Every time when I visit to Mandeville, I stop by for lunch. Their meals is so delicious, fresh made & fast service is smth extra. People here are friendly. Worth your time & money spent in this Pizzeria. Definitely Recommended. !!!
CHERYLYN WEBB
My very first visit and first order. Suggested by my daughter in law. They have ordered before. Delicious pizza my new go to for pizza night. Ordered the Neely no Mushrooms but added jalapeños. Toppings were plenty not like most pizza place’s.
Rebecca Wade
Delicious!! Very good pizza! Wished I had gotten thicker crust because their dough is out of this world! The cheese stuffed bread was so good! Will definitely order again
Mike Nathanson
Not one to write reviews, but this is worth it. Full-time traveling always looking for some good pizza. This was a great pizza and definitely worth stuffing your face. Local family owned homemade recipe w/ great service.
Jeremy Atkinson
The best pizza I've had in a long time, super friendly staff.
William Cahill
Great pizza. Good local, hard working staff!
john copeland
Disappointed. Showed up 5 minutes before open time posted on the door and waited another half hour. Never got to try it due to apparently incorrect hours posted. Ended up missing kick off of the saints game to find another avenue for pizza.
David Bell
Great pizza joint run by a very nice family. Please support this local family owned business!
teena s.
Ordered online for pickup. Received confirmation email of estimated pick up time of 8:03. I ordered at 6:55. I arrived at 8:05 and stood at the front door for at least 10 minutes before being approached by what looked like the young son. He checked the status of my pizza informed me my pizza was in the oven and would be ready in 6 minutes. I sat in my car for another 10 minutes before going back inside. At that time I again stood there about 7 minutes before the same young man asked if he could help me. He checked and again told me it would be a couple more minutes. This was our first time trying Neely's and if it would have been exceptional pizza, I'd overlook the lack of being told a correct time but it was super greasy & almost raw. The crust was soggy and did not hold up well. While the toppings were in abundance, I like them more well done. Much better pizza in the area in my opinion.
Matthew Miranda
Excellent flavor, great thin crust, fresh ingredients. My new favorite on the north shore!
We have been searching high and low for a new favorite, go-to pizza place since moving here over a year ago. We have tried several, several, SEVERAL places and this one is by far the best we have had! My wife actually called the owner directly after our family devoured his pizza to tell him how thankful we are to have found them! The dough is so light and airy and the fresh ingredients homemade sauce just make it a near perfect pie.
sam flores
This pizzeria is a breath of fresh air! Hand made dough from a family recipe combined with high quality ingredients make for an absolutely delicious pizza. We, personally, tried the Cheese, Pepperoni, Carnivore and Margherita pizzas and my family loved all of them. We also treated ourselves to the homemade Baklava and Cannolis and I can honestly say that I have never had such wonderful delights. A perfect end to a wonderful meal. Neely’s is owned and operated by a hard working Italian family whom are ever present in the kitchen. Their children greet you upon entering as they play in the dining room. The ongoing pandemic keeps their quaint dining area closed at the present but the family does everything possible to make you comfortable as you wait for your order to be hand prepared. This is a must try if you’re looking for a new pizzeria to call home, I know we have.
Chris Ward
I ordered a half supreme half Neely's specialty and it was fantastic. They definitely don't skimp on the topping! The crust was light and fluffy too.Update: went a second time and the owners were as friendly as could be! Also hands down the best cheesy bread I've ever had!
Amanda L.
Now I don't leave reviews on yelp unless it's GREAT or BAD. I've lived in Mandeville for 10 years and had Neely's pizza and been satisfied. My last experience here was absolutely AWFUL. We got a large combo pizza, a small cheese pizza, 4 Cannolis and 4 BITE SIZE pieces of baklava. When I say BITE SIZE I mean ONE bite and it's gone. My little brother went to pick up and pay for the order and upon arrival back home told me it was 75$!!!! I said for WHAT?!? I called and was told each dessert was 5$ a POP! I wish I would have known that before giving my brother my card but the balaclava isn't on the menu. The cannoli was EMPTY. They put 2 tiny squirts of subpar filling on each side and the middle was empty. The balaclava was literally 1 inch by .5 inch and not very good. The female worker with her 2 children in the store running around justified the 5$ per bite by saying they are "worth it and made with real walnuts and butter"...are you joking me. Eventually after having to GO to the store and hash this insane charge out they refunded me 17$ for the cannoli because I had pictures of the dry middles. Absolutely won't be going back here.
