Pizza is okay. I had the pepperoni and foragers delight tonight. I suggest they take the forager off the
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Mary L.
Can only rave about the Crispy Pepperoni Cup tray pizza. It has a thick and chewy crust. Not many places in Boston have the crispy edge pepperoni cups like the one here. Very cheesy and added touch of honey. I personally didn't mind the honey but I wonder if it can be put on the side. Will definitely get this pizza again
Anaïs Lambert
Best pizza in Boston!
Bridget Allison
Great pizza. If you like thick flavorful crust with some crunch you’ll love this pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crispy Pepperoni Cup
Marisa R.
If you have celiac, definitely avoid this place. My son was glutened and got sick after eating their pizza.
Kenneth K.
I got steak and cheese sub , Mozzarella sticks and chocolate chip cookies there the only things that were good were the Mozzarella sticks and cookies the sub was fair could have been better
Andrew G.
This was the best gluten free crust I've ever had. Cronchy and thiccc. Food came out quick and the rest of it was good too. Went out of my way for this and it did not disappoint.
Bill T.
Just ordered a sunday special from these guys (8 wings) 1 large pizza for 35 dollars...wings were old and not hot. The pepperoni pizza had no sauce on it for some strange reason. I have ordered from here once before and it was excellent which is why im giving 2 stars as opposed to 1. Wont be coming back.
Coral Krentz
The first time we went here we got sandwiches and they were just alright, tonight we gave it a second shot with their tray pizzas and we officially have a new household favorite!! ♥️ the pepperoni cup tray pizza is amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crispy Pepperoni Cup Pizza
Ron K.
3rd visit, first ordered the Italian sub, good, fresh, well done, meats as advertised. Second, tried the mushroom pizza, good, maybe a B rating, a little soft, not tremendous flavor, there are better options across the river in the north end. Last, large set of subs ordered for 4 of us. Italian was so drenched in oil it couldn't be eaten, half of the "specialty" meats missing. French fries in photo, but "the don't serve those." Two pork sub also not edible, meat seem old. Faro salad lacked Faro! Complete failure. No consistency hear. Another sandwich shop nearby, too bad they don't stay open later to provide an edible option.
Best pizza around! Eric makes some Damgoode pies! Will be ordering catering from them before my next event.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sharon Orishaba
The worst restaurant manager who clearly showed me what racism is. I was dying to use the restroom to the extent of me pleading with him to help and he said I wasn't welcome there yet I had picked up a delivery order. For your information sir,being the person I am doesn't make you a better person if you can't even have a soft heart for a human being.
Tavy-Anna Chheng
The food is really good honestly, had the steak and cheese sub, I love it the cheese pull is immaculate, it’s not too overbearing with seasonings, it’s just right! And this garden sub with tomatoes and fresh mozzarella? with the balsamic dressing just balanced the sub! The food isn’t too big nor too small, it’s literally just right to eat it all without feeling full in my opinion. Such a friendly atmosphere and great service! Just a tip delivery goes through doordash and ubereats I believe, it’s cheaper for the delivery taxes?. The chefs did amazing with my meal ? Shout out to all of them
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: JP Cheesesteak Sub, Hot Honey Gold Wings, Tomato Garden Sub
Angela R.
Great pizza! I'd love to see them add more innovative vegetarian options to the menu. Great addition to the charlestown restaurant lineup!
Jea Kim
Take-out only spot with interesting tray pizzas and good baked wings.On my recent visit on a quiet weekday evening, I got the Cacio E Pepe wings and the Pepperoni Tray pizza. Starting with the Cacio E Pepe wings, their robust dry-rubbed flavor profile won me over. Not the most tender wings I've had, but the seasoning combined with a subtle baked crust undertone was a pleasant departure from the norm.The Crispy Pepperoni Cup Tray Pizza, however, had its highs and lows. At first glance and bite, it felt reminiscent of a cheesy bread topped with pepperoni and a hint of tomato sauce. The crunchy edges were delightful, but the thickness of the dough made for a heftier experience than I would've preferred. It teetered between the styles of a classic pizza and a Chicago deep dish, albeit minus the lavish sauce of the latter. The honey drizzle, for someone with a palate tolerant of sweetness in savory dishes, was an interesting touch. Yet, when weighing up the overall experience with its price point, it settled in the realm of satisfactory.The prices are slightly steeper than other local pizza spots, but whether it warrants the premium is debatable. Nevertheless, Johnny Pomodoro offers a curious culinary experience for those keen to venture beyond traditional pizza shop fare. While some aspects justify the price, others might leave you contemplating value. Worth a try, but set expectations accordingly.
