Judy Gibson Restaurant

171 Ocean St, South Portland
(207) 808-8649

Recent Reviews

PatrickPastor

From the moment you enter you feel welcome. “Doc & Lloyd” a delicious cocktail and inventive The scallops: quite simply, delicious and very surprising. The “Roast Duck”: the cooking was perfect, the taste exceptional. The “Grilled Swordfish”a presentation and taste worthy of a 5 star. The Dessert “Basil Mint Pudding” very surprising in taste, a delight, a very beautiful revelation!! Stéphanie was adorable, the chef very friendly, a whole wonderful team. Can't wait to come back!!

Patrick Buchanan

Been here about 10 times; it’s never been less than great. Worth a drive. They are cooking some of my favorite food in all of New England. Come hungry, order the menu, live it up. Top tier spot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sean Joy

I have been here many times and this place is amazing. I recommend ordering a bunch of the small plates so you can enjoy different dishes.

Sarah Conly

Terrific food, and good for vegetarians, pescatarians, and carnivores. Excellent service, as well.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brett Banhazl

First time there depsite living nearby. Lovely elevated atmosphere that doesn't feel stuffy or intense. All about good vibes & good food.Everything we ate was delicious, but the Chicken Liver Toast & Brocollini were some of the best dishes we've ever had. The menu changes often so we'll be sad when those leave, but we can't wait to keep coming back and trying new things!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Liver Mousse

jesse thomas

Our favorite restaurant in the Portland area. Reliably excellent and adventurous dishes with flavors that sing to the palette. Truly underrated, far more than the fried chicken that carried them through the pandemic, Chef Chris is at the top of his art. The service is great, the drinks are fantastic… gotta love a good Gibson. It should be impossible to get a table here but somehow there’s always a great seat.

Ali Rowe

Such a great spot with fantastic food. The gnocchi was out of this world delicious. Great date night spot, with food cocktails.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Daisy Wilson

Fool me once... we tried to enjoy this neighborhood restaurant but have been disappointed by the quality and value of each meal we've had, so no going back for us. At our most recent visit, I ordered blistered carrots with ricotta and lavender. The lavender was the main draw, but I couldn't taste it at all. I asked the server about this and her response was that the carrots were initially boiled with lavender, but that the taste was subtle because not everybody likes lavender. Why you would feature an ingredient on the menu and then hide the flavor of it makes no sense to me.That's just the tip of the food disappointment ice berg - the flavors are either way too complex or completely lacking. Sorry, won't be back.

Bostontravels

We've been here 8 or 10 times now and are always happy. They rotate their menu frequently so it's fun to visit frequently. Had an amazing pork chop the other night as well as one of the best chicken liver mousses I've ever tried.

Lucky Strike

Hit or miss. Gizmo vs stripeUpdate: Decided to try again. Cocktails are as unbalanced as a person trying to use a see saw by themselves. I didn't even finish my drink it was so bad. Be wary of who your bar tender is...food is awesome though. Go for food and get drink at Cafe loise.

MONIQUE S

Excellent attention to every detail of this well appointed restaurant. We are Vegetarian and enjoyed sharing the cheeses, delicious gnocchi in a cloud of parm, a subtly blue cheesed salad and blistered cauliflower. We had very tasty cocktails and do be sure to save room for a dessert of delicious butterscotch delight. The service was impeccable and the chefs clearly know their assignment.

Tasia D.

Judy Gibson's New Year's Eve menu was nothing short of beautiful. Bright, confident flavors in every bite with the perfect cast of drinks alongside. The staff was far from disappointing. The chefs moved together flawlessly and the waitstaff worked as a team. One of South Portland's hidden gems, worth checking out.

Erna K.

We went here last week, and all of us were disappointed with the dishes we had. One remarkable element was that all vegetables and the beans were undercooked. Maybe this is the new fashion, but as one of us was recovering from digestive disease, she couldn't eat most of what was served. If the vegetables had been adequately cooked, the meal would probably have ranked with us as adequate. The steak was good. We won't return, because we couldn't eat much of the food, and at the price, it is not a good value for us.

Sarah M.

Hidden gem! Not sure how I JUST found out about this place. Food was incredible, might go as far to say it was better than Twelve...we will be back! Don't miss the gnocchi or the sweet breads.

Randy939

Wow impressive meal. Small plates and each one was incredibly tasty and amazing flavors and food combinations. Great cocktails also.

Load More