Great spot been coming here since I was a child. Closed for remodeling as of 10/25/23 see you guys
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bert Keith-Avril
It's a small family pizza place, but their slices are huge. They have great cake as well.Vegetarian options: They are happy to help you find a good vegetarian option.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Pearl Wirtanen
Great food and fast and friendly service.I believe it's family run, and they show pride in their service and great food.Parking: It's located near Shaws, which allows for ample parking. Parking, which is directly in front of the restaurant..I'm glad I found this place. Their food is extraordinary for a pizza place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Small Eggplant Parm Sub, Mozzarella Sticks
David Robinson
I ordered 2 slices of pizza twice and had the same issue with the slices and I had to explain to them that there's a difference between warm and hot, I like my slices hot so the cheese will pull off when I bite it. I went in and ordered 2 slices hot and they were hot but one of the slices looked like the cheese was dried out, I shouldn't have even took that slice but I was on the phone when it was brought to my table.I will never dine there nor order from this establishment again, some of the food that they prepare is terrible and I wouldn't feed it to a dog.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Kyle Dirksmeier
usually I don't write reviews but this time going to Athens pizza the hamburger must have been changed and it is disgusting , not sure why you would change something that has been working for over 10 years.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Danielle Hardin
We have been going to Athens for a very long time. Food service is always hit or miss. Today my husband ordered an Italian sub, everything on it and no onions. When I bit inside of it I was so confused. This sub only had one piece of salami with lettuce, some tomatoes, pickles, and banana peppers. We called to complain and the guy who answered the phone stated the only way we could see if we can get a refund is if we brought the sub back to the store. So not only are we inconvenienced once by not getting to eat but we need to be inconvenienced again by bringing our food to the store so they can throw it out and give us our money back. Fair to say this is our last time ordering from Athens again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Erin C.
Over priced for the quality. The pizza is just okay. What is driving the 1-star was the delivery experience and execution. I had food delivered to another local Weymouth business (about a mile away), provided the right address, and received a call from the delivery driver unable to find the location. Thinking they were in the area but couldn't find the actual location I asked for landmarks or street names. I'm not from the area myself. Turns out they were on the other side of town and from my conversation with the driver were not equipped with the right tools to find the location. I remained on the phone with the driver, looking at my phones GPS to provide him with what he needed. I told him I'd be putting in a call to his manager. It's absurd that in todays work where most of the population has immediate access to directions, that he couldn't or wouldn't do this for himself. I immediately called the location, asked to speak with a manager, was put on hold and told that they were not available and were making deliveries. I was not pleasant to the person on the other line due to high frustrations with having to explain why this was unacceptable and him, as not a manager, would not be able to help. I'm sorry to that person as I'm sure I was a big F-off customer for the day....but $50 (with tip) for 2 pizzas that were not in anyone's opinion "best of Weymouth" on top of having to provide tools and assistance to their employee was annoying as fuck. He took my number...which I had already provided for the order...and (no shock) am still waiting on a call back from the manager who is likely still out making deliveries. What's sad is how much referral business they lost out on that day. 6 additional groups saw our pizza boxes and asked where we got it. We immediately told them no...terrible service today and just ok pizza. They all ordered from elsewhere. For the future: please be transparent with your customers...if you can't deliver to another local business turn them away. If you can and are under staffed...be up front. If you don't have the tools to service the public...please invest in them AND provide other solutions. Best of luck.
Elizabeth M.
Ordered foe delat a local brewery. Took over an hour (early Sunday afternoon), and the driver called for directions and was over 5 miles away. The brewery is less than 1.5 mules away. Driver claimed no access to GPS and asked me to complain to the company. Had to give drivers directions over the phone. Called to speak with management and was told they were out making deliveries. 100% a joke. Pizza was meh.
william Rodriguez
Pizza was delicious, and the atmosphere was a friendly, family type. I will definitely be returning whenever I'm in boston again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 2 Large 2-Topping Pizzas
Justin Shaffer
Honestly just tastes highly processed, from the chicken to the cheese it feels off. It’s rare to find places that use fresh ingredients and sadly this is one if then.
A lot of time wasted for those who order online. I ordered online and picked it up 30 minutes later. the guy said it would have to wait. Then everyone who ordered at the counter was ready except the one I had ordered before everyone else. They are antipasti unfriendly and without respect for
Black World
Food ok but I noticed a bearded gentleman and an older lady preparing doe in the back with out gloves! Do I need to explain how nasty and unsanitary that is? Definitely not ordering from that place again
Elizabeth McDermott
I had a small piza last Thursday it was awful it was thick doughy and under cooked!
Mark O'Neill
Buffalo fingers had little to no Buffalo sauce. Coleslaw was a cup of mayo. Fries were definitely not fresh. Way over priced
Hamza Q
Don’t know how the place has good reviews. Food is nothing special. I order a chicken parm sub and eggplant parm sub. Both were on the dry side even though extra sauce was requested. In the end I won’t return here. Eggplant sub photos added for reference.
