Best pizza in the North shore Great salad Dressing, great Toasted subs And we miss you Bill
Deanna Smith
Thought their subs were a bit pricey, $12+ for a small Italian. Asked for "just a little bit" of salad dressing in my Italian sub, cuz that's how I like it, and it was completely slathered in dressing. This must have been the first time someone asked for that. And it was so full I could not eat it without it falling apart and getting the dressing all over my hands. The dressing flavor dominated. Was it still delicious? Yes.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Tl O.
This place is ridiculous. I called twice, but the phone service was out. Strange. So, I drove over, and they had taken their phone off the hook. I asked for a menu and they told me they didn't have any. None. I ordered a pizza off a piece of paper with no prices on it. I tried to pay and the young man who was waiting on me told me he didn't know the exact price. So I said, "I'll google it." He said, "Well we don't have a website." They actually had a light-up menu board, but he had turned it off. This is the worst service I've ever seen at any restaurant. The pizza was mediocre. It was a complete clown show. I don't know how they stay in business.
Mel Beano
I drive from Hull to get a pizza. it's that good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Evan
Good food. But extremely overpriced. Everything here is $3+ more expensive than any other pizza place. I get it's Marblehead and the population here is wealthy but nonetheless, overpriced. $14 for a small one topping pizza.$15 for a large sub. Absolutely ridiculous.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Michael Hughes
The pizza here has an tangy sauce. Like they use spaghettios or something.My only experience here was too inconvenient to consider returning. I placed a pickup order but they dont have a website in the year 2023 so it turns out the online pdf menus I found were from years ago.I only realized this when I was hit over the head by how much my order actually was going to cost when I got there. They also do not have a frialator nor do they accept cash in 2023.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
Alexander Gillis
Great Pizza, not skimpy on the toppings. Fair prices and friendly staff. Cash only!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Dan Tucker
Great Greek style pizza, great calzones, great steak subs.Don't forget that they're still cash only
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren Shuman
The chicken kabob salad is the best.
Carla Cooper
While visiting, we found this place, and the pizza was terrific (mushrrom, onion, and sausage, best sausage ever) plus couldn't beat the price. Totally recommend it!
Our neighbor recommended we try Marblehead House of Pizza and suggested we get small pizza's because they're "more crispy." We didn't know what to expect and I'm so excited we ordered. We got 2 small pizza's : pepperoni on one and Buffalo chicken on the other. I'd compare it to a very thin deep dish pizza because you can tell it was cooked in a pan, and brings all the crispy edges and bits you could ever want. We'll definitely order again, the pizza was great!
Adam Jaillet
It's a small town shop. Small town recipes, so you know the food is top-notch. Customer service and staff? Mint!But please, bring cash. My God. Bring. Cash. They do not take credit / debit. To all my fellow tourists, consider this a warning! The closest ATM is 2 buildings down the road and requires a debit card to be inserted onto the door of the building to have access. Normally, it's not a problem. But the door did not read my card. Had to try 4 different banks to get to an ATM. bring cash. I can not stress that enough.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
James B.
Awesome pizza, friendly service, casual family-oriented atmosphere, great location. There is nothing else to add.
Abby Miller
Won’t be back. Way too much money for a meatball sub with 4 small meatballs. They don’t take credit cards and it’s not anywhere on the door. Had to leave and go to the bank to pay for a sandwich that wasn’t worth it. It’s not the same as it used to be
Adeline Flynn
I called to get a junior beef. The owner (I assume) answered and gave me serious attitude. I guess they don't go by the same sizes as every other roast beef shop on the north shore. They're special guys! I got there and he threw a huge sub sandwich on the counter, because although he knew what I was asking for, he had to make some stupid point. He said 'you're not from around here'. Get a grip buddy. You're a greek pizza place - you're not reinventing the roast beef sandwich wheel by rejecting the sizing that everyone else goes by.Anyways, even though it was a terrible experience, I was still looking forward to the sandwich. Beyond the bad customer service, this is literally the worst roast beef I have ever had. Waste of money and food. I would recommend any of the other million roast beef places around that don't pretend they're special.
