The food there has been poorly put together. Instructions are never followed. Dont let this place fool you. Won't be ordering here again. To many run-ins with my food being incorrect along with the presentation being off.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Italian, Steak & Cheese
Sheena
I ordered from this place. My food arrived in minutes not cooked properly. Presentation was horrible. I called them to alert them manager was very nonchalant.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
myob
Tried Supreme for the first time ever after seeing it a few times driving by. I was immediately greeted by 2 ladies with smiles on their faces (already +10 points). I got a large cheese pizza and a steak and cheese sub (always a hit or miss). The pizza was genuinely one of the best I’ve ever had in the entire state and I’m a pizza eater. The sub was cooked perfectly and had so much flavor. I will definitely be coming back to try more items in the future. A must visit if you’re in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Derrick Pallis
I’m pleased to see a recent ownership change and the new owners couldn’t be more welcoming, providing a wonderful experience and some very delicious food! I went with a steak n cheese sub and pizza and can’t wait for my next stop at Supreme Pizza! Thanks guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ann L.
This place was way better (which is saying something) with the old owners. The new owners couldn't care less about their customers. We order there at least twice a month, specifically because they have a gluten-free pizza option that tastes good. We'd spend at least $50 every time we went-a decent amount at a pizza shop. Previously they followed universal precautions for allergens -cooked it in a separate tin pan, put it in the box to cut it with a special gluten free cutter that was stored safely away. So this time I go in to pick up my order. My regular pizza is ready. They take out the gluten free and take it out of the tin and put it directly into the box; the boxes sit on the shelves prefolded so can gather flour particles. I mentioned that it seemed that it was not in the pan, and asked if it was cut with the gluten-free cutter. They said it was fine, right into the box and with the cutter. When I walked out of the store it was observable through the windows they were talking about me, just because I asked a question about my son having an allergy. I had been polite. I just got in the car and drove home. I called and my son who has celiac and asked him if it's always served in the pan, and he said it is. I called Supreme back and mentioned that I had just been in the store and spoke with my son and he said it is always in the pan. The guy who answered the phone doubled down and somewhat aggressively asked me if I wanted to speak to the cook because he watched him prepare it. I mentioned the difference of the pan, and that the reason we go there is that they always follow the same precautions. Then he said that they were busy that night (there was no one in the place) and THAT was why he took it out of the pan. He guaranteed that the next time we went in that it would be prepared correctly. Well, when you have an allergy, there is no next time. Indeed, my son did get glutened and has been up vomiting with diarrhea most of the night. The concept of the customer being right, or perhaps someone with medical concerns being taken seriously is not the case at Supreme. He could have offered to make another pie. Not even in his wheelhouse. They're right. They're always right. There will be no next time. I advise you if you have celiac or a gluten allergy to not go to Supreme. I can suggest better places in town that have great reputations for all kinds of pizza shop food! We'll try Family Pizzeria or Biancos for gluten-free and let you know. Jimmy's might not have gluten free, but they're super nice there!
Laurie Espitia
This is a go to for their chicken wings, pizza is mediocre based on other places I have had. People are pretty nice there.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Jared M W
Pretty impressed with pizza. Good salty cheese and a dry crispy crust. I’ll be back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Bart Rys
Ordered from here as everything else was closing at 9, probably the worst buff chicken pizza I ever has. Dough is dry cardboard, chicken dry as hell, blue cheese barely existent. I should have ended the night slightly hungry because that was horrendously disappointing. Definitely never ordering from here again. Despite paying almost 30 bucks for a pizza after fees and delivery, threw the second half of this in the trash. ??
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Rebecca Ryan
Amazing food!!!! And delivery service!!! I ordered the Greek calzone and it is literally the best calzone I've ever had! My boyfriend got the chicken bacon wrap and it was beautifully stuffed! Very happy customers? ?
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gary S.
ordered two steak and cheese subs. If you want a salt and steak sub with no cheese, very little steak and not the way you ordered it. order here. called to find out why and they hung up on us. Won't use them ever again. 2 subs both wrong. nice job.