Great spot been coming here since I was a child. Closed for remodeling as of 10/25/23 see you guys
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's a small family pizza place, but their slices are huge. They have great cake as well.Vegetarian options: They are happy to help you find a good vegetarian option.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great food and fast and friendly service.I believe it's family run, and they show pride in their service and great food.Parking: It's located near Shaws, which allows for ample parking. Parking, which is directly in front of the restaurant..I'm glad I found this place. Their food is extraordinary for a pizza place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Small Eggplant Parm Sub, Mozzarella Sticks
I ordered 2 slices of pizza twice and had the same issue with the slices and I had to explain to them that there's a difference between warm and hot, I like my slices hot so the cheese will pull off when I bite it. I went in and ordered 2 slices hot and they were hot but one of the slices looked like the cheese was dried out, I shouldn't have even took that slice but I was on the phone when it was brought to my table.I will never dine there nor order from this establishment again, some of the food that they prepare is terrible and I wouldn't feed it to a dog.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
usually I don't write reviews but this time going to Athens pizza the hamburger must have been changed and it is disgusting , not sure why you would change something that has been working for over 10 years.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
We have been going to Athens for a very long time. Food service is always hit or miss. Today my husband ordered an Italian sub, everything on it and no onions. When I bit inside of it I was so confused. This sub only had one piece of salami with lettuce, some tomatoes, pickles, and banana peppers. We called to complain and the guy who answered the phone stated the only way we could see if we can get a refund is if we brought the sub back to the store. So not only are we inconvenienced once by not getting to eat but we need to be inconvenienced again by bringing our food to the store so they can throw it out and give us our money back. Fair to say this is our last time ordering from Athens again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Over priced for the quality. The pizza is just okay. What is driving the 1-star was the delivery experience and execution. I had food delivered to another local Weymouth business (about a mile away), provided the right address, and received a call from the delivery driver unable to find the location. Thinking they were in the area but couldn't find the actual location I asked for landmarks or street names. I'm not from the area myself. Turns out they were on the other side of town and from my conversation with the driver were not equipped with the right tools to find the location. I remained on the phone with the driver, looking at my phones GPS to provide him with what he needed. I told him I'd be putting in a call to his manager. It's absurd that in todays work where most of the population has immediate access to directions, that he couldn't or wouldn't do this for himself. I immediately called the location, asked to speak with a manager, was put on hold and told that they were not available and were making deliveries. I was not pleasant to the person on the other line due to high frustrations with having to explain why this was unacceptable and him, as not a manager, would not be able to help. I'm sorry to that person as I'm sure I was a big F-off customer for the day....but $50 (with tip) for 2 pizzas that were not in anyone's opinion "best of Weymouth" on top of having to provide tools and assistance to their employee was annoying as fuck. He took my number...which I had already provided for the order...and (no shock) am still waiting on a call back from the manager who is likely still out making deliveries. What's sad is how much referral business they lost out on that day. 6 additional groups saw our pizza boxes and asked where we got it. We immediately told them no...terrible service today and just ok pizza. They all ordered from elsewhere. For the future: please be transparent with your customers...if you can't deliver to another local business turn them away. If you can and are under staffed...be up front. If you don't have the tools to service the public...please invest in them AND provide other solutions. Best of luck.
Ordered foe delat a local brewery. Took over an hour (early Sunday afternoon), and the driver called for directions and was over 5 miles away. The brewery is less than 1.5 mules away. Driver claimed no access to GPS and asked me to complain to the company. Had to give drivers directions over the phone. Called to speak with management and was told they were out making deliveries. 100% a joke. Pizza was meh.
Pizza was delicious, and the atmosphere was a friendly, family type. I will definitely be returning whenever I'm in boston again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 2 Large 2-Topping Pizzas
Honestly just tastes highly processed, from the chicken to the cheese it feels off. It’s rare to find places that use fresh ingredients and sadly this is one if then.
Restaurantji Recommends
A lot of time wasted for those who order online. I ordered online and picked it up 30 minutes later. the guy said it would have to wait. Then everyone who ordered at the counter was ready except the one I had ordered before everyone else. They are antipasti unfriendly and without respect for
Food ok but I noticed a bearded gentleman and an older lady preparing doe in the back with out gloves! Do I need to explain how nasty and unsanitary that is? Definitely not ordering from that place again
I had a small piza last Thursday it was awful it was thick doughy and under cooked!
Buffalo fingers had little to no Buffalo sauce. Coleslaw was a cup of mayo. Fries were definitely not fresh. Way over priced
Don’t know how the place has good reviews. Food is nothing special. I order a chicken parm sub and eggplant parm sub. Both were on the dry side even though extra sauce was requested. In the end I won’t return here. Eggplant sub photos added for reference.