Great food and great service. Will definitely return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Short Rib Poutine, Bolognese
Thanh Shortall
Love this place! Good vibes here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
William O.
Food quality is very good, try the mussels, Service is consistent and above what most people expect and ambiance is upscale & friendly.
Ralph M.
Food is good, service is good, ambiance is great! I think it's a solid 4 - the building is fairly new and the design is a very nice tavern. We enjoyed the Thursday night special the last time we went - a nice bottle of wine, an appetizer and 2 entrees for $75.
Kaitlyn A.
Black lantern is one of my favorite spots!! Food is always consistently amazing as well as the service!! Joey is the best and always has a smile on his face! Couldn't recommend more!
Linda M.
I really don't understand the 5 star reviews. The restaurant itself is beautiful and it has a great ambiance and the service is good but the actual food is mediocre at best. I've eaten here a dozen or so times since moving to Redbrook and I've yet to get a really good meal. Extremely overcooked burgers, short ribs that are tough as nails, flavorless seafood, meatballs and steak tips. I think I've tried most of the menu hoping it gets better but it never does. I've repeatedly left disappointed. I'll definitely keep coming here for a few glasses of wine because it's so close but I don't think I'll be ordering the food anymore.
Prudence Remick (Prudy)
This is a very nice place to eat in the food is really
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari, Carrot Cake
Paul Driscoll
Food was good, $20 prime rib special. Really enjoyed the music of the Darling Duo and hope to see them here again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Maureen Pizzi
Very nice place. Guitar singer was wonderful. Leg tater tots were excellent ?. Steak and cheese rolls were the same as everywhere. Thinking about sneaking in for a dinner soon. S little pricy. Needs more parking spaces! And outside night lights.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Mike B.
So I was looking for something new in the area and read some reviews on this place and decided to give it a try. We were a little early for dinner so decided to get an appetizer and some salads before the dinner menu was offered. We ordered the tater tot kegs with bacon cheddar and chives, they were very tasty with a nice crispy outside and a really pillowy inside. None of the components overpowered the other which made them that much better. The salads were very fresh and the dressings were great. When the mains came out I was pleasantly surprised at how fresh and hot everything was, my steak was cooked to perfection and the potatoes wedges were a very nice touch instead of the same old mashed potatoes. The green beans were not overcooked and had a nice garlic taste too them as well. My wife's meal was nicely prepared and the mushroom sauce was excellent and the braised short ribs were very flavorful and very tender, and the onion rings were excellent as well. I can't wait to return and try the other items on the menu!
Truly one of our favorite places. Food is outstanding, atmosphere is absolutely beautiful and service is friendly and quick. So glad this place is top notch and only 2 mi from where we live in Wareham. Favorite date nights for myself and hubby is at the Black lantern.
Phil Mcguinness
Best new restaurant in town! I had the Rack of Lamb and it was amazing!!! Staff is amazing. Drinks are great. Fun atmosphere . Great tv’s with a couch and chair area for games. Owners are the kindest people you will ever meet! Wednesday is prime rib night- unbelievable !!!! See you there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patricia C.
last night the prime rib was delicious! the Sunday brunch is the best in town. Great drinks too
Howard B.
I have been to this restaurant a few times since it opened and had a good experience every time. As I write this review they have 1 review and a 2 star rating. That had not been my experience. Mine had been a 4 star experience on at least 3 visits. I am rating them a 5 to help their average. I have had the burger, salmon and steak as entrees and all were tasty and well prepared. I have ordered the hummus platter every visit and it is great. There is a very good selection of wine beer and cocktails. I like the house Malbec. Please see the pic I posted of the menu. The decor and ambiance is nice and is well done. The bar area is spacious and the seating is plentiful. So is the outdoor seating area in good weather. My service has been exceptional on every visit. I would be happy to come back here any time ...and will. If I had one ding it would be to have a few better vegan options. I am not a vegan but dine with them and like to eat this way sometimes. A vegan protein for salads would be an easy add. So would an entree or too. Fried tofu, some local squash, maybe skip the feta on the hummus plate, ... and I hear quinoa is popular with the vegan set. Anyway, really like this place overall. Very pleased to have it in this part of Plymouth. Not sure what happened with other reviewer. Every time I am in there are plenty of happy diners. Two thumbs up.
Ginger Lawrence
First timers. Everything about the tavern was first class. Fabulous menu. It was very difficult to choose I had Fruit de Mare. It was excellent. The best I’ve had in a long time. My husband had the kale soup…he said “ better than mine”. He also wanted to pick, so he ordered the charcuterie board. Amazing!! Service was spot on. Our waitress, Nicole, was so sweet and accommodating. We actually are heading back there tomorrow night for their prime rib special.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Charcuterie Board, Carrot Cake, Soup of the Day
Great food and great service. Will definitely return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Short Rib Poutine, Bolognese
Love this place! Good vibes here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food quality is very good, try the mussels, Service is consistent and above what most people expect and ambiance is upscale & friendly.
