Great food, a bit over priced for what you are getting.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Alfredo
Diane Peraino
Excellent food. Atmosphere a little to close and loud...but will return...great eggplant..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Hicks
Great food, huge portion sizes, excellent service. I just wish it wasn't so dimly
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michele H.
Johnny Macaroni's never disappoints! Huge portions and always good! I mainly order take out... indoor seating is small at both locations but definitely not bad. Bartenders at Plymouth st location were great! Haven't been to the other location in a while but I'm sure they are too.
Jerry A.
Great food and great service. Never had a bad experience here. I only wish it was easier to get out of their parking lot and out onto 106. Seems like there's always a giant pickup truck blocking the view west.
Ron Kornet
Very much enjoyed this
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kathy K.
If you want THE BEST Italian food, you have to come to Johnny Macaronis. The Gnocci Pomodoro and the Baked Lasagna was excellent. Fiona, our waitress/bartender was wonderful. We will be back...SOON!
Kathy Kornet
Fabulous Italian Restaurant! Got seated right away, and Fiona checked on us immediately. Offered us drinks, which we got. I got a Malibu Sunset, and my husband got a Captain and Ginger Ale. Both were excellent.I thought about getting the Beef Stroganoff, but when Fiona checked, they didn't have any more. But that's OK. I decided to get the baked lasagna with meat sauce, and my husband got the Gnocci Pomodoro with a meatball.The dinners were superb! The lasagna noodles were cooked perfectly, and the sauce was tasty. The Gnocci was excellent also. My husband loved it.We will definitely be back soon.We live in Florida, and now, every time we come back here to visit, we will be stopping in.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian, Meatballs
Kathryn C.
My family loves this place. My hubby is a picky eater especially when it comes to Italian food. I love everything I have tried chicken parm, chicken picatta. My hubby and son likes the sampler with meatballs lasagna and chicken parm. Staff is friendly and helpful. Cozy atmosphere. There are gluten free options. I highly recommend
D T.
They used to have good food many years ago and they are still coasting off that and location, the service is not good the chicken parm is rubbish (and that is the easiest meal to knock out of the park), I've had better food at Olive Garden
Never had a bad meal at JM. Take out or Dine In, its always great and consistent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Santos
Very good Italian. I got three meals out of my huge American chop suey.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian
Costa Trem
Nice cozy little spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joanne B.
Great service and martini's. I chose salmon piccata and my husband veal and eggplant parmesan. Both served piping hot and delicious! Plenty left for a second meal.
Paul License
This place is my absolute favorite restaurant of all time! Everyone is friendly,professional, caring and the service is beyond expectations. All their food is absolutely amazing the owners don't downsize their portions due to inflation they did go up in price with the meals but everything has.... but I'm willing to pay the extra costs due to inflation not their fault at all! I'm a regular here I go here once or twice a week and every time is a awsome experience. I come here to unwind whenever I feel stressed and life isn't going that great and every time I walk out I feel alot better. The main meal I get is Billy's bufredo it's phenomenal! The owners kid is professional and takes his job seriously and I'd love to meet the actual owners in person once in my life to tell them how much their restaurant matters not only to me but everyone in the community! I would give them 20 stars they NEVER DISAPPOINT and all their staff seems happy which means they are appreciated and that's how you run a amazing business. Bravo to your excellent service and food you're appreciated more then you will ever know. THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING YOU ALL DO !SINCERELYPAUL LICENSEVegetarian options: Yes plenty to choose fromParking: They have a big parking lot since they are amazing they are usually packed. Not their fault for having a thriving businessKid-friendliness: VeryWheelchair accessibility: Yes
Great food, a bit over priced for what you are getting.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Alfredo
Excellent food. Atmosphere a little to close and loud...but will return...great eggplant..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food, huge portion sizes, excellent service. I just wish it wasn't so dimly
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Johnny Macaroni's never disappoints! Huge portions and always good! I mainly order take out... indoor seating is small at both locations but definitely not bad. Bartenders at Plymouth st location were great! Haven't been to the other location in a while but I'm sure they are too.
Great food and great service. Never had a bad experience here. I only wish it was easier to get out of their parking lot and out onto 106. Seems like there's always a giant pickup truck blocking the view west.
Very much enjoyed this
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you want THE BEST Italian food, you have to come to Johnny Macaronis. The Gnocci Pomodoro and the Baked Lasagna was excellent. Fiona, our waitress/bartender was wonderful. We will be back...SOON!
Fabulous Italian Restaurant! Got seated right away, and Fiona checked on us immediately. Offered us drinks, which we got. I got a Malibu Sunset, and my husband got a Captain and Ginger Ale. Both were excellent.I thought about getting the Beef Stroganoff, but when Fiona checked, they didn't have any more. But that's OK. I decided to get the baked lasagna with meat sauce, and my husband got the Gnocci Pomodoro with a meatball.The dinners were superb! The lasagna noodles were cooked perfectly, and the sauce was tasty. The Gnocci was excellent also. My husband loved it.We will definitely be back soon.We live in Florida, and now, every time we come back here to visit, we will be stopping in.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian, Meatballs
My family loves this place. My hubby is a picky eater especially when it comes to Italian food. I love everything I have tried chicken parm, chicken picatta. My hubby and son likes the sampler with meatballs lasagna and chicken parm. Staff is friendly and helpful. Cozy atmosphere. There are gluten free options. I highly recommend
They used to have good food many years ago and they are still coasting off that and location, the service is not good the chicken parm is rubbish (and that is the easiest meal to knock out of the park), I've had better food at Olive Garden
Restaurantji Recommends
Never had a bad meal at JM. Take out or Dine In, its always great and consistent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good Italian. I got three meals out of my huge American chop suey.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian
Nice cozy little spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service and martini's. I chose salmon piccata and my husband veal and eggplant parmesan. Both served piping hot and delicious! Plenty left for a second meal.
This place is my absolute favorite restaurant of all time! Everyone is friendly,professional, caring and the service is beyond expectations. All their food is absolutely amazing the owners don't downsize their portions due to inflation they did go up in price with the meals but everything has.... but I'm willing to pay the extra costs due to inflation not their fault at all! I'm a regular here I go here once or twice a week and every time is a awsome experience. I come here to unwind whenever I feel stressed and life isn't going that great and every time I walk out I feel alot better. The main meal I get is Billy's bufredo it's phenomenal! The owners kid is professional and takes his job seriously and I'd love to meet the actual owners in person once in my life to tell them how much their restaurant matters not only to me but everyone in the community! I would give them 20 stars they NEVER DISAPPOINT and all their staff seems happy which means they are appreciated and that's how you run a amazing business. Bravo to your excellent service and food you're appreciated more then you will ever know. THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING YOU ALL DO !SINCERELYPAUL LICENSEVegetarian options: Yes plenty to choose fromParking: They have a big parking lot since they are amazing they are usually packed. Not their fault for having a thriving businessKid-friendliness: VeryWheelchair accessibility: Yes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm, Chicken Marsala, Italian Combo, Steak Tips, Italian, Buffredo, Alfredo