Food is always good and cooked to order highly recommend it. You won't be disappointed.
UPDATED 12-22-2021: (STILL) MY FAVORITE PIZZE PLACE IN THE ENTIRE CITY! . Takeout, dine in, all good. They have the best spinach/artichoke pizza in existence, and the service is usually one of the best i know of; friendly, quick, and attentive. My family are regulars to this place and the owners learn your face after only a few times going, so if you are a loyal customer they will treat you even better than usual if you get to know them well enough, they even remember your order when you call for takeout. They know my grandmother's voice so when she calls, they say somethi ng like "the usual?" And make it perfectly.
Ordered 2 lasagna plates, picked up 2 plates that are 2” X 2” plates of noodles with nothing in between no sauce no ricotta no cheese just overloaded with marinara sauce. $20 for meals less than canned ravioli. Not sure if they having a bad day. I worked at Italian Pie 6 years ago, this definitely isn’t the same.
Soooo good! The cheese sticks and chicken Alfredo pizza are our go to things. The people are super nice too.
Original Italian Pie has the best food! My go to menu items are one of the pasta plates. So much food and oh so good! Only four stars this time because my Vene tian chicken could have been hotter. My noodles and garlic bread were nice and hot though. The Mediterranean salad is my favorite too! The staff there is always so nice. It's a pleasure to dine there.
Love Italian Pie. I hadn't been to one in over 10 years since I moved to Baton Rouge and just realized there was one out here. Their food is always delicious. The cheese bread (called garlic bread on the menu) is some of the best I've had in a good while. Pepperoni pizza was also really good. My husband had a calzone which he enjoyed - it was a pretty good size.
Was really excited to try this place after finding out it was still open. I didn't make it passed the door.
The staff is always friendly. I love their lasagna and garlic bread.
Restaurantji Recommends
Went Mother’s Day weekend -great food-great experience—shared a meal with my daughterToday first time since then -my husband & I went for lunch ordered pasta with salad & itialian salad with Italian sandwich BOTH lunch specials -our Italian salads came out with chunks of white lettuce (little green) , a few tomato cubes & moz cheese? Where was the green pepper, red onion, mushroom slices, Olive slices, or pepperoni? I asked owner -she explained they had to cut back on quantity due to prices-they wanted prices to stay same-I understand but I would rather pay more for QUALITY than less for lacking salads etcSandwich was no better missing key ingredients? Chicken parm was 1/2 the size -I don’t see how they will survive if they choose to cut back by making these choices
The owner is always friendly & goes out of his way to see if you are happy.
Great neighborhood restaurant! The food is consistently delicious! Yummy pizzas! Owners are very gracious. Have been coming for years and never disappointed!
Great Food...Best Stuffed Mushrooms Ever! Pizza and Salads Excellent! Wait Staff and Owner/Chef always nice! Stop by table and ask if all was good!
Food was fresh, nice size portions and it was delicious! i had the chicken parm, chicken was flakey and moist!