Been a few times, mostly for my family. Mom says 8/10 son rates in at 9/10! Me 7/10 daughter picks 4/10 ouch! Have to say good food. But when I took the first bite from my meatball sub there was only sauce and bread….. and I have a big mouth! This was a bummer because it was delicious! $$?? will try again w/new report.
Connor McKeon
Best pizza on island if you just want a “pizza”
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Cronyck Rodriguez
It sells very good food and it is an excellent service. I definitely recommend it to go eat with your family or friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Travis Nichols
This is my favorite year-round pizza place on island! Sophie T's is generous with toppings, quick with service, and a fair value for the island. My favorite pizza is the prosciutto &
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy H.
GF pizza was good. Better than most GF take out pizza options. I would defiantly order again. Wedge salad was not so much. No bacon? Bacon is a Key ingredient of the classic wedge! We added grilled chicken to the salad...again, not so much. The chicken was just not good. No flavor, kind of fake in texture and had a bad flavor!
Jim M.
There are much better options on the island such as Pi. Soggy, flavorless slab of dough.
Jessica J.
If you're craving just like a normal regular pie pizza, this is the place. They have perfected their Greek salad & dressing and we always have the best experience ordering from here.
John D (JD)
Friendly spot with good pizza joint menu. Nice people working there and eating there.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jamie M.
I ordered delivery and my order came very quick. The pizza was absolutely delicious, full of flavor, full of toppings. Absolutely delicious. I will 100% be back and highly recommend anyone wanting pizza on Nantucket get their pizza at Sophie T's! Five stars
Born and raised in New Jersey and recently relocated to Nantucket, this is a taste of home and a brand new experience rolled out, topped with sauce and cheese, and baked just right. We ordered over the phone for pickup, which made me feel like a kid again. And, what is pizza if it's not nostalgic? I would choose Sophie T's whether we were in New Jersey, Massachusetts or even Italy.
bL Gaudette
Great pizza, good lunch spot
Ed McCaney
Great spot for quick bites. I was on island for work, it is an easy location to get to without going all the way into town. Recommend the chicken bacon ranch pizza or meatball sub.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aileen M.
Definitely a great family friendly pizza location on the island. The pizza is a standard NYC pizza which is approachable for kids. They have unique slices you can try on the go. The best part of Sophie T's is the hospitality they provide to their guests. Every visit was pleasant. It's refreshing compared to other places on the island.
Ruth Tonico
Always fresh with big slices, customer service may need a little improvement because it always feels like their rushing you to order. Other than that the pizza ? is great ??Vegetarian options: They have veggie pizza options Parking: parking is limited especially during peak hours which is usually around lunch time, so either go early enough or late in order to beat the crowd
Thanks for pizza so
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Been a few times, mostly for my family. Mom says 8/10 son rates in at 9/10! Me 7/10 daughter picks 4/10 ouch! Have to say good food. But when I took the first bite from my meatball sub there was only sauce and bread….. and I have a big mouth! This was a bummer because it was delicious! $$?? will try again w/new report.
Best pizza on island if you just want a “pizza”
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza
It sells very good food and it is an excellent service. I definitely recommend it to go eat with your family or friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is my favorite year-round pizza place on island! Sophie T's is generous with toppings, quick with service, and a fair value for the island. My favorite pizza is the prosciutto &
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
GF pizza was good. Better than most GF take out pizza options. I would defiantly order again. Wedge salad was not so much. No bacon? Bacon is a Key ingredient of the classic wedge! We added grilled chicken to the salad...again, not so much. The chicken was just not good. No flavor, kind of fake in texture and had a bad flavor!
There are much better options on the island such as Pi. Soggy, flavorless slab of dough.
If you're craving just like a normal regular pie pizza, this is the place. They have perfected their Greek salad & dressing and we always have the best experience ordering from here.
Friendly spot with good pizza joint menu. Nice people working there and eating there.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered delivery and my order came very quick. The pizza was absolutely delicious, full of flavor, full of toppings. Absolutely delicious. I will 100% be back and highly recommend anyone wanting pizza on Nantucket get their pizza at Sophie T's! Five stars
Restaurantji Recommends
Born and raised in New Jersey and recently relocated to Nantucket, this is a taste of home and a brand new experience rolled out, topped with sauce and cheese, and baked just right. We ordered over the phone for pickup, which made me feel like a kid again. And, what is pizza if it's not nostalgic? I would choose Sophie T's whether we were in New Jersey, Massachusetts or even Italy.
Great pizza, good lunch spot
Great spot for quick bites. I was on island for work, it is an easy location to get to without going all the way into town. Recommend the chicken bacon ranch pizza or meatball sub.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Definitely a great family friendly pizza location on the island. The pizza is a standard NYC pizza which is approachable for kids. They have unique slices you can try on the go. The best part of Sophie T's is the hospitality they provide to their guests. Every visit was pleasant. It's refreshing compared to other places on the island.
Always fresh with big slices, customer service may need a little improvement because it always feels like their rushing you to order. Other than that the pizza ? is great ??Vegetarian options: They have veggie pizza options Parking: parking is limited especially during peak hours which is usually around lunch time, so either go early enough or late in order to beat the crowd