Jersey Mike's Subs

35 Storey Ave, Newburyport
(978) 961-0441

Recent Reviews

Jo-Ann G.

Love that they have gluten free bread!! Subs are always fresh and delicious!! Especially like the #17

Lala Spring

I ordered through the Jersey mikes app for delivery. It arrived 20 minutes early and came out great! I got the turkey mikes way and added mayo. It’s not soggy and the produce is fresh. I even got the mini and saved the other half for tomorrow.Dietary restrictions: There are gluten free bread options for the whole menu and you can get the product in a bowl.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brownie

mandy beth

Ordered online at noon. It said 15 minutes and then when completed the order it said 30 minutes. No big deal. I show up at 12:10 in case it was ready early. Friendly cashier asks my name and they ask, who I find out after, is the OWNER if it was ready. He yells out "No, because she's 30 minutes early" which I calmly told him, I was 20 minutes early and I didn't mind waiting. As I was waiting, 5 customers came in after me and got their food. I told him nicely that next time, I won't order online, I'll just go in, since he served then first even though they came in after me. Then I asked who the manager was. When they told me that he was the owner I was appalled that he spoke like that! Cashier apologized and made my sub after about 10 minutes. I didn't mind the wait, but I did mind his rude mouth and behavior. I'll never go back.

dick b.

Quite frankly, I can't see how this store could get anything but a 5. Everything my wife, family and friends have had has been outstanding. Someone complaining about the meat in a sub, my goodness, the sandwiches are packed. The steak and cheese has real meat, not "mystery meat," and all the kids that work there are great. Don't let any of these "bogus" bad reviews deter you, you will thank me.

D P

Great sandwich and service. No complaints.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jillian Z.

Surprisingly Tasty. But Not Tasty Enough To Go There On A Monthly Basis. Subway Is Better.

Charles Rizzo

The best subs around.You have to try the Turkey Club Mike's Way.Yummy ? ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Club Sub

Maxx Levesque (maxx)

Great food. Been to this location many times and I’m never disappointed with the food. The workers are especially kind. The one with the pink hair is very efficient and friendly :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Club Sub

Cheryl Haley

Very disappointed. Been to other Jersey Mike's and have always had a quality sub. Last time we ordered from this Jersey Mike's we were not overly impressed. We gave it another shot and have to say they failed miserably. Steak and cheese was overcooked. Cold subs were too oily which made them soggy. Not much in any of the subs. More bread than filling. Think we are done with this location.

Food: 1

Kellie Kelley

Steak and cheese was greasy, bread fell apart as soon as it was picked up. Tasted awful, could not get through 2 bites.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Heidi Townsend

Order#26. It was terrible unedible me and my aunt couldn't even eat it after two bites and it was just terrible call this is terrible can I bring it in and she's like yeah rude right there so I should have knownsoo I bring it in and they're like well we can't give you a refund and I'm like really you can't give me my 10 or even at 5 of it back believe me I don't want to coupon for 10 cuz I //would never eat. This garba?

Food: 1

Service: 4

Heidi T.

The presentation for the 26th was wonderful but do not get it it was tough salty awful unedible I wish I could take a picture cuz the presentation was beautiful but cannot eat it I am wish I could return it but that would just be useless Adventure back there

Annalie B.

sandwich was good but the one with pink hair didn't put my applewood spoked bacon on my sub and I am upset to be quite frank.

chris mcnulty

Can't beat Jersey

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

M Wright

Just an epic sandwich place...always consistently good with all kinds of options. The staff is great too!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Jersey Shore

Load More