Bennett's Sandwich Shop

1348 Boylston St, Boston
(857) 239-9736

Recent Reviews

John Fish

Not much value for the money and the food is sub par

Keke

My sister bought two large steak subs with onions peppers one was for me and a small tuna for my mom! We were all looking forward to enjoying our subs we ate the subs (or attempted to)we were quite disappointed! The steak was very dry and the bread was soggy! Don't they know that the bread is a major part of the sub? They wrap it in foil ! Also the texture was gummy! My mom didn't enjoy her tuna sub either.. she said"this is nothing like ideal subs"! I agree ! Award winning subs? Which award is this? Dryest soggiest? Going back to Ideal!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

K N.

Matt and his team at the Boston Bennett's are always top notch in customer service and consistency. Matt goes above and beyond to greet customers & ensure satisfaction. I have become a regular for lunchtime (turkey & cheese) a classic but delicious sub & I must try their breakfast sandwiches! With so many options in the Fenway area you cannot go wrong with something from Bennett's (and it's affordable!)

Matthew A.

Great breakfast sandwich, especially since nowadays places like Starbucks and Dunkin microwave everything and use egg beaters instead of REAL whole eggs. I mean come on! Coffee was alright but food was great!

Casey D.

Excellent place for a quick bite on the way to Fenway Park. I selected a simple sausage, egg and cheese on a roll and the staff member suggested a perfect twist by adding Sriracha aïoli.

lakaijd

This place is fantastic! The steaks, pastramis, Buffalo Philly! Just everything is sooo damn

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Janice Cagan-Teuber

Perfect steak & sauteed onions!!!! Staff very friendly. Restroom clean.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak

Rémi Diesler

Great place to have true American sandwichs ! I usually get them to go. One big sub is generally enough for two meals. Fries are also great.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Zach LeBlanc

These sandwiches are absolutely delicious! We were in too much of a rush before the Fenway tour and forgot to take pictures, but take my word for it: you won't regret it! I got the grilled chicken ("F" bomb) and my wife got the chicken cheesesteak and we were both wow'd by the quality and taste of the food. Often when you order sandwiches with peppers and onions, you can tell toppings are very cheap or saturated with oil, but Bennett's tasted high quality. If you're around Fenway and are in the mood for a sandwich, make Bennett's a priority!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Famous Chicken Cheesesteak, F Bomb

Jake Lloyd

Very weird experience, normally this place is good but I ordered the Stegg Bowl this morning and it just straight up didn’t have anything in it? Of the ingredients usually in it, there was no steak, no sauce, no peppers, nothing but egg and onions. I was so confused I just ate it and left. Probably won’t come back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 5

Kelly Hong

First time ordering, placed a pickup order and they forgot both sauces for the fries. Also ordered the strawberry banana smoothie and the cup was cracked and they put the order sticker over the crack instead of using an undamaged cup, which led to the smoothie leaking everywhere in my car. Sandwiches were good, nothing extraordinary and the fries were quite salty. Overall not a good experience.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

Joe A.

I work in the area and hit this place up monthly -- great food and choices, solid staff, clean and well presented, consistent quality, you won't be disappointed. #steakandcheese #wicked

Candice C.

Such a great sandwich! I got the kids size and thank goodness because it was huge! Great portions and hearty flavors!

Brenda K.

I ordered a chicken sandwich through Relish. The bread was super fresh however the sandwich filling was a meager portion. It was even too little for me and I'm a tiny 5'3" woman with a small appetite. I felt hungry afterward.

Luca C.

It's probably exactly what you were expecting The pastrami breakfast sandwich was great, if a little greasy, and the Italian we grabbed for lunch was solid, but could use something like hots on it as a standard (or at least a required option) to give it some oomph.

Load More