Best pizza in the North shore Great salad Dressing, great Toasted subs And we miss you Bill
Thought their subs were a bit pricey, $12+ for a small Italian. Asked for "just a little bit" of salad dressing in my Italian sub, cuz that's how I like it, and it was completely slathered in dressing. This must have been the first time someone asked for that. And it was so full I could not eat it without it falling apart and getting the dressing all over my hands. The dressing flavor dominated. Was it still delicious? Yes.
Food: 3
Service: 3
This place is ridiculous. I called twice, but the phone service was out. Strange. So, I drove over, and they had taken their phone off the hook. I asked for a menu and they told me they didn't have any. None. I ordered a pizza off a piece of paper with no prices on it. I tried to pay and the young man who was waiting on me told me he didn't know the exact price. So I said, "I'll google it." He said, "Well we don't have a website." They actually had a light-up menu board, but he had turned it off. This is the worst service I've ever seen at any restaurant. The pizza was mediocre. It was a complete clown show. I don't know how they stay in business.
I drive from Hull to get a pizza. it's that good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Good food. But extremely overpriced. Everything here is $3+ more expensive than any other pizza place. I get it's Marblehead and the population here is wealthy but nonetheless, overpriced. $14 for a small one topping pizza.$15 for a large sub. Absolutely ridiculous.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
The pizza here has an tangy sauce. Like they use spaghettios or something.My only experience here was too inconvenient to consider returning. I placed a pickup order but they dont have a website in the year 2023 so it turns out the online pdf menus I found were from years ago.I only realized this when I was hit over the head by how much my order actually was going to cost when I got there. They also do not have a frialator nor do they accept cash in 2023.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
Great Pizza, not skimpy on the toppings. Fair prices and friendly staff. Cash only!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Great Greek style pizza, great calzones, great steak subs.Don't forget that they're still cash only
Food: 5
Service: 5
The chicken kabob salad is the best.
While visiting, we found this place, and the pizza was terrific (mushrrom, onion, and sausage, best sausage ever) plus couldn't beat the price. Totally recommend it!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Our neighbor recommended we try Marblehead House of Pizza and suggested we get small pizza's because they're "more crispy." We didn't know what to expect and I'm so excited we ordered. We got 2 small pizza's : pepperoni on one and Buffalo chicken on the other. I'd compare it to a very thin deep dish pizza because you can tell it was cooked in a pan, and brings all the crispy edges and bits you could ever want. We'll definitely order again, the pizza was great!
It's a small town shop. Small town recipes, so you know the food is top-notch. Customer service and staff? Mint!But please, bring cash. My God. Bring. Cash. They do not take credit / debit. To all my fellow tourists, consider this a warning! The closest ATM is 2 buildings down the road and requires a debit card to be inserted onto the door of the building to have access. Normally, it's not a problem. But the door did not read my card. Had to try 4 different banks to get to an ATM. bring cash. I can not stress that enough.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Awesome pizza, friendly service, casual family-oriented atmosphere, great location. There is nothing else to add.
Won’t be back. Way too much money for a meatball sub with 4 small meatballs. They don’t take credit cards and it’s not anywhere on the door. Had to leave and go to the bank to pay for a sandwich that wasn’t worth it. It’s not the same as it used to be
I called to get a junior beef. The owner (I assume) answered and gave me serious attitude. I guess they don't go by the same sizes as every other roast beef shop on the north shore. They're special guys! I got there and he threw a huge sub sandwich on the counter, because although he knew what I was asking for, he had to make some stupid point. He said 'you're not from around here'. Get a grip buddy. You're a greek pizza place - you're not reinventing the roast beef sandwich wheel by rejecting the sizing that everyone else goes by.Anyways, even though it was a terrible experience, I was still looking forward to the sandwich. Beyond the bad customer service, this is literally the worst roast beef I have ever had. Waste of money and food. I would recommend any of the other million roast beef places around that don't pretend they're special.