Food is good, service is good, ambiance is great! I think it's a solid 4 - the building is fairly new and the design is a very nice tavern. We enjoyed the Thursday night special the last time we went - a nice bottle of wine, an appetizer and 2 entrees for $75.
Black lantern is one of my favorite spots!! Food is always consistently amazing as well as the service!! Joey is the best and always has a smile on his face! Couldn't recommend more!
I really don't understand the 5 star reviews. The restaurant itself is beautiful and it has a great ambiance and the service is good but the actual food is mediocre at best. I've eaten here a dozen or so times since moving to Redbrook and I've yet to get a really good meal. Extremely overcooked burgers, short ribs that are tough as nails, flavorless seafood, meatballs and steak tips. I think I've tried most of the menu hoping it gets better but it never does. I've repeatedly left disappointed. I'll definitely keep coming here for a few glasses of wine because it's so close but I don't think I'll be ordering the food anymore.
This is a very nice place to eat in the food is really
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari, Carrot Cake
Food was good, $20 prime rib special. Really enjoyed the music of the Darling Duo and hope to see them here again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Very nice place. Guitar singer was wonderful. Leg tater tots were excellent ?. Steak and cheese rolls were the same as everywhere. Thinking about sneaking in for a dinner soon. S little pricy. Needs more parking spaces! And outside night lights.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
So I was looking for something new in the area and read some reviews on this place and decided to give it a try. We were a little early for dinner so decided to get an appetizer and some salads before the dinner menu was offered. We ordered the tater tot kegs with bacon cheddar and chives, they were very tasty with a nice crispy outside and a really pillowy inside. None of the components overpowered the other which made them that much better. The salads were very fresh and the dressings were great. When the mains came out I was pleasantly surprised at how fresh and hot everything was, my steak was cooked to perfection and the potatoes wedges were a very nice touch instead of the same old mashed potatoes. The green beans were not overcooked and had a nice garlic taste too them as well. My wife's meal was nicely prepared and the mushroom sauce was excellent and the braised short ribs were very flavorful and very tender, and the onion rings were excellent as well. I can't wait to return and try the other items on the menu!
Restaurantji Recommends
Truly one of our favorite places. Food is outstanding, atmosphere is absolutely beautiful and service is friendly and quick. So glad this place is top notch and only 2 mi from where we live in Wareham. Favorite date nights for myself and hubby is at the Black lantern.
Best new restaurant in town! I had the Rack of Lamb and it was amazing!!! Staff is amazing. Drinks are great. Fun atmosphere . Great tv’s with a couch and chair area for games. Owners are the kindest people you will ever meet! Wednesday is prime rib night- unbelievable !!!! See you there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
last night the prime rib was delicious! the Sunday brunch is the best in town. Great drinks too
I have been to this restaurant a few times since it opened and had a good experience every time. As I write this review they have 1 review and a 2 star rating. That had not been my experience. Mine had been a 4 star experience on at least 3 visits. I am rating them a 5 to help their average. I have had the burger, salmon and steak as entrees and all were tasty and well prepared. I have ordered the hummus platter every visit and it is great. There is a very good selection of wine beer and cocktails. I like the house Malbec. Please see the pic I posted of the menu. The decor and ambiance is nice and is well done. The bar area is spacious and the seating is plentiful. So is the outdoor seating area in good weather. My service has been exceptional on every visit. I would be happy to come back here any time ...and will. If I had one ding it would be to have a few better vegan options. I am not a vegan but dine with them and like to eat this way sometimes. A vegan protein for salads would be an easy add. So would an entree or too. Fried tofu, some local squash, maybe skip the feta on the hummus plate, ... and I hear quinoa is popular with the vegan set. Anyway, really like this place overall. Very pleased to have it in this part of Plymouth. Not sure what happened with other reviewer. Every time I am in there are plenty of happy diners. Two thumbs up.
First timers. Everything about the tavern was first class. Fabulous menu. It was very difficult to choose I had Fruit de Mare. It was excellent. The best I’ve had in a long time. My husband had the kale soup…he said “ better than mine”. He also wanted to pick, so he ordered the charcuterie board. Amazing!! Service was spot on. Our waitress, Nicole, was so sweet and accommodating. We actually are heading back there tomorrow night for their prime rib special.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Charcuterie Board, Carrot Cake, Soup of the Day