Great location, clean place , friendly staff, unfortunately the pizza lacks seasoning .. wasn’t tasting perfect .
Deb Farmer
No directions to find them, inside another store. Disabled people can't walk to look for it.
GIOVANNI LOPEZ
I like the place but will be better if pizza Hut open a full RESTAURANT
J W.
Best pizza in town and it's not even close. 2 dollar slice deal for a giant slice. The owner is a great guy.
Erin L.
I was recently at a hockey tournament in Marlboro and needed to order good food for a team of hungry girls and their families. The Plum Tomato did not disappoint! Despite it being a large order, the food was absolutely outstanding. The fresh ingredients were apparent in all of the different pizza varieties we ordered and the two different salads. 35 kids/adults said it was the BEST pizza they had ever had! Thank you to TPT for satisfying a "tough" bunch and for your commitment to offering something better than the rest!
Edward Smith
Would definitely recommend trying out this place. Great mood, tasty food, good service. Keep it up.
Jamie E.
Siciliano pizza is tremendously amazing. Loaded with cheese and right amount of toppings. Salads always fresh and at least 2 meals. Quick and courteous staff. Prices are great for quality of food.
Dawn E.
The Plum Tomato is wonderful. One day. And mediocre the next. For the same pizza. I don't know if it's different chefs but it's super inconsistent. That said, they're the only decent game in town that delivers IMHO so there you go. I rounded to 4 because it's better than 3 but really 3.5 is where I'd land.
EJ K.
I've lived in Marlborough for four years and this place has been a favorite since day one. Food is great and the staff is friendly. Fresh ingredients...it's always appreciated when your dinner tastes like someone took the time to make it instead of just shoveling orders out the window. Everything is great, really. Pizza, calzones subs, fries, salads. Everything tastes great and there are so many different and delicious flavor combinations too. Just wanted to brag about my favorite spot. My favorite pizza in the area hands down.
Ncd112 D.
Food is usually good but ordered by the app at 530 and its now 720 and still no food. Called and they said they have no idea where it is and they cant do anything. So i have no idea if the food is still being delivered or not. My kid is starving so now i need to make him something and i wasted all that money on now cold pizza.
Ordered two small subs and we picked them up. They were busy but unorganized totally. When we got the subs they were very small. The size was like they made a large and cut them in half. We used to get decent sizes. Wow very disappointed!
J L.
As new residents of Marlborough, we have been in search of great pizza, the go to place when we need our pizza fix. This is not that place. This review is after visiting The Plum Tomato two previous times in the past two months. Basically, the pizza is dry; there is not enough sauce. Additionally, the last two visits they placed ingredients on sparingly. During our second visit we thought the sparse ingredients could have been from the closing for vacation during the 4th of July week but it was not. The people are very nice and very welcoming. I love frequenting a local business.
Marvel Marvel
Okay, let's do this one last time, yeah? For real this time. This is it. My name is Miles Morales. I was bitten by a radioactive spider, And for like two days, I've been the one and only Spider-Man. I think you know the rest. I finished my essay, saved a bunch of people, got hit by a drone, I did this with my dad, met my roommate finally, slapped a sticker where my Dad's never gonna find it, and when I feel alone, like no one understands what I'm going through, I remember my friends who get it. I never thought I'd be able to do any of this stuff, but I can. Anyone can wear the mask. You could wear the mask. If you didn't know that before, I hope you do now. 'Cause I'm Spider-Man, and I'm not the only one. Not by a long shot.
Scott J.
Very hit or miss lately. If I didn't live so close, I'd be going elsewhere. The last few subs and salads we ordered were very disappointing. Appetizer combo is usually very good though. Quality of food has gone downhill drastically the last year or so.
Bernadette M.
We have become regulars for takeout/delivery. Tonight was very disappointing. First off tried for over 40 minutes and couldn't get through by phone. It was either busy or rang and rang and then went busy. Finally gave up and placed the order online even though one of the dishes we wanted wasn't available on the online menu. Forgot one item on the order and tried to go back to add it. Got a message that orders were no longer being accepted. Again couldn't get through via phone to add the item. We ordered the chicken broccoli with "creamy alfredo sauce" and the chicken parm dinner. Both were ordered with extra chicken and the parm was ordered with extra sauce. The dishes didn't seem to have either. The alfredo had no flavor and the sauce was like milk in both consistency and flavor. The chicken parm came with cold pasta. Don't know what went on tonight but hoping this was an anomaly.
