Delicious!! Both savory and sweet pies were awesome. And the most cozy and inviting atmosphere. We’ll be back!
Laura D.
Pros: -Absolutely adorable exterior & interior vibe -outdoor seating -quick service -sweet and savory options I wished there was a chocolate pie option, but there were some other chocolate sweets available and I should have tried. The hand pie we tried had a delicious buttery & flaky dough and I think I preferred it to the apple pie. If I were back in the area I'd try another hand pie and one of the chocolate offerings!
Debbi Tomel
Was very disappointed when we were told that there was only three choices of pie. Who wouldn't have apple pie!!! A New England favorite!!! Very cramped inside, little space to sit and eat.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
B. M.
One of the best bakeries I have ever been too. Cafe is cozy and stocked with countless sweet and savory goods. Definitely stop in!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alison Zabko
The parking situation is terrible. There are no signs to direct you around back just signs saying no parking. Had heard good things, but on my first time there was screamed at by another customer before even making it inside. Will not be attempting again.
Atmosphere: 1
Rachael Jennison
What a cute little pie shop. They have cookies too. Went there and got a slice of cookies and cream pie and a coke. Will be coming again with people.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie Bar, Hand Pie, Cookies, Salted Chocolate
Benny D.
This is one of the best places to pick your pie in the state of Massachusetts! I drive here once to twice a year from Boston to pick up something which is generally 1.5-3 hour drive depending on traffic. Here is generally my thoughts: Florence Pie use ingredients that are in seasons which also means apples aren't always available. If you plan to visit, I would order the morning you plan to get there or atleast the night before to place a to go order. Ask what is in season and what they recommend. When you get there, there is a lot things to eat there that aren't just pie. Savor pies, quiches, coffee, soups, and others available. I always enjoy getting a quick lunch there before I leave with some pies. If you are a post card writer, I would pick up some.
Jimmy Gonzalez
This is the BEST place for Pies! So many choices and everything is so FRESH! Whenever we are up here we make sure to live with goodies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
TheEmpress I.
New owners and the Bar has been lowered... The classic Pie Bar's pecan pie was legendary. I religiously pre-ordered it for holidays for several years. The custard was like no other: buttery in texture, just the right level of sweetness, and a deep, complex flavor with hints of cocoa. The crust was ample and flaky. A true delight. I am sad to report that pie of my dreams is no more. They have reduced the amount of crust; the rim is barely there and the bottom so thin it might at well be paper. Further, I believe they changed the fat mix, because the flakes are more or less gone. (Might just be rolled too thin, in their effort to shrink their crust cost.) Worst of all, the custard is now cloying, simple, and just like any other pecan pie filling I have had: boring, gelatinous, and sickly sweet. The lemon chess filling was fine, but the skimpy crust was fatal flaw. Finally, the new owners lack grace completely. They do not say thank you. They do not chat. Your thank you is met with: 'No problem'--a graceless response. We do not owe you our business! Goodbye, I will miss my delightful pies and pray for a day that someone serious about quality and appreciative of their customers opens a new shop...
rick marinaro
Not what I was expecting in pies but the different assortment looked
This is our favorite spot in the Northampton area -- new owners really improved everything:) Love the layout, service is super attentive and friendly, food is wonderful. Always new things on the menu and -- as expected -- the pie crusts are wonderful. So glad to have this here!
Layannie Haydon-Mayer
This is a nice little pie shop with sweet and savory pies and coffee. It had great outside seating.
Darryl Ventura
Unique flavorful pies, great coffee, lots of treats and even meat pies for a meal if your really hungry! Nice staff :))
Rhine Merten
Under new management! The same folks who run Familiar on Noho. The pastries are still great, the coffee is better, you're welcome inside again. Prices are high but so is quality.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Olivia Rossetti
One of my favorite spots! I always make a point to stop in when I’m nearby. The pie crust? Possibly the best I’ve ever had.
Delicious!! Both savory and sweet pies were awesome. And the most cozy and inviting atmosphere. We’ll be back!
Pros: -Absolutely adorable exterior & interior vibe -outdoor seating -quick service -sweet and savory options I wished there was a chocolate pie option, but there were some other chocolate sweets available and I should have tried. The hand pie we tried had a delicious buttery & flaky dough and I think I preferred it to the apple pie. If I were back in the area I'd try another hand pie and one of the chocolate offerings!
Was very disappointed when we were told that there was only three choices of pie. Who wouldn't have apple pie!!! A New England favorite!!! Very cramped inside, little space to sit and eat.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
One of the best bakeries I have ever been too. Cafe is cozy and stocked with countless sweet and savory goods. Definitely stop in!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The parking situation is terrible. There are no signs to direct you around back just signs saying no parking. Had heard good things, but on my first time there was screamed at by another customer before even making it inside. Will not be attempting again.
Atmosphere: 1
What a cute little pie shop. They have cookies too. Went there and got a slice of cookies and cream pie and a coke. Will be coming again with people.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie Bar, Hand Pie, Cookies, Salted Chocolate
This is one of the best places to pick your pie in the state of Massachusetts! I drive here once to twice a year from Boston to pick up something which is generally 1.5-3 hour drive depending on traffic. Here is generally my thoughts: Florence Pie use ingredients that are in seasons which also means apples aren't always available. If you plan to visit, I would order the morning you plan to get there or atleast the night before to place a to go order. Ask what is in season and what they recommend. When you get there, there is a lot things to eat there that aren't just pie. Savor pies, quiches, coffee, soups, and others available. I always enjoy getting a quick lunch there before I leave with some pies. If you are a post card writer, I would pick up some.
This is the BEST place for Pies! So many choices and everything is so FRESH! Whenever we are up here we make sure to live with goodies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
New owners and the Bar has been lowered... The classic Pie Bar's pecan pie was legendary. I religiously pre-ordered it for holidays for several years. The custard was like no other: buttery in texture, just the right level of sweetness, and a deep, complex flavor with hints of cocoa. The crust was ample and flaky. A true delight. I am sad to report that pie of my dreams is no more. They have reduced the amount of crust; the rim is barely there and the bottom so thin it might at well be paper. Further, I believe they changed the fat mix, because the flakes are more or less gone. (Might just be rolled too thin, in their effort to shrink their crust cost.) Worst of all, the custard is now cloying, simple, and just like any other pecan pie filling I have had: boring, gelatinous, and sickly sweet. The lemon chess filling was fine, but the skimpy crust was fatal flaw. Finally, the new owners lack grace completely. They do not say thank you. They do not chat. Your thank you is met with: 'No problem'--a graceless response. We do not owe you our business! Goodbye, I will miss my delightful pies and pray for a day that someone serious about quality and appreciative of their customers opens a new shop...
Not what I was expecting in pies but the different assortment looked
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cookies
Restaurantji Recommends
This is our favorite spot in the Northampton area -- new owners really improved everything:) Love the layout, service is super attentive and friendly, food is wonderful. Always new things on the menu and -- as expected -- the pie crusts are wonderful. So glad to have this here!
This is a nice little pie shop with sweet and savory pies and coffee. It had great outside seating.
Unique flavorful pies, great coffee, lots of treats and even meat pies for a meal if your really hungry! Nice staff :))
Under new management! The same folks who run Familiar on Noho. The pastries are still great, the coffee is better, you're welcome inside again. Prices are high but so is quality.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of my favorite spots! I always make a point to stop in when I’m nearby. The pie crust? Possibly the best I’ve ever had.