Lighthouse Keeper's Pantry

173 Main St, Yarmouth
(774) 994-8295

Recent Reviews

Conrad Watson

OMG. I had the best lunch there. Delicious salad and a decadent Treasure Chest Ice Cream Sandwich. Go here often. Great seating and nice people in the amazing North side.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Peter Smith

This is a great coffee shop and bakery. I highly recommend it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gee Goes To The Cape

Step into a little slice of heaven on Cape Cod with Lighthouse Keepers Pantry! With its sandwiches, flavorful, out of this world coffee, and laid-back atmosphere, this cafe is a true haven for relaxation. Don’t miss out on this unforgettable experience. It is a must-visit spot for everyone who’s on the cape, and worth a trip just for the coffee alone! Lighthouse Keepers is Gee Approved!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ariel Folkerts

Cute shop & cafe! Pastries and food are quite overpriced ($6.25 for a cinnamon roll). However, it’s all delicious. Local goods for sale are fun to browse. Very cozy seating area as well.Parking: Huge lot in the back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 3

Hollis Engley

High quality coffee and croissants, friendly staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Martin McAdam

A lovely sea salty spot. Excellent scones and breakfast sandwiches. Nice wee delicatessen and funky gifts. Lovely staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Break Fast Sandwiches

M T

Love everything about this place! Great food, exceptional atmosphere, and a fantastic variety of merchandise. A wonderful place to enjoy coffee and a treat!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Break Fast Sandwiches, Ice Cream Cake

Lauren P. Dodge

So excited to soon live down the road from Lighthouse Keeper’s, I couldn’t ask for a better local coffee joint ? Amazing service, such friendly people. Awesome dried goods and little gift options. Lovely interiors and outdoor seating.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Coffee Cake by the Slice Ham & Cheese Crossant, Lunch Sandwiches, Break Fast Sandwiches, Pumpkin Scone Scone, Clam Shell Fortunes

Andrew D

Fabulous little cafe. Great sandwiches and coffee. The chocolate chunk cookies are from heaven!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lunch Sandwiches

Lizeth G.

I love popping into lighthouse keepers. It's such a lovely store, with great decor and offerings. I like perusing their shelves for new ingredients or local artisan tools (I really want their knives!!). Most of the time it's for inspiration, but one day I'll be back to take it all home with me. What I always leave with are snacks and treats. I love their pecan rolls and will someone choose a rotating or special selection. They have lots of beverage selections, coffee and teas. I ordered their London fog once and really enjoyed it. I popped in for a breakfast sandwich once and highly recommend the pesto. If you're around in the summer, visit them in the evening for their ice cream. It's adorably sold out of a boat on their front lawn and is enormous. Be ready to share!

Csilla Lyerly

Yummy latte. Girls behind counter a bit rude! but cute shop …

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 2

Mon I.

Cute little coffee shop. The website is a little deceiving. The food is pre-prepared, even the breakfast sandwiches which are heated up very slowly in some type of warmer. The coffee was delicious and our daughter felt her almond milk hot chocolate was one of the best! (They could benefit from using a thermometer as it was so hot she couldn't hold the cup even with a sleeve for 15-20 minutes). The cape dory breakfast sandwich was full of flavor, you can never go wrong with pesto. The Ketch breakfast sandwich was alright, when you a highlight a breakfast sandwich with a jam (especially on a dense English muffin) it's always helpful to be able to taste it...we couldn't and that was disappointing. We felt the price of these sandwiches was high for their reheat on-the-go style and quality.The young person taking our order and making the drinks was friendly, knowledgeable and wonderful to interact with. However, the adult working alongside her didn't carry the same qualities. The creamer was empty and when we politely handed it to her to let her know (we paid for our coffee and wanted to be able to enjoy it how we like it) she was very inconvenienced and hesitant to take it. Looking between the canister and a box across the room. She shared that they just got it in with annoyance. After an awkward couple of minutes passed she pushed her way through and refilled it. As customers, this was awkward and uncomfortable.Overall, it was ok. We doubt we will be back, not due to avoidance, but due it not being memorable food or an extremely pleasant experience.

Rachel Chiang

Love that they’re open year round and consistent hours. The place brings the neighborhood together.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kirsten Meyer Zaryky

We came here several mornings during our vacation to get coffee to go. Everything tasted great and the overall atmosphere was very friendly and cozy. The line was long some days, but everyone was very pleasant and we just chalked it up to being a popular stop for good reason! The shop itself was very cute and we appreciated the selection of food/souvenir items for sale. There was ample parking behind the shop and a good amount of both indoor and outdoor seating.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Calín E.

By far one of the cutest coffee shops on cape cod! The staff is always friendly and if I was still in school the seating makes it a quaint place to study or hang out with friends. The beautiful and private couches and tables make it fun. I enjoy the charm of this place right when I walk in the front door. You walk into a beautiful local gift shop and get the benefit of great food and service. I hope to do my Christmas shopping there and maybe a nice treat for myself. The coffee is excellent there, I love that they have lavender as a flavor and my favorite menu item is definitively the chocolate croissant!

Load More

Lighthouse Keeper's Pantry

173 Main St, Yarmouth, MA 02675
(774) 994-8295