Mayflower Tavern

2240 State Rd Suite 6-7, Plymouth
(508) 888-0041

Recent Reviews

Gary Caldwell

On December 8 we arrived mid afternoon only to find a sign on the door saying closed from now til the first week in January. This despite all info here to the contrary.

Alicia Kearney (A.K.Explorah)

Cute little spot in Cedarville for a good quick meal.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Kendra Noonan

Starting with a welcome at the door, friendly helpful staff and great server. Then the food! Absolutely delicious! This will be my new go to place! The Mac and cheese and Chicken cordon bleu are both amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Don Cline

Great place to watch a game. Great beer selection.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Cheryl

All good! Prices reasonable & great food &

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Shepherd

Nancy Abrams

First time here, loved it. Great atmosphere, cute sit up, doesn’t look like much from the outside, in a little strip mall. Food was really good, we had fried pork egg rolls for an appetizer, so good, and the dipping sauce it came with was wonderful. I had lasagna that came with a piece of garlic bread , very good, meaty and cheesy, husband had seafood stuffed cod, was a nice piece of cod ontop of stuffing on top of mashed potatoes , stuffing had small shrimps i it, he really enjoyed it but felt that it would be better with the stuffing on top and broiled a bit to make the stuffing crusty, it kind of mushed in with the mashed potatoes. Drinks were very good, huge drink menu!!! Waitstaff was really nice and friendly. Bathrooms clean and well decorated, lots of cute signs . We really enjoyed it and will be back when we are in the area. $107.00 which included 4 mixed drinks. Pretty inexpensive these days.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tamika Potts

Nice service, but the chimchurri chicken was too dry, some parts were over cooked, some parts were undercooked, and it was missing the chimchurri sauce. I hate being wasteful, but unfortunately it wasn’t edible.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Katie Mahoney

Food was absolutely horrible. Took an hour and 10 minutes after ordering to get our food and the restaurant was empty. The food was huge portions of mediocre food at best. Would never go back.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dorothy Buckley

I ordered steak tips medium. The plate came to me with a cheap piece of steak cut into cubes and it was done very well. They were not steak tips and I was charged 25.00. My husband got the country fried chicken and he enjoyed it. I also had a cup of chowder and it was nondescript. My husband got a Ceaser salad he said it was fine. There was only a hand full of patrons at the restaurant at 7:00pm on a Friday night. I don’t think the restaurant will survive the winter and that’s unfortunate.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5

Katie M

Food was absolutely horrible. Took an hour and 10 minutes after ordering to get our food and the restaurant was empty. The food was huge portions of mediocre food at best. Would never go back.

Stephen Puopolo

Menu seems a bit limited. Would love more of a salad selection. Pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Shepherd

Jay

After a round of golf at Atlantic, excellent place for a meal! Food was superior, service fantastic!

janet mercier

Great atmosphere and amazing staff! The food was delicious, definitely coming back!

Eve C

The service and hospitality was very nice. Felt very welcome. Coming from New Jersey. The food was amazing but the service was impeccable. Thank you!

Clay Walsh

Phenomenal food, but most notably is the redesigned interior. Owner Juston should be an interior designer because he has created these little nook seating areas that make what can be a loud restaurant into a very quiet, and private feeling mini dining room. If you haven’t checked it out yet since it’s changed ownership, give it a try. World of difference

Load More