Love this place , friendly cute staff , good fudge
Jakob C.
Alright idk where these good reviews are coming from. We stopped in here because the line for Mad Martha's was out the door. Walked over to Murdick's and saw that it was completely empty- should've taken that as a hint.We got two ice creams- the Moose tracks and peppermint. I swear that's the exact same moose tracks that they have at Aldi. It legit tastes exactly the same down to the quality of the PB cups. AND it was horribly freezer burn. Almost to the point of it being inedible. I ate what ice cream was on the top of the cup and was just scraping at ice chunks after that. Peppermint was also freezer burn but not as bad. Overall just a disappointing experience. I haven't had ice cream that bad in a while.
J D.
Fudge was hard and dry do not recommend. Ice cream was pretty good though... only reason not 1 star. They also only sell the fudge by whole big slice which is really annoying.
Bridanya E.
I can't think of any better combination in the world than Martha's Vineyard and Murdick's Fudge! It instantly makes me reminisce and wish I was lucky enough to live on the island forever
Bea Chukwulozie
They don’t cater to allergies, if you are allergic to something in one ice cream you can’t have any.
Erica Valery
We went to get ice cream on 7/30 night and the staff was so rude that we ended up leaving and going to get ice cream down the street. When we got to the next ice cream store, there was a group of people also talking about how rude the staff was at Murdicks which is why they also left to get ice cream elsewhere. I feel bad for the owner of the shop. They lost out on a lot of business because of rude staff.
Ryan M.
3 simple words: BEST FUDGE EVER! If you're in vineyard Haven any time soon this is a must go you will not regret it! But that's not the only thing! The costumer service is amazing! And they have so many different flavors it might take you half an hour to pick one out. I love this place
Connor Printz
Very disappointing. Got 2 scoops of ice cream and each scoop was literally the size of a golf ball, no exaggeration finished the cone in 2-3 bites. Ice cream was very soft and almost melted when I received it. Would never spend my money on the ice cream again.
Daniel R.
Tried the cashew peanut brittle and an assortment of fudge. Peanut brittle was similar to hard toffee. The taste has good, but it's consistency would be good for pulling out your molars. The fudge had a disappointing consistency, it was a bit more dry and chalky then the creamy fudge I was expecting. This was before the rush of the summer season so may have had an older batch
TasteofMassachusetts
Visited and watched them make their cranberry fudge, the smell was amazing and it was a super fun treat to watch.
I stopped in here while visiting Martha's Vineyard for the day to grab some ice cream. They had a lot of flavors We ended up getting the muddy boots, vanilla ice cream with brownie and caramel, in a cup. It came to $5 which I found pretty expensive. The person inside was friendly and the store was clean. I'd recommend stopping in for a snack.
656oceanp
Cool place, my kids love to watch them make the fudge right in front of you. The fudge is great, many options, I Highly recommend.
Dan Krych
great coconut ice cream
Sammi
I stopped in here while visiting Martha's Vineyard for the day to grab some ice cream. They had a lot of flavors (as well as a big assortment of fudge) and it was so hard to choose! We ended up getting the muddy boots, vanilla ice cream with brownie and caramel, in a cup. It came to $5 which I found pretty expensive, but I know we're in a tourist location as well as an island so it was understandable. The person inside was friendly and the store was clean. I'd recommend stopping in if you'd like a nice snack!
Aidan Ziegenhorn
Amazing fudge, amazing ice cream. The fudge is great for gifts and is made on the island. As an islander I can say its definately good.
Love this place , friendly cute staff , good fudge
Alright idk where these good reviews are coming from. We stopped in here because the line for Mad Martha's was out the door. Walked over to Murdick's and saw that it was completely empty- should've taken that as a hint.We got two ice creams- the Moose tracks and peppermint. I swear that's the exact same moose tracks that they have at Aldi. It legit tastes exactly the same down to the quality of the PB cups. AND it was horribly freezer burn. Almost to the point of it being inedible. I ate what ice cream was on the top of the cup and was just scraping at ice chunks after that. Peppermint was also freezer burn but not as bad. Overall just a disappointing experience. I haven't had ice cream that bad in a while.
Fudge was hard and dry do not recommend. Ice cream was pretty good though... only reason not 1 star. They also only sell the fudge by whole big slice which is really annoying.
I can't think of any better combination in the world than Martha's Vineyard and Murdick's Fudge! It instantly makes me reminisce and wish I was lucky enough to live on the island forever
They don’t cater to allergies, if you are allergic to something in one ice cream you can’t have any.
We went to get ice cream on 7/30 night and the staff was so rude that we ended up leaving and going to get ice cream down the street. When we got to the next ice cream store, there was a group of people also talking about how rude the staff was at Murdicks which is why they also left to get ice cream elsewhere. I feel bad for the owner of the shop. They lost out on a lot of business because of rude staff.
3 simple words: BEST FUDGE EVER! If you're in vineyard Haven any time soon this is a must go you will not regret it! But that's not the only thing! The costumer service is amazing! And they have so many different flavors it might take you half an hour to pick one out. I love this place
Very disappointing. Got 2 scoops of ice cream and each scoop was literally the size of a golf ball, no exaggeration finished the cone in 2-3 bites. Ice cream was very soft and almost melted when I received it. Would never spend my money on the ice cream again.
Tried the cashew peanut brittle and an assortment of fudge. Peanut brittle was similar to hard toffee. The taste has good, but it's consistency would be good for pulling out your molars. The fudge had a disappointing consistency, it was a bit more dry and chalky then the creamy fudge I was expecting. This was before the rush of the summer season so may have had an older batch
Visited and watched them make their cranberry fudge, the smell was amazing and it was a super fun treat to watch.
Restaurantji Recommends
I stopped in here while visiting Martha's Vineyard for the day to grab some ice cream. They had a lot of flavors We ended up getting the muddy boots, vanilla ice cream with brownie and caramel, in a cup. It came to $5 which I found pretty expensive. The person inside was friendly and the store was clean. I'd recommend stopping in for a snack.
Cool place, my kids love to watch them make the fudge right in front of you. The fudge is great, many options, I Highly recommend.
great coconut ice cream
I stopped in here while visiting Martha's Vineyard for the day to grab some ice cream. They had a lot of flavors (as well as a big assortment of fudge) and it was so hard to choose! We ended up getting the muddy boots, vanilla ice cream with brownie and caramel, in a cup. It came to $5 which I found pretty expensive, but I know we're in a tourist location as well as an island so it was understandable. The person inside was friendly and the store was clean. I'd recommend stopping in if you'd like a nice snack!
Amazing fudge, amazing ice cream. The fudge is great for gifts and is made on the island. As an islander I can say its definately good.