I ordered a cake for my sister's 60th Birthday.The cake Judy made was so beautiful and it was delicious.Everyone complimented how beautiful and delicious the cake was. Highly recommend Piece of cake..Maureen Downes
Scott K.
Thes best cake place on the east coast. A must stop place if you are visiting Plymouth or passing through. Service is top notch! The ambiance is perfect for the cosy town of Plymouth. The owner Judy is a very special person.
Janis M.
Judy and her team are amazing women who make delicious and beautiful cake creations. Share an idea and they fly with it and help you achieve your plan. I am a happy customer for 7 years. One taste and you will be too.
Paige Marino
Judy and team could not be more amazing to work with during our wedding! Judy is a delight and her cakes are beyond delicious. We opted to do cupcakes for guests and a cutting cake for ourselves because her flavors were so incredible that we couldn't choose!We had many guests with dietary restrictions and Judy was able to make delicious gluten-free and vegan cupcakes. Our guests are still commenting on how much they loved the desserts- we can't recommend Judy highly enough!Judy has new life-long customers in us! We are so grateful that she was part of our big day. If you're looking for a perfectly sweet addition to your wedding, look no further!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Angela & Thomas Costello
Judy made our beach-themed wedding cake, and it turned out beautifully. She was able to match the icing color to our bridesmaids' dresses, and was diligent in executing our vision. We chose a different cake flavor for each tier, and all of them were a slam dunk! Overall, her cake excelled in flavor and presentation. What more could you ask for?
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Kelli Logan
I was in need of cupcakes for a little function I was doing on short notice. The cupcakes were flavorful and moist. The frosting was not too sweet like some places. The prices were reasonable which is hard to find. Will definitely go back for my next function. Thank you so much!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexis Alexander
We stumbled upon Piece of Cake when we were in town on my husband’s birthday and needed last minute cupcakes to celebrate! The cupcakes were so good, we ended up placing an order of 30 cupcakes for our rehearsal dinner 2 weeks later as well! We live in Pittsburgh, but if we lived in Plymouth or the surrounding areas I would be using Piece of Cake for every single cake need that I have!!! Highly recommended.
I Am (JustSomeGuy)
Cupcakes were absolutely delicious. The cookies and creme were perfect. Will definitely be getting more soon.
Heidi Hunter
Excellent gluten free cupcakes. Very friendly and accommodating.
Christine C.
The best! Had a very special occasion. Our cake was beautifully decorated, and all of our guests commented on how delicious it was. Staff was knowledgeable and kind.
The bad reviews definitely have ulterior motives because Judy’s cakes taste like heaven and never fail to be worth every penny! Keep doing awesome guys!
carol stocker
Cake was dry and very disappointing also pretty expensive. Decorations were alright but not worth the price
tina reed
We ordered this cake from Judy for my parents’ anniversary. It came out beautiful and fed our crew of 60 with some to spare. Judy was great to work with and I would recommend her and will use her again!
Lynne B.
A cake and several dozen cupcakes were ordered from here for my graduation party and they were awful. Flavorless and dry. The cake was also not the same design that was ordered but the biggest problem here was that the cupcakes were inedible. Not one person enjoyed them. Do not recommend.
Barbara A. Mack
OMG. I want to give a shout out to “Piece Of Cake” in Plymouth. They made the most delectable birthday cake for my hubby’s 75th Birthday this past Sunday. The decorations were incredible! Not only was the cake beautiful but it tasted fantastic...top half yellow, bottom chocolate with a raspberry filling. Everyone raved about the cake. Thank you “Piece Of Cake”. You made my husband’s birthday extra special!
I ordered a cake for my sister's 60th Birthday.The cake Judy made was so beautiful and it was delicious.Everyone complimented how beautiful and delicious the cake was. Highly recommend Piece of cake..Maureen Downes
Thes best cake place on the east coast. A must stop place if you are visiting Plymouth or passing through. Service is top notch! The ambiance is perfect for the cosy town of Plymouth. The owner Judy is a very special person.
Judy and her team are amazing women who make delicious and beautiful cake creations. Share an idea and they fly with it and help you achieve your plan. I am a happy customer for 7 years. One taste and you will be too.
Judy and team could not be more amazing to work with during our wedding! Judy is a delight and her cakes are beyond delicious. We opted to do cupcakes for guests and a cutting cake for ourselves because her flavors were so incredible that we couldn't choose!We had many guests with dietary restrictions and Judy was able to make delicious gluten-free and vegan cupcakes. Our guests are still commenting on how much they loved the desserts- we can't recommend Judy highly enough!Judy has new life-long customers in us! We are so grateful that she was part of our big day. If you're looking for a perfectly sweet addition to your wedding, look no further!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Judy made our beach-themed wedding cake, and it turned out beautifully. She was able to match the icing color to our bridesmaids' dresses, and was diligent in executing our vision. We chose a different cake flavor for each tier, and all of them were a slam dunk! Overall, her cake excelled in flavor and presentation. What more could you ask for?
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
I was in need of cupcakes for a little function I was doing on short notice. The cupcakes were flavorful and moist. The frosting was not too sweet like some places. The prices were reasonable which is hard to find. Will definitely go back for my next function. Thank you so much!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We stumbled upon Piece of Cake when we were in town on my husband’s birthday and needed last minute cupcakes to celebrate! The cupcakes were so good, we ended up placing an order of 30 cupcakes for our rehearsal dinner 2 weeks later as well! We live in Pittsburgh, but if we lived in Plymouth or the surrounding areas I would be using Piece of Cake for every single cake need that I have!!! Highly recommended.
Cupcakes were absolutely delicious. The cookies and creme were perfect. Will definitely be getting more soon.
Excellent gluten free cupcakes. Very friendly and accommodating.
The best! Had a very special occasion. Our cake was beautifully decorated, and all of our guests commented on how delicious it was. Staff was knowledgeable and kind.
Restaurantji Recommends
The bad reviews definitely have ulterior motives because Judy’s cakes taste like heaven and never fail to be worth every penny! Keep doing awesome guys!
Cake was dry and very disappointing also pretty expensive. Decorations were alright but not worth the price
We ordered this cake from Judy for my parents’ anniversary. It came out beautiful and fed our crew of 60 with some to spare. Judy was great to work with and I would recommend her and will use her again!
A cake and several dozen cupcakes were ordered from here for my graduation party and they were awful. Flavorless and dry. The cake was also not the same design that was ordered but the biggest problem here was that the cupcakes were inedible. Not one person enjoyed them. Do not recommend.
OMG. I want to give a shout out to “Piece Of Cake” in Plymouth. They made the most delectable birthday cake for my hubby’s 75th Birthday this past Sunday. The decorations were incredible! Not only was the cake beautiful but it tasted fantastic...top half yellow, bottom chocolate with a raspberry filling. Everyone raved about the cake. Thank you “Piece Of Cake”. You made my husband’s birthday extra special!