Pizza is okay. I had the pepperoni and foragers delight tonight. I suggest they take the forager off the
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Can only rave about the Crispy Pepperoni Cup tray pizza. It has a thick and chewy crust. Not many places in Boston have the crispy edge pepperoni cups like the one here. Very cheesy and added touch of honey. I personally didn't mind the honey but I wonder if it can be put on the side. Will definitely get this pizza again
Best pizza in Boston!
Great pizza. If you like thick flavorful crust with some crunch you’ll love this pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crispy Pepperoni Cup
If you have celiac, definitely avoid this place. My son was glutened and got sick after eating their pizza.
I got steak and cheese sub , Mozzarella sticks and chocolate chip cookies there the only things that were good were the Mozzarella sticks and cookies the sub was fair could have been better
This was the best gluten free crust I've ever had. Cronchy and thiccc. Food came out quick and the rest of it was good too. Went out of my way for this and it did not disappoint.
Just ordered a sunday special from these guys (8 wings) 1 large pizza for 35 dollars...wings were old and not hot. The pepperoni pizza had no sauce on it for some strange reason. I have ordered from here once before and it was excellent which is why im giving 2 stars as opposed to 1. Wont be coming back.
The first time we went here we got sandwiches and they were just alright, tonight we gave it a second shot with their tray pizzas and we officially have a new household favorite!! ♥️ the pepperoni cup tray pizza is amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crispy Pepperoni Cup Pizza
3rd visit, first ordered the Italian sub, good, fresh, well done, meats as advertised. Second, tried the mushroom pizza, good, maybe a B rating, a little soft, not tremendous flavor, there are better options across the river in the north end. Last, large set of subs ordered for 4 of us. Italian was so drenched in oil it couldn't be eaten, half of the "specialty" meats missing. French fries in photo, but "the don't serve those." Two pork sub also not edible, meat seem old. Faro salad lacked Faro! Complete failure. No consistency hear. Another sandwich shop nearby, too bad they don't stay open later to provide an edible option.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza around! Eric makes some Damgoode pies! Will be ordering catering from them before my next event.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The worst restaurant manager who clearly showed me what racism is. I was dying to use the restroom to the extent of me pleading with him to help and he said I wasn't welcome there yet I had picked up a delivery order. For your information sir,being the person I am doesn't make you a better person if you can't even have a soft heart for a human being.
The food is really good honestly, had the steak and cheese sub, I love it the cheese pull is immaculate, it’s not too overbearing with seasonings, it’s just right! And this garden sub with tomatoes and fresh mozzarella? with the balsamic dressing just balanced the sub! The food isn’t too big nor too small, it’s literally just right to eat it all without feeling full in my opinion. Such a friendly atmosphere and great service! Just a tip delivery goes through doordash and ubereats I believe, it’s cheaper for the delivery taxes?. The chefs did amazing with my meal ? Shout out to all of them
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: JP Cheesesteak Sub, Hot Honey Gold Wings, Tomato Garden Sub
Great pizza! I'd love to see them add more innovative vegetarian options to the menu. Great addition to the charlestown restaurant lineup!
Take-out only spot with interesting tray pizzas and good baked wings.On my recent visit on a quiet weekday evening, I got the Cacio E Pepe wings and the Pepperoni Tray pizza. Starting with the Cacio E Pepe wings, their robust dry-rubbed flavor profile won me over. Not the most tender wings I've had, but the seasoning combined with a subtle baked crust undertone was a pleasant departure from the norm.The Crispy Pepperoni Cup Tray Pizza, however, had its highs and lows. At first glance and bite, it felt reminiscent of a cheesy bread topped with pepperoni and a hint of tomato sauce. The crunchy edges were delightful, but the thickness of the dough made for a heftier experience than I would've preferred. It teetered between the styles of a classic pizza and a Chicago deep dish, albeit minus the lavish sauce of the latter. The honey drizzle, for someone with a palate tolerant of sweetness in savory dishes, was an interesting touch. Yet, when weighing up the overall experience with its price point, it settled in the realm of satisfactory.The prices are slightly steeper than other local pizza spots, but whether it warrants the premium is debatable. Nevertheless, Johnny Pomodoro offers a curious culinary experience for those keen to venture beyond traditional pizza shop fare. While some aspects justify the price, others might leave you contemplating value. Worth a try, but set expectations accordingly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pad Thai Wings