Closest to a Chicago beef sandwich since I've lived on the East coast. BONUS that it was on a gluten free roll that didn't crumble with the au jous!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Neil Alper
Got the Rueben, I’m sorry it was terrible, I threw half of it away. I’ve had Rueben’s made with pastrami before, the pastrami tasted more like a barbecue beef brisket, the flavor from the pastrami was overpowering and completely ruined the sandwich for me. Best part of sandwich was the bread, very disappointing. Bringing the Italian with prosciutto to my wife for lunch, we will see what she thinks
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Shirley Ellsey
OMG. The sandwiches are huge and stuffed full. Would recommend them to one and all.
You get your money's worth.
Rob “CyFoniK” Flaherty
The ultimate Italian, the bear, the stuffed meatball, and the roast beef...You guys have a special place in my heart and stomach .Parking: Charging spots for the electric cars too I believe.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Bear, Stuffed Meatball Sub, Ultimate Italian
Robert Fortado
From the very first time I walked in here I knew I was going to love this place. The staff is very friendly, place is always clean, and their sandwiches/subs are truly ambrosial! I started things off with their Deluxe Italian - would definitely recommend! Since I have also had their Jammin’ & notorious Triple Crown sandwiches - all very impressive! Great place for a quick bite or social hour. They have backyard games like corn hole, as well as, live music at the pub!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deluxe Italian
Melissa Burns
Our go to place for take out!!! From the Reuben to the cutlets to the onion rings!!! All amazing! Their ice cream is favorite! Can’t say
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Reuben, Onion Rings
Daniel Ceritto
A little disappointed with my visit tonight. I haven't been here in a while and usually it's a good experience whether food or ice cream. Tonight was off putting when the guy working in the kitchen came over and said to the girl serving me ice cream that I don't have a problem kicking people out, were closed etc. To be fair it was 20 minutes before close which I usually don't do but my girlfriend had just lost her grandmother that morning and needed a pick me up. To be fair the cashier brushed it off and said no it was okay and was pleasant for the transaction which is why it's 3 stars and not 1.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
Peter sieg
Website says open until 8:00 on Sunday . When you call they won’t take your order and tell you they close at 6:00
Jean C.
Don't get me wrong, we love this place, but they need to update their website for Sunday hours. Website states 9am to 8pm. Still closing at 6pm on Sunday is strange since that is when most people eat dinner! Guess they don't need the business!
Lee D
We were there for an event in the attached function space. Food was top-notch. Bar staff were great!
Very disappointed today. I usually love Pica's Deli. Today my caprese sub was barely full and dry.
Food: 2
Dave Nichols
NOTHING ... NOTHING beats the chicken cutlet sandwiches.Except may the fries we tried for the first time the other day. More straws than traditional fries, so absolutely crisp and totally addicting.My poor wife got only a few. I tried not to eat them all on the way home.I succeeded. Sort of.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
aematthews76
Good sandwiches but pricey. Fries or a bag of chips should be included with a 20 dollar sub. Great roast beef sandwich,chicken cutlet and steak and cheese
Best sandwich I’ve had in the area. Over never eaten at the restaurant but this deli is putting out some amazing sandwiches. Larges are x2 subs. I got the cutlet with all fixings and bacon and god damn this place delivered. Their Mozzo sticks are amazing too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ava C.
A Saturday afternoon we found ourselves first timers here. It was not busy so we ordered right away. The customer service was great. I ordered the Mayflower. It tasted great. I took away a star because the bee problem outside was abnormally bothersome.
Closest to a Chicago beef sandwich since I've lived on the East coast. BONUS that it was on a gluten free roll that didn't crumble with the au jous!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got the Rueben, I’m sorry it was terrible, I threw half of it away. I’ve had Rueben’s made with pastrami before, the pastrami tasted more like a barbecue beef brisket, the flavor from the pastrami was overpowering and completely ruined the sandwich for me. Best part of sandwich was the bread, very disappointing. Bringing the Italian with prosciutto to my wife for lunch, we will see what she thinks
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
OMG. The sandwiches are huge and stuffed full. Would recommend them to one and all. You get your money's worth.
The ultimate Italian, the bear, the stuffed meatball, and the roast beef...You guys have a special place in my heart and stomach .Parking: Charging spots for the electric cars too I believe.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Bear, Stuffed Meatball Sub, Ultimate Italian
From the very first time I walked in here I knew I was going to love this place. The staff is very friendly, place is always clean, and their sandwiches/subs are truly ambrosial! I started things off with their Deluxe Italian - would definitely recommend! Since I have also had their Jammin’ & notorious Triple Crown sandwiches - all very impressive! Great place for a quick bite or social hour. They have backyard games like corn hole, as well as, live music at the pub!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deluxe Italian
Our go to place for take out!!! From the Reuben to the cutlets to the onion rings!!! All amazing! Their ice cream is favorite! Can’t say
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Reuben, Onion Rings
A little disappointed with my visit tonight. I haven't been here in a while and usually it's a good experience whether food or ice cream. Tonight was off putting when the guy working in the kitchen came over and said to the girl serving me ice cream that I don't have a problem kicking people out, were closed etc. To be fair it was 20 minutes before close which I usually don't do but my girlfriend had just lost her grandmother that morning and needed a pick me up. To be fair the cashier brushed it off and said no it was okay and was pleasant for the transaction which is why it's 3 stars and not 1.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
Website says open until 8:00 on Sunday . When you call they won’t take your order and tell you they close at 6:00
Don't get me wrong, we love this place, but they need to update their website for Sunday hours. Website states 9am to 8pm. Still closing at 6pm on Sunday is strange since that is when most people eat dinner! Guess they don't need the business!
We were there for an event in the attached function space. Food was top-notch. Bar staff were great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Very disappointed today. I usually love Pica's Deli. Today my caprese sub was barely full and dry.
Food: 2
NOTHING ... NOTHING beats the chicken cutlet sandwiches.Except may the fries we tried for the first time the other day. More straws than traditional fries, so absolutely crisp and totally addicting.My poor wife got only a few. I tried not to eat them all on the way home.I succeeded. Sort of.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good sandwiches but pricey. Fries or a bag of chips should be included with a 20 dollar sub. Great roast beef sandwich,chicken cutlet and steak and cheese
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Meatball Sub, Clucking Pig
Best sandwich I’ve had in the area. Over never eaten at the restaurant but this deli is putting out some amazing sandwiches. Larges are x2 subs. I got the cutlet with all fixings and bacon and god damn this place delivered. Their Mozzo sticks are amazing too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A Saturday afternoon we found ourselves first timers here. It was not busy so we ordered right away. The customer service was great. I ordered the Mayflower. It tasted great. I took away a star because the bee problem outside was abnormally bothersome.