Wayne G.
My wife said this is the best pizza she's ever had and she is very picky
Every time when I visit to Mandeville, I stop by for lunch. Their meals is so delicious, fresh made & fast service is smth extra. People here are friendly. Worth your time & money spent in this Pizzeria. Definitely Recommended. !!!
My very first visit and first order. Suggested by my daughter in law. They have ordered before. Delicious pizza my new go to for pizza night. Ordered the Neely no Mushrooms but added jalapeños. Toppings were plenty not like most pizza place’s.
Delicious!! Very good pizza! Wished I had gotten thicker crust because their dough is out of this world! The cheese stuffed bread was so good! Will definitely order again
Not one to write reviews, but this is worth it. Full-time traveling always looking for some good pizza. This was a great pizza and definitely worth stuffing your face. Local family owned homemade recipe w/ great service.
The best pizza I've had in a long time, super friendly staff.
Great pizza. Good local, hard working staff!
Disappointed. Showed up 5 minutes before open time posted on the door and waited another half hour. Never got to try it due to apparently incorrect hours posted. Ended up missing kick off of the saints game to find another avenue for pizza.
Great pizza joint run by a very nice family. Please support this local family owned business!
Ordered online for pickup. Received confirmation email of estimated pick up time of 8:03. I ordered at 6:55. I arrived at 8:05 and stood at the front door for at least 10 minutes before being approached by what looked like the young son. He checked the status of my pizza informed me my pizza was in the oven and would be ready in 6 minutes. I sat in my car for another 10 minutes before going back inside. At that time I again stood there about 7 minutes before the same young man asked if he could help me. He checked and again told me it would be a couple more minutes. This was our first time trying Neely's and if it would have been exceptional pizza, I'd overlook the lack of being told a correct time but it was super greasy & almost raw. The crust was soggy and did not hold up well. While the toppings were in abundance, I like them more well done. Much better pizza in the area in my opinion.
Excellent flavor, great thin crust, fresh ingredients. My new favorite on the north shore!
Restaurantji Recommends
We have been searching high and low for a new favorite, go-to pizza place since moving here over a year ago. We have tried several, several, SEVERAL places and this one is by far the best we have had! My wife actually called the owner directly after our family devoured his pizza to tell him how thankful we are to have found them! The dough is so light and airy and the fresh ingredients homemade sauce just make it a near perfect pie.
This pizzeria is a breath of fresh air! Hand made dough from a family recipe combined with high quality ingredients make for an absolutely delicious pizza. We, personally, tried the Cheese, Pepperoni, Carnivore and Margherita pizzas and my family loved all of them. We also treated ourselves to the homemade Baklava and Cannolis and I can honestly say that I have never had such wonderful delights. A perfect end to a wonderful meal. Neely’s is owned and operated by a hard working Italian family whom are ever present in the kitchen. Their children greet you upon entering as they play in the dining room. The ongoing pandemic keeps their quaint dining area closed at the present but the family does everything possible to make you comfortable as you wait for your order to be hand prepared. This is a must try if you’re looking for a new pizzeria to call home, I know we have.
I ordered a half supreme half Neely's specialty and it was fantastic. They definitely don't skimp on the topping! The crust was light and fluffy too.Update: went a second time and the owners were as friendly as could be! Also hands down the best cheesy bread I've ever had!
Now I don't leave reviews on yelp unless it's GREAT or BAD. I've lived in Mandeville for 10 years and had Neely's pizza and been satisfied. My last experience here was absolutely AWFUL. We got a large combo pizza, a small cheese pizza, 4 Cannolis and 4 BITE SIZE pieces of baklava. When I say BITE SIZE I mean ONE bite and it's gone. My little brother went to pick up and pay for the order and upon arrival back home told me it was 75$!!!! I said for WHAT?!? I called and was told each dessert was 5$ a POP! I wish I would have known that before giving my brother my card but the balaclava isn't on the menu. The cannoli was EMPTY. They put 2 tiny squirts of subpar filling on each side and the middle was empty. The balaclava was literally 1 inch by .5 inch and not very good. The female worker with her 2 children in the store running around justified the 5$ per bite by saying they are "worth it and made with real walnuts and butter"...are you joking me. Eventually after having to GO to the store and hash this insane charge out they refunded me 17$ for the cannoli because I had pictures of the dry middles. Absolutely won't be going back here.
My wife said this is the best pizza she's ever had and she is very picky