Great location, clean place , friendly staff, unfortunately the pizza lacks seasoning .. wasn’t tasting perfect .
No directions to find them, inside another store. Disabled people can't walk to look for it.
I like the place but will be better if pizza Hut open a full RESTAURANT
Best pizza in town and it's not even close. 2 dollar slice deal for a giant slice. The owner is a great guy.
I was recently at a hockey tournament in Marlboro and needed to order good food for a team of hungry girls and their families. The Plum Tomato did not disappoint! Despite it being a large order, the food was absolutely outstanding. The fresh ingredients were apparent in all of the different pizza varieties we ordered and the two different salads. 35 kids/adults said it was the BEST pizza they had ever had! Thank you to TPT for satisfying a "tough" bunch and for your commitment to offering something better than the rest!
Would definitely recommend trying out this place. Great mood, tasty food, good service. Keep it up.
Siciliano pizza is tremendously amazing. Loaded with cheese and right amount of toppings. Salads always fresh and at least 2 meals. Quick and courteous staff. Prices are great for quality of food.
The Plum Tomato is wonderful. One day. And mediocre the next. For the same pizza. I don't know if it's different chefs but it's super inconsistent. That said, they're the only decent game in town that delivers IMHO so there you go. I rounded to 4 because it's better than 3 but really 3.5 is where I'd land.
I've lived in Marlborough for four years and this place has been a favorite since day one. Food is great and the staff is friendly. Fresh ingredients...it's always appreciated when your dinner tastes like someone took the time to make it instead of just shoveling orders out the window. Everything is great, really. Pizza, calzones subs, fries, salads. Everything tastes great and there are so many different and delicious flavor combinations too. Just wanted to brag about my favorite spot. My favorite pizza in the area hands down.
Food is usually good but ordered by the app at 530 and its now 720 and still no food. Called and they said they have no idea where it is and they cant do anything. So i have no idea if the food is still being delivered or not. My kid is starving so now i need to make him something and i wasted all that money on now cold pizza.
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered two small subs and we picked them up. They were busy but unorganized totally. When we got the subs they were very small. The size was like they made a large and cut them in half. We used to get decent sizes. Wow very disappointed!
As new residents of Marlborough, we have been in search of great pizza, the go to place when we need our pizza fix. This is not that place. This review is after visiting The Plum Tomato two previous times in the past two months. Basically, the pizza is dry; there is not enough sauce. Additionally, the last two visits they placed ingredients on sparingly. During our second visit we thought the sparse ingredients could have been from the closing for vacation during the 4th of July week but it was not. The people are very nice and very welcoming. I love frequenting a local business.
Okay, let's do this one last time, yeah? For real this time. This is it. My name is Miles Morales. I was bitten by a radioactive spider, And for like two days, I've been the one and only Spider-Man. I think you know the rest. I finished my essay, saved a bunch of people, got hit by a drone, I did this with my dad, met my roommate finally, slapped a sticker where my Dad's never gonna find it, and when I feel alone, like no one understands what I'm going through, I remember my friends who get it. I never thought I'd be able to do any of this stuff, but I can. Anyone can wear the mask. You could wear the mask. If you didn't know that before, I hope you do now. 'Cause I'm Spider-Man, and I'm not the only one. Not by a long shot.
Very hit or miss lately. If I didn't live so close, I'd be going elsewhere. The last few subs and salads we ordered were very disappointing. Appetizer combo is usually very good though. Quality of food has gone downhill drastically the last year or so.
We have become regulars for takeout/delivery. Tonight was very disappointing. First off tried for over 40 minutes and couldn't get through by phone. It was either busy or rang and rang and then went busy. Finally gave up and placed the order online even though one of the dishes we wanted wasn't available on the online menu. Forgot one item on the order and tried to go back to add it. Got a message that orders were no longer being accepted. Again couldn't get through via phone to add the item. We ordered the chicken broccoli with "creamy alfredo sauce" and the chicken parm dinner. Both were ordered with extra chicken and the parm was ordered with extra sauce. The dishes didn't seem to have either. The alfredo had no flavor and the sauce was like milk in both consistency and flavor. The chicken parm came with cold pasta. Don't know what went on tonight but hoping this was an anomaly.