I was so disappointed tonight. First the gentleman taking my order got my name wrong 4 x and still my sister had to return to the car asking what name I left. Although it was closing within an hour I assumed they would still make a fresh pie. I was sadly mistaken. Regina you should no better!
John Templehof
I don’t normally do reviews, but this place gave me an amazing experience. Staff was very friendly and quick! And the food was awesome! The north end ovens are a lot different so the crust wasn’t the same but the ingredients were still top notch.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joshua Levinson
Delicious pizza. Local
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Tyler Gilbert
I usually love Regina’s but this one on Boylston Street is terrible now. The last couple times, I’ve ordered just a small cheese pizza. It is severely undercooked, and now they sent me a pizza that was undercooked spilling over and stuck to my box.
Food: 1
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
ProneYT
I was giving a lunch and learn at a local business on Thursday 3/7, so I called this pizza shop on Tuesday 3/5 11:20am to place an order for 20 pizzas. The man on the phone instructed me to use an app such as uber eats/door dash to place the order as they don't take orders that big over the phone. I accepted and placed the order over ubereats. At 11:51am I called back the pizza shop to confirm this order and ask for disposable plates (not an option on ubereats). The man on the phone confirmed the order and said he would "ask the boss" about providing plates. On Thursday, 25 minutes before my event i was hosting, they cancelled the order through ubereats with no reason why. We called the shop who said that it was uber's fault and that I should've placed the order through their shop over the phone. So needless to say I had to tell 40+ people they weren't getting a lunch.I called ubereats later who said that the order had been cancelled by this pizza shop. They have forever lost my business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mike P
No frills environment for a decent slice. I'd say that the friendly staff is what elevates the Fenway location to a 4 star review. Better pizza is the original Reginas in the North End but the Fenway is decent for slices. Btw, better pizza around is Florinas in Beacon Hill. I would not recommend Tenderonis for pizza. Regina's is cheaper and better.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza
Sam Sheridan
We visited from Austin and had to try it out before the Celts game, loved it so much we went back the next day as well! Great pizza, great convo with staff, great atmosphere.
Shari D.
Now I can see why this pizza place has been around since 1926. It's simple and it's delicious. Warm and ready. Huge slices!
April G.
I love this place!! The pizza is nice and hot every time and I like the selection and quality! Good specials, 2 pizzas and a drink for $10-$12! I wish we had one in California.
Yolidia Rojas
I stopped there yesterday ( 1/18/24 4:30 pm) because my husband wanted to eat there. So I saw the menu on the wall and I asked the cashier for a chicken and bacon wrap. He said we don't have that , then I asked for a cesar salad , the same answer" we don't have that ". I never thought that he was like denying me the food from there until the his Spanish coworker told me in Spanish " No me gusto la manera que el te trato" which means " I didn't like the way he is treating you, then I realized that the white cashier didn't wanted to take my order. The Spanish guy was really nice but the other two seemed like they don't like their job and denied the service to whoever they want to.
Pizza tasted good and service was fine but I found what looks/feels like a chicken bone in my pizza despite ordering the Giambotta which has no chicken
Kathleen Chang
Not as good as the original.
Max B
Had a mushroom slice and pepper/onion slice. Mushroom slice was so wet and floppy. Pepper onion slice had more constitution but needed more salt or something in there. Would not recommend.
Joe thetraveller
I bought 2 pieces of pizza in Fenway. They burnt it like
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Doc L.
The food quality and value is outstanding!! I feel that I'm being generous giving a 4 star rating because the web site says they do curbside delivery and they don't. I tried calling but they wouldn't answer the phone so I had to double park and run in to get my pizza. I hate false advertising.....
I was so disappointed tonight. First the gentleman taking my order got my name wrong 4 x and still my sister had to return to the car asking what name I left. Although it was closing within an hour I assumed they would still make a fresh pie. I was sadly mistaken. Regina you should no better!
I don’t normally do reviews, but this place gave me an amazing experience. Staff was very friendly and quick! And the food was awesome! The north end ovens are a lot different so the crust wasn’t the same but the ingredients were still top notch.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza. Local
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
I usually love Regina’s but this one on Boylston Street is terrible now. The last couple times, I’ve ordered just a small cheese pizza. It is severely undercooked, and now they sent me a pizza that was undercooked spilling over and stuck to my box.
Food: 1
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
I was giving a lunch and learn at a local business on Thursday 3/7, so I called this pizza shop on Tuesday 3/5 11:20am to place an order for 20 pizzas. The man on the phone instructed me to use an app such as uber eats/door dash to place the order as they don't take orders that big over the phone. I accepted and placed the order over ubereats. At 11:51am I called back the pizza shop to confirm this order and ask for disposable plates (not an option on ubereats). The man on the phone confirmed the order and said he would "ask the boss" about providing plates. On Thursday, 25 minutes before my event i was hosting, they cancelled the order through ubereats with no reason why. We called the shop who said that it was uber's fault and that I should've placed the order through their shop over the phone. So needless to say I had to tell 40+ people they weren't getting a lunch.I called ubereats later who said that the order had been cancelled by this pizza shop. They have forever lost my business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
No frills environment for a decent slice. I'd say that the friendly staff is what elevates the Fenway location to a 4 star review. Better pizza is the original Reginas in the North End but the Fenway is decent for slices. Btw, better pizza around is Florinas in Beacon Hill. I would not recommend Tenderonis for pizza. Regina's is cheaper and better.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza
We visited from Austin and had to try it out before the Celts game, loved it so much we went back the next day as well! Great pizza, great convo with staff, great atmosphere.
Now I can see why this pizza place has been around since 1926. It's simple and it's delicious. Warm and ready. Huge slices!
I love this place!! The pizza is nice and hot every time and I like the selection and quality! Good specials, 2 pizzas and a drink for $10-$12! I wish we had one in California.
I stopped there yesterday ( 1/18/24 4:30 pm) because my husband wanted to eat there. So I saw the menu on the wall and I asked the cashier for a chicken and bacon wrap. He said we don't have that , then I asked for a cesar salad , the same answer" we don't have that ". I never thought that he was like denying me the food from there until the his Spanish coworker told me in Spanish " No me gusto la manera que el te trato" which means " I didn't like the way he is treating you, then I realized that the white cashier didn't wanted to take my order. The Spanish guy was really nice but the other two seemed like they don't like their job and denied the service to whoever they want to.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza tasted good and service was fine but I found what looks/feels like a chicken bone in my pizza despite ordering the Giambotta which has no chicken
Not as good as the original.
Had a mushroom slice and pepper/onion slice. Mushroom slice was so wet and floppy. Pepper onion slice had more constitution but needed more salt or something in there. Would not recommend.
I bought 2 pieces of pizza in Fenway. They burnt it like
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
The food quality and value is outstanding!! I feel that I'm being generous giving a 4 star rating because the web site says they do curbside delivery and they don't. I tried calling but they wouldn't answer the phone so I had to double park and run in to get my pizza. I hate false advertising.....