I live relatively close by, but have never stopped in before tonight. How to slice of cheese pizza while I waited for my steak and cheese. The slice was very good with plenty of cheese and an amazing crust. Very different that most other pizza shops of this kind. Cheese steak was delicious too. Will be back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jackie E.
If you haven't tried them yet, you absolutely need to. The handful of times we've been there it has always been delicious. And tonight, as I picked up my pizza after a hellish car ride with my toddler, they could not have been kinder. They offered my toddler some fresh-baked cookies (and then gave them to her on the house when I mentioned I left my wallet in my car ) and then, without missing a beat walked my order out to my car and put it in the front seat for me. I am 8 months pregnant and I cannot even tell you how this small gesture meant the world. The genuine kindness from the staff is unmatched not to mention their food is top tier. If you value postive customer service.. do not hesitate to check out Supreme!!
Kate Herbert
Disappointed. I ordered chicken parmigiana pasta and a side salad. I wasn’t sure they delivered to my address, so after checking out the menu and prices, I was surprised when I was told $29 for $20 worth of food, but I decided it wasn’t a big deal.The salad was 100% iceberg chunks with a couple of old tomato slices- not a tomato I would eat.The chicken parm was a huge dish of spaghetti with almost no sauce, and chunks of heavily breaded chicken that had a very oniony flavor, not a pleasant taste at all. I have never seen chicken Parm served in this manner, where they appear to have pre-cut the chicken for me. It was not even worth eating, which was a shame, because there was an enormous amount of food.Perhaps, if they spent more money on quality ingredients and reduced the serving size, it might have been edible, but unfortunately, this is making its way to the trash. What a waste of $30 + tip.The worst part was the fact that they included garlic bread that was so incredibly stale I couldn’t eat it if I wanted to.I feel very bad writing this review, because the woman who delivered it it was on time, and was very friendly and professional. I just can’t get past the quality or lack there of, though, so I’m sorry to say that I will not be returning.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Chris Grogan
I NEVER a leave bad reviews…..but this time yes!! Got a ham sub from here…..sad…..there shouldn’t be more veggies on a sandwich than meat! Four slices of ham and six slices of tomato! Put some meat on the sandwich maybe when charging $12 for sandwich!!! A very disappointing sandwich will NOT return!!!
The food there has been poorly put together. Instructions are never followed. Dont let this place fool you. Won't be ordering here again. To many run-ins with my food being incorrect along with the presentation being off.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Italian, Steak & Cheese
I ordered from this place. My food arrived in minutes not cooked properly. Presentation was horrible. I called them to alert them manager was very nonchalant.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tried Supreme for the first time ever after seeing it a few times driving by. I was immediately greeted by 2 ladies with smiles on their faces (already +10 points). I got a large cheese pizza and a steak and cheese sub (always a hit or miss). The pizza was genuinely one of the best I’ve ever had in the entire state and I’m a pizza eater. The sub was cooked perfectly and had so much flavor. I will definitely be coming back to try more items in the future. A must visit if you’re in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’m pleased to see a recent ownership change and the new owners couldn’t be more welcoming, providing a wonderful experience and some very delicious food! I went with a steak n cheese sub and pizza and can’t wait for my next stop at Supreme Pizza! Thanks guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place was way better (which is saying something) with the old owners. The new owners couldn't care less about their customers. We order there at least twice a month, specifically because they have a gluten-free pizza option that tastes good. We'd spend at least $50 every time we went-a decent amount at a pizza shop. Previously they followed universal precautions for allergens -cooked it in a separate tin pan, put it in the box to cut it with a special gluten free cutter that was stored safely away. So this time I go in to pick up my order. My regular pizza is ready. They take out the gluten free and take it out of the tin and put it directly into the box; the boxes sit on the shelves prefolded so can gather flour particles. I mentioned that it seemed that it was not in the pan, and asked if it was cut with the gluten-free cutter. They said it was fine, right into the box and with the cutter. When I walked out of the store it was observable through the windows they were talking about me, just because I asked a question about my son having an allergy. I had been polite. I just got in the car and drove home. I called and my son who has celiac and asked him if it's always served in the pan, and he said it is. I called Supreme back and mentioned that I had just been in the store and spoke with my son and he said it is always in the pan. The guy who answered the phone doubled down and somewhat aggressively asked me if I wanted to speak to the cook because he watched him prepare it. I mentioned the difference of the pan, and that the reason we go there is that they always follow the same precautions. Then he said that they were busy that night (there was no one in the place) and THAT was why he took it out of the pan. He guaranteed that the next time we went in that it would be prepared correctly. Well, when you have an allergy, there is no next time. Indeed, my son did get glutened and has been up vomiting with diarrhea most of the night. The concept of the customer being right, or perhaps someone with medical concerns being taken seriously is not the case at Supreme. He could have offered to make another pie. Not even in his wheelhouse. They're right. They're always right. There will be no next time. I advise you if you have celiac or a gluten allergy to not go to Supreme. I can suggest better places in town that have great reputations for all kinds of pizza shop food! We'll try Family Pizzeria or Biancos for gluten-free and let you know. Jimmy's might not have gluten free, but they're super nice there!
This is a go to for their chicken wings, pizza is mediocre based on other places I have had. People are pretty nice there.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Pretty impressed with pizza. Good salty cheese and a dry crispy crust. I’ll be back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Ordered from here as everything else was closing at 9, probably the worst buff chicken pizza I ever has. Dough is dry cardboard, chicken dry as hell, blue cheese barely existent. I should have ended the night slightly hungry because that was horrendously disappointing. Definitely never ordering from here again. Despite paying almost 30 bucks for a pizza after fees and delivery, threw the second half of this in the trash. ??
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Amazing food!!!! And delivery service!!! I ordered the Greek calzone and it is literally the best calzone I've ever had! My boyfriend got the chicken bacon wrap and it was beautifully stuffed! Very happy customers? ?
Food: 5
Service: 5
ordered two steak and cheese subs. If you want a salt and steak sub with no cheese, very little steak and not the way you ordered it. order here. called to find out why and they hung up on us. Won't use them ever again. 2 subs both wrong. nice job.
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious food and loved the homemade cookies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I live relatively close by, but have never stopped in before tonight. How to slice of cheese pizza while I waited for my steak and cheese. The slice was very good with plenty of cheese and an amazing crust. Very different that most other pizza shops of this kind. Cheese steak was delicious too. Will be back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you haven't tried them yet, you absolutely need to. The handful of times we've been there it has always been delicious. And tonight, as I picked up my pizza after a hellish car ride with my toddler, they could not have been kinder. They offered my toddler some fresh-baked cookies (and then gave them to her on the house when I mentioned I left my wallet in my car ) and then, without missing a beat walked my order out to my car and put it in the front seat for me. I am 8 months pregnant and I cannot even tell you how this small gesture meant the world. The genuine kindness from the staff is unmatched not to mention their food is top tier. If you value postive customer service.. do not hesitate to check out Supreme!!
Disappointed. I ordered chicken parmigiana pasta and a side salad. I wasn’t sure they delivered to my address, so after checking out the menu and prices, I was surprised when I was told $29 for $20 worth of food, but I decided it wasn’t a big deal.The salad was 100% iceberg chunks with a couple of old tomato slices- not a tomato I would eat.The chicken parm was a huge dish of spaghetti with almost no sauce, and chunks of heavily breaded chicken that had a very oniony flavor, not a pleasant taste at all. I have never seen chicken Parm served in this manner, where they appear to have pre-cut the chicken for me. It was not even worth eating, which was a shame, because there was an enormous amount of food.Perhaps, if they spent more money on quality ingredients and reduced the serving size, it might have been edible, but unfortunately, this is making its way to the trash. What a waste of $30 + tip.The worst part was the fact that they included garlic bread that was so incredibly stale I couldn’t eat it if I wanted to.I feel very bad writing this review, because the woman who delivered it it was on time, and was very friendly and professional. I just can’t get past the quality or lack there of, though, so I’m sorry to say that I will not be returning.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
I NEVER a leave bad reviews…..but this time yes!! Got a ham sub from here…..sad…..there shouldn’t be more veggies on a sandwich than meat! Four slices of ham and six slices of tomato! Put some meat on the sandwich maybe when charging $12 for sandwich!!! A very disappointing sandwich will NOT return!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5