Ordered a cake to be delivered on Saturday for a Birthday party. After delivery never happened I contacted the company and received zero response. Do not trust the delivery date it will never arrive on time.
Lyndsay steiner
Delivery of smith island original cake was delicious! Great for an at home celebration!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smith Island Bakery Chocolate Cake
Jean Brown
Picked up worker
Milan K.
Arrived as expected-truly a delicious cake-with free delivery it is definitely worth the price. Excellent product.
Wayde Jenkins
Great place. Order online!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smith Island Bakery Chocolate Cake
Cheyenne Reiman
Holy hell!! This had to be the absolute best cake I've ever eaten. A friend had several shipped to PA for a wedding, they were fabulous and everyone raved about them!
Scott Jessup
Not only a wonderfully delicious cake but a conversation piece too. Cake was moist easy to thaw for servicing and was a huge hit for our Easter Celebration. Had a little hiccup with shipping contacted customer service AFTER hours and received a reply back from the owner Brian within 5 minutes. Problem resolved and cake was on the table for Easter. Family has requested these cakes for our family holidays and I have no objections! Thank you for a unique and delicious offering to our holidays.
Gianna E.
Owner called me to explain the situation and resolved the issue thank god!!! There was a UPS issue and now the cake will be there tomorrow. Not for my moms birthday but I guess for Mother's Day.
Allie A.
We are a fan of the official state Maryland cake, and since we happened to be near by, we decided to stop in the physical bakery and see if we could bring a cake home to family and friends. Most of their business is online and shipped to order.Gotta say the $65 price tag for a small cake was just a tad out of my reach, so when we found out they didn't offer any slices, we had to walk away.Nice staff and the property looked clean and in great shape.
Joe Haupt
My niece in Iowa was delighted with the Smith Island cake sampler we just sent her for her birthday. We have sent the sampler to a number of family members, and it is always a big hit for special celebrations. The cakes always arrive as scheduled and in excellent condition.
Awesome 16th Birthday Celebration for my grandson thanks to Smith Island Baking Company ??? The ice cream is fabulous too. Excellent service, it was delivered right on time.
DeVanna Young
Highly Recommend! Fresh ingredients, and top notch customer service. The owner Brian is hands on and personally reached out regarding our order. If you are looking for an authentic Smith Island cake this is the place to go.
Kristin H.
Ordered two smaller cakes for Valentine's day. Order arrived on time and was well-packaged! Original chocolate smith island cake was delicious. Peanut butter cake was not my favorite - tasted very similar to a Tastykake Kandy Kake. Will be ordering another original cake soon!
Robert Lloyd III
I was expecting more of a storefront with cakes on the shelves to be showcased. It was just empty, but they had a glass window to actually show them making the cakes
Steph Gemini
I have heard of these cakes before back when it was just offered in the standard flavor yellow cake with chocolate icing. I'm one of the rare individuals that don't eat chocolate and that's why I never had one until now as I have discovered that the cakes now come in other varieties besides chocolate. Purchased the small vanilla buttercream cake recently for the first time and have to say it's pretty good. It arrived as promised and well packaged.
Ordered a cake to be delivered on Saturday for a Birthday party. After delivery never happened I contacted the company and received zero response. Do not trust the delivery date it will never arrive on time.
Delivery of smith island original cake was delicious! Great for an at home celebration!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smith Island Bakery Chocolate Cake
Picked up worker
Arrived as expected-truly a delicious cake-with free delivery it is definitely worth the price. Excellent product.
Great place. Order online!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smith Island Bakery Chocolate Cake
Holy hell!! This had to be the absolute best cake I've ever eaten. A friend had several shipped to PA for a wedding, they were fabulous and everyone raved about them!
Not only a wonderfully delicious cake but a conversation piece too. Cake was moist easy to thaw for servicing and was a huge hit for our Easter Celebration. Had a little hiccup with shipping contacted customer service AFTER hours and received a reply back from the owner Brian within 5 minutes. Problem resolved and cake was on the table for Easter. Family has requested these cakes for our family holidays and I have no objections! Thank you for a unique and delicious offering to our holidays.
Owner called me to explain the situation and resolved the issue thank god!!! There was a UPS issue and now the cake will be there tomorrow. Not for my moms birthday but I guess for Mother's Day.
We are a fan of the official state Maryland cake, and since we happened to be near by, we decided to stop in the physical bakery and see if we could bring a cake home to family and friends. Most of their business is online and shipped to order.Gotta say the $65 price tag for a small cake was just a tad out of my reach, so when we found out they didn't offer any slices, we had to walk away.Nice staff and the property looked clean and in great shape.
My niece in Iowa was delighted with the Smith Island cake sampler we just sent her for her birthday. We have sent the sampler to a number of family members, and it is always a big hit for special celebrations. The cakes always arrive as scheduled and in excellent condition.
Restaurantji Recommends
Awesome 16th Birthday Celebration for my grandson thanks to Smith Island Baking Company ??? The ice cream is fabulous too. Excellent service, it was delivered right on time.
Highly Recommend! Fresh ingredients, and top notch customer service. The owner Brian is hands on and personally reached out regarding our order. If you are looking for an authentic Smith Island cake this is the place to go.
Ordered two smaller cakes for Valentine's day. Order arrived on time and was well-packaged! Original chocolate smith island cake was delicious. Peanut butter cake was not my favorite - tasted very similar to a Tastykake Kandy Kake. Will be ordering another original cake soon!
I was expecting more of a storefront with cakes on the shelves to be showcased. It was just empty, but they had a glass window to actually show them making the cakes
I have heard of these cakes before back when it was just offered in the standard flavor yellow cake with chocolate icing. I'm one of the rare individuals that don't eat chocolate and that's why I never had one until now as I have discovered that the cakes now come in other varieties besides chocolate. Purchased the small vanilla buttercream cake recently for the first time and have to say it's pretty good. It arrived as promised